• Join, for peat' sake
    • or

    Most active reviewers

    1. ColoradoDram
    2. Colin
    3. Eye-lah Guy
    4. ChadDavis
    5. Saul

    Can't find what you're looking for? Suggest it!

    Reviews by: Anonymous

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay May 20th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    I’m not a knowledgeable Whiskey drinker. I’m also not picky and usually buy (and enjoy) the cheapest thing on the shelf, but this is the worst thing I’ve ever had. It tastes like something crawled in there and died! Disgusting. I’m going to pour this down the sink...

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay May 20th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    I’m not a knowledgeable Whiskey drinker. I’m also not picky and usually buy (and enjoy) the cheapest thing on the shelf, but this is the worst thing I’ve ever had. It tastes like something crawled in there and died! Disgusting. I’m going to pour this down the sink...

    The Macallan Cask Strength

    The Macallan Cask Strength May 18th 2012

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label May 18th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    nice deep warm gold
    Nose
    very nice nose i smell peat vanilla and caramel
    Body
    nice long legs very powerfull whisky
    Palate
    very powerfull and peat smoke tast i take a little pure dark chocolate and the tast change a lot very exciting
    Finish
    long finish keep staying in your mouth for a long time and when its go down you feel it in your stomage

    very nice whisky lot of people don't like it only for mixing its not true this whisky keep on standing to all the years

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old May 18th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label May 18th 2012

    52
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Honey
    Nose
    Oil
    Body
    Watery
    Palate
    Eagle Brand
    Finish
    Warm

    Tasted like medicinal oil

    Jameson

    Jameson May 17th 2012

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Medium gold
    Nose
    Sweet, caramel, slight smoke, fruit, weak.
    Body
    Smooth as silk, but takes a long time to hit any flavor.
    Palate
    slight smoke, cream, light earthy notes.
    Finish
    clean finish, not oily, without water- long and warm, with water- long and mild with a slight tingle on the tongue.

    Just purchased this whiskey for the first time. Added a touch of water and by the end of the first glass i felt my money was not wasted.

    The Macallan 12 Years Old

    The Macallan 12 Years Old May 16th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Welcome to the Dark Side
    Nose
    Blossoms of spring with a heavy Sherry influence
    Body
    Medium body but smooth
    Palate
    Oaked & a little sweet, but pleasantly fruity
    Finish
    Smooth and warm with a lingering aftertaste that invites another taste

    I'm giving this a 90 mainly because it tastes much better than most other 12 year olds. Normally I don't care for the sweet drinks, but this had a way of growing on me.

    Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select

    Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select May 14th 2012

    73
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale Amber
    Nose
    Fruity, Spicy, Floral Notes, Vague Citrus
    Body
    Medium Bodied
    Palate
    Fruity, Spicy, there is real flavor here.
    Finish
    Smooth finish that lingers just enough.

    This is a better Bourbon, I prefer it to Makers Mark.

    Jack Daniel's Old no7

    Jack Daniel's Old No7 May 14th 2012

    66
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark Copper
    Nose
    Oakie, Maple, Vanilla, Alcohol
    Body
    Medium Body
    Palate
    Sweet, similar to the nose
    Finish
    Medium finish, Harsh

    Works great with Coke. Not to be drank neat, works well enough on the rocks. This whiskey benefits from Banding & reputation. For the same price you could buy a bottle & Jameson & be much more satisfied.

    Royal Lochnagar 12

    Royal Lochnagar 12 May 14th 2012

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Darker amber or honey.
    Nose
    Peaty, rye-ish, caramel and honey.
    Body
    Full bodied.
    Palate
    Rich honey and caramel.
    Finish
    Long finish.

    This is quite simply my favorite Single Malt. What a pity that is practically impossible to find in the USA. I can only enjoy it when I go to Europe, where it is fairly common---at least in Germany (available in most grocery sections of the big department stores). This is a superb Single Malt. I would rate it higher than all others.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old May 13th 2012

    77
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    walnut
    Nose
    Ashtray, heavy smoke
    Body
    thick and consistent
    Palate
    Strange balance of smoke and mainstream Scotch whiskey
    Finish
    Sweetness prevails

    It taste like Johnny Walker Black mixed with cigar ashes, no peat, no resemblance with Laphroaig at all. Balance of flavors is very strange. Grossly overpriced.The 16 years maturation is probably the reason for the price.

    Macallan 1979

    Macallan 1979 May 11th 2012

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    dark mahagony
    Nose
    orange, ginger, cinamon, fruits
    Body
    very full bodied. extremely oily around the glass, extremely flavourful
    Palate
    no peat, little to no smoke, fruits, slight cinamon, slight sugar
    Finish
    Extra long fruity finish with slight tingle.

    quite simply the best to date. pricy at 500, but well worth it.

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old May 11th 2012

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light honey
    Nose
    Subtle fruit
    Body
    watery
    Palate
    sweet and fruity
    Finish
    short,diverse and satisfying

    Great blend

    The Macallan 12 Years Old

    The Macallan 12 Years Old May 10th 2012

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark golden brown
    Nose
    Woody with a hint of honey.
    Body
    Full body
    Palate
    Fruity turning cold to a refreshing oak
    Finish
    A finish that you don't know is over. Very warm

    23 yrs old, first time scotch drinker. I would recommend this to someone who would like to start.

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old May 9th 2012

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Very Subtle w/a hint of sweetness
    Body
    Perfect
    Palate
    Very sweet, fruity, well mannered, quite enjoyable.
    Finish
    Smooth & warm as it should be.

    One of my favorites along w/Johnny Walker Black label.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old May 8th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Smoke, peat - did I mention the smoke and peat.
    Body
    Surprisingly smooth.
    Palate
    Salt from an old sailors best boot mixed with the stub of a fine Havana cigar.
    Finish
    Long and strong. Wanting more.

    "What have I done", was the thought when I tasted it. I had bought a litre bottle on the way out of the country. I decided to show the wife what a great scotch tasted like after we landed. Yikes. But after getting home with my 1 litre baby, I am hooked.

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old May 6th 2012

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    beach sunset
    Nose
    Oranges, honey, slight peat medium smoke.
    Body
    Full and rich
    Palate
    Tackled by a force of sweet perfection. Instantly sweet then a touch of smoke and peat.
    Finish
    Long and smooth. Leaves a clean sweet and Smokey finish.

    Quite simply the best tasting whiskey for the money. My cabinet will always have a back up.

    The Macallan 12 Years Old

    The Macallan 12 Years Old May 6th 2012

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    I'm not very well versed on color but a nice golden color to
    Nose
    Fresh fruity smell. Very pleasant smell.
    Body
    Smooth not heavy. Light in the mouth
    Palate
    Fruit salad. Fresh air.
    Finish
    Not overly strong. Short spice. Nice spicy tingle on the lips. Not like an alcohol bite but more a spicy fruit if there were such a thing

    New to single malts but this was very enjoyable. A little spicy but not overwhelming. A fresh after taste and light in the mouth. I'm no seasoned pro but I would definitely purchase again. A little sweet, very easy to drink. Almost like a strong wine. I voted the average number bc I have not had many single malts. Def would recommend to someone wanting to try scotch the way it's supposed to be. Great pair with a light body or after dinner cigar.

    Rebel Yell Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Rebel Yell Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey May 4th 2012

    55
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber
    Nose
    Antiseptic
    Body
    Astringent
    Palate
    A glassful of water and pennies
    Finish
    Short and to the point

    Honestly, this is rot-gut whiskey. It burned my mouth out and ate away my stomach lining... seriously.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old May 1st 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark gold
    Nose
    Floral, Tar, Peat, Iodine, Barley Sweetness, Smoke
    Body
    Velvety and substantial.
    Palate
    Rich tarry sweetness; big hospital and peat in the development.
    Finish
    Long sweet and floral.

    This is the one I give to people who have never tried Islay whisky.

    Knob Creek

    Knob Creek Apr 28th 2012

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark amber
    Nose
    Good saddle leather and wood smoke
    Body
    Rich full body
    Palate
    Nutshells sweet bitter
    Finish
    Full long finish. Warm tingly burn

    Makes a great manhattan

    The Macallan Fine Oak 15 Years Old

    The Macallan Fine Oak 15 Years Old Apr 28th 2012

    60
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    Very average. Weak nose and average palate. If I were drinking it blindfolded, I'd have trouble distinguishing it from a Glenlivet 12. Gives the impression of a whisky that should have been left alone to age longer. I've had my first and last bottle.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Apr 28th 2012

    96
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Smoke
    Body
    Full
    Palate
    Peaty
    Finish
    Long
    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength Apr 27th 2012

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    honey or dark golden
    Nose
    Peat, Black pepper, band-aids, tar oil, fresh laid tar, fresh laid asphalt.
    Body
    This numbs whatever it touches. Thick!
    Palate
    Wasabi, Tabasco, menthol, Call 911!
    Finish
    North Atlantic storm of salt. Then one is sweetly romanced back to ones home.

    Only a fool would not add water to this. How much water? We never did find the sweet spot.

    Bowmore Tempest

    Bowmore Tempest Apr 26th 2012

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark caramel
    Nose
    Wet Cardboard, smoke, toffee and peat
    Body
    Full and balanced, gorgeous mouth feel
    Palate
    Lovely peat and smoke with wood, sea air and hints of caramel
    Finish
    Almost a perfect balance, fades away like a sunset

    Tempest is a gorgeous color, and is a real treat for the senses. From a rich and complex nose to a smooth finish, the overwhelming characteristic of this whiskey for me is balance in texture, taste and experience. And it does all that without compromising a strong peaty Islay character.

    Teacher's HIghland Cream

    Teacher's HIghland Cream Apr 25th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    JWLELUVZBmXQQdCBFva
    Nose
    I have a question.What Is the Clevenger E. G. Booz Old Cabin Bottle worth? Is The Clevenger one a rtcioduperon?I have one of these bottles its light Amber in color has the beveled cornors on roof. Has all the wording where it should be.To me its hard to tell the real one from a fake.
    Body
    I have a question.What Is the Clevenger E. G. Booz Old Cabin Bottle worth? Is The Clevenger one a rtcioduperon?I have one of these bottles its light Amber in color has the beveled cornors on roof. Has all the wording where it should be.To me its hard to tell the real one from a fake.
    Palate
    I have a question.What Is the Clevenger E. G. Booz Old Cabin Bottle worth? Is The Clevenger one a rtcioduperon?I have one of these bottles its light Amber in color has the beveled cornors on roof. Has all the wording where it should be.To me its hard to tell the real one from a fake.
    Finish
    I have a question.What Is the Clevenger E. G. Booz Old Cabin Bottle worth? Is The Clevenger one a rtcioduperon?I have one of these bottles its light Amber in color has the beveled cornors on roof. Has all the wording where it should be.To me its hard to tell the real one from a fake.

    I have a question.What Is the Clevenger E. G. Booz Old Cabin Bottle worth? Is The Clevenger one a rtcioduperon?I have one of these bottles its light Amber in color has the beveled cornors on roof. Has all the wording where it should be.To me its hard to tell the real one from a fake.

    Talisker Distiller's Edition

    Talisker Distiller's Edition Apr 25th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    bASBIORHBGtmfDxwv
    Nose
    most Canadian provinces will soon be out of these bnards of scotch as Diageo, the world's largest spirit supplier, is redirecting its products to more profitable markets in China, Russia and India.Mutha uckas!Scotch enthusiasts who favoured some of the discontinued bnards may be upset, but NB Liquor said the new bottles should help satisfy the average drinker.Right.I'll have to talk to the guys at my local liquor store. I might have to stock up. This blows.
    Body
    most Canadian provinces will soon be out of these bnards of scotch as Diageo, the world's largest spirit supplier, is redirecting its products to more profitable markets in China, Russia and India.Mutha uckas!Scotch enthusiasts who favoured some of the discontinued bnards may be upset, but NB Liquor said the new bottles should help satisfy the average drinker.Right.I'll have to talk to the guys at my local liquor store. I might have to stock up. This blows.
    Palate
    most Canadian provinces will soon be out of these bnards of scotch as Diageo, the world's largest spirit supplier, is redirecting its products to more profitable markets in China, Russia and India.Mutha uckas!Scotch enthusiasts who favoured some of the discontinued bnards may be upset, but NB Liquor said the new bottles should help satisfy the average drinker.Right.I'll have to talk to the guys at my local liquor store. I might have to stock up. This blows.
    Finish
    most Canadian provinces will soon be out of these bnards of scotch as Diageo, the world's largest spirit supplier, is redirecting its products to more profitable markets in China, Russia and India.Mutha uckas!Scotch enthusiasts who favoured some of the discontinued bnards may be upset, but NB Liquor said the new bottles should help satisfy the average drinker.Right.I'll have to talk to the guys at my local liquor store. I might have to stock up. This blows.

    most Canadian provinces will soon be out of these bnards of scotch as Diageo, the world's largest spirit supplier, is redirecting its products to more profitable markets in China, Russia and India.Mutha uckas!Scotch enthusiasts who favoured some of the discontinued bnards may be upset, but NB Liquor said the new bottles should help satisfy the average drinker.Right.I'll have to talk to the guys at my local liquor store. I might have to stock up. This blows.

    Blanton's The Original Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey

    Blanton's The Original Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey Apr 25th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    GZmiDgheZcq
    Nose
    Nancy,It seems like the Clevenger reproductions at least the aattrctive hand blown examples in amber tend to sell in the $100 to $250 range. Occasionally, they will fetch more. Yes, the Clevenger examples are fairly accurate reproductions of the original 19th century bottles blown at Whitney Glassworks in New Jersey.Discerning the originals from the reproductions can sometimes be quite difficult. In some cases, the differences come down to subtle variations in the embossing. A more obvious difference is the bevel on the gables of the roof. If the bevel cuts into the second row of shingles, then it is without question a reproduction.
    Body
    Nancy,It seems like the Clevenger reproductions at least the aattrctive hand blown examples in amber tend to sell in the $100 to $250 range. Occasionally, they will fetch more. Yes, the Clevenger examples are fairly accurate reproductions of the original 19th century bottles blown at Whitney Glassworks in New Jersey.Discerning the originals from the reproductions can sometimes be quite difficult. In some cases, the differences come down to subtle variations in the embossing. A more obvious difference is the bevel on the gables of the roof. If the bevel cuts into the second row of shingles, then it is without question a reproduction.
    Palate
    Nancy,It seems like the Clevenger reproductions at least the aattrctive hand blown examples in amber tend to sell in the $100 to $250 range. Occasionally, they will fetch more. Yes, the Clevenger examples are fairly accurate reproductions of the original 19th century bottles blown at Whitney Glassworks in New Jersey.Discerning the originals from the reproductions can sometimes be quite difficult. In some cases, the differences come down to subtle variations in the embossing. A more obvious difference is the bevel on the gables of the roof. If the bevel cuts into the second row of shingles, then it is without question a reproduction.
    Finish
    Nancy,It seems like the Clevenger reproductions at least the aattrctive hand blown examples in amber tend to sell in the $100 to $250 range. Occasionally, they will fetch more. Yes, the Clevenger examples are fairly accurate reproductions of the original 19th century bottles blown at Whitney Glassworks in New Jersey.Discerning the originals from the reproductions can sometimes be quite difficult. In some cases, the differences come down to subtle variations in the embossing. A more obvious difference is the bevel on the gables of the roof. If the bevel cuts into the second row of shingles, then it is without question a reproduction.

    Nancy,It seems like the Clevenger reproductions at least the aattrctive hand blown examples in amber tend to sell in the $100 to $250 range. Occasionally, they will fetch more. Yes, the Clevenger examples are fairly accurate reproductions of the original 19th century bottles blown at Whitney Glassworks in New Jersey.Discerning the originals from the reproductions can sometimes be quite difficult. In some cases, the differences come down to subtle variations in the embossing. A more obvious difference is the bevel on the gables of the roof. If the bevel cuts into the second row of shingles, then it is without question a reproduction.

    Wiser's De Luxe

    Wiser's De Luxe Apr 25th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    GHZgFAExPazBZsw
    Nose
    Sacrilege. If you're going to burn booze for fuel, use something oboiunoxs, like gin.What's next, someone use bacon for something other than eating?
    Body
    Sacrilege. If you're going to burn booze for fuel, use something oboiunoxs, like gin.What's next, someone use bacon for something other than eating?
    Palate
    Sacrilege. If you're going to burn booze for fuel, use something oboiunoxs, like gin.What's next, someone use bacon for something other than eating?
    Finish
    Sacrilege. If you're going to burn booze for fuel, use something oboiunoxs, like gin.What's next, someone use bacon for something other than eating?

    Sacrilege. If you're going to burn booze for fuel, use something oboiunoxs, like gin.What's next, someone use bacon for something other than eating?

    Distiller's Edition 15 years old

    Distiller's Edition 15 Years Old Apr 25th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    LKgHtcrmaIHwVGN
    Nose
    Bunnahabhain(good luck on trying to prounonce it) is actually one of my favorites and the 18 yr old bottle is what I served at the head table in my wedding. I hope to make it over to their distillery this year. Thanks for the wonderful update. It is always a pleasure to read.
    Body
    Bunnahabhain(good luck on trying to prounonce it) is actually one of my favorites and the 18 yr old bottle is what I served at the head table in my wedding. I hope to make it over to their distillery this year. Thanks for the wonderful update. It is always a pleasure to read.
    Palate
    Bunnahabhain(good luck on trying to prounonce it) is actually one of my favorites and the 18 yr old bottle is what I served at the head table in my wedding. I hope to make it over to their distillery this year. Thanks for the wonderful update. It is always a pleasure to read.
    Finish
    Bunnahabhain(good luck on trying to prounonce it) is actually one of my favorites and the 18 yr old bottle is what I served at the head table in my wedding. I hope to make it over to their distillery this year. Thanks for the wonderful update. It is always a pleasure to read.

    Bunnahabhain(good luck on trying to prounonce it) is actually one of my favorites and the 18 yr old bottle is what I served at the head table in my wedding. I hope to make it over to their distillery this year. Thanks for the wonderful update. It is always a pleasure to read.

    Jameson 12 Year Old

    Jameson 12 Year Old Apr 23rd 2012

    84
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold
    Nose
    Peat, orange peels, pineapple, oak.
    Body
    full bodied.
    Palate
    walnut, oak, citrus.
    Finish
    warm and light.

    Who said...Only the scots make good whiskeys, This is one to remember.

    Jim Beam Black Sour Mash Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Jim Beam Black Sour Mash Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Apr 23rd 2012

    77
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark Tan
    Nose
    Smoke with a punch of citrus and pineapple, not to mention the oak.
    Body
    Oily, light weight, has good legs.
    Palate
    pepper, rock salt, citrus.
    Finish
    Strong and warm, long lingering taste in the mouth.

    A good alternative to blended scotch and irish whiskeys. Has a goodcolor and a taste which lingers around in a strong, masculine way.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Apr 20th 2012

    96
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Straw Amber
    Nose
    Heinous, smoky, band-aid...hospital.
    Body
    Pleasant, non-syrupy.
    Palate
    An old fireplace. Barley malt mash. A palmetto forest fire just after a light Florida afternoon rainstorm.
    Finish
    Clean and calming. My wife says she can smell the smoke on my breath 2-3 hours later.

    Glorious. I dont know why, but I'm drawn to the smokiness and smoothness. I drink over crushed ice. Te more it melts, the better it tastes.

    Glenfiddich Solera Reserve 15 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Solera Reserve 15 Years Old Apr 18th 2012

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Caramel or medium dark honey
    Nose
    Dried fruits, honey, tinge of smoke, vanilla oak although not as pronounced as the 12yr old.
    Body
    Medium. More legs than the 12yr although very dry edge to it.
    Palate
    Mostly dried fruit characteristics however interrupted too quickly by the dry Finnish
    Finish
    A little disappointing. It lingers but only the less appealing flavors of charred wood and spice.

    It's an interesting alternative to the 12 but for my money not as good. I expected the sweeter flavors to resonate more. Worth a try but I'll be going back to Highland Park as my mid priced standard.

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Apr 13th 2012

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Clover honey
    Nose
    Carmel, orange chocolate truffle, a hint of peat
    Body
    Medium body
    Palate
    Orange, citrus, carmel, peat, sweet, leather. Best without water, IMO.
    Finish
    Nice finish, not too long or too short. The peat becomes much more pronounced at the end.
    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old Apr 6th 2012

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Straw
    Nose
    Light nose, Summer Fruit, Grass, Slightly Vegetal.
    Body
    Medium
    Palate
    Apple, Shortbread, Slight Ginger, Slightly Sweet, A little Ethanol Bitter, Oily.
    Finish
    A little young, but not offensive, tinge hot, nice medium finish.

    Very good intro scotch. It's light fruity taste and short finish definitely add to it's easy drinkability. Slightly oily and a little young, it's easy going down with a slight hot candy mouthfeel. Anytime of the day dram.

    Red Breast 12 Year Old

    Red Breast 12 Year Old Apr 5th 2012

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden wheat grass
    Nose
    hollow hazelnut
    Body
    full smooth and buttery
    Palate
    hazelnutty
    Finish
    a feather slowly tickling the tongue and throat

    a sweet, smooth, buttery, hazelnut taste that rolls off the tongue with tiny electric shocks

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Apr 5th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light brown
    Nose
    Unwatered : Sharply salty! Iodine, with some smoke. Watered : More iodine, 1950s hospital, but peatier and woodier underneath. Reminds me of a foggy night in the country in Ireland, where turf is burned as fuel.
    Body
    Wet, but not too oily
    Palate
    Burning turf (peat), more iodinic than Ardbeg but not so much as Talisker. A little sweeter when watered - aged toffee/sweets perhaps?
    Finish
    Watered : Burning turf smoke (peat), warm in the chest with aged wood. Iodine is there, but lesser than the palate & nose. Saltier, less 'muted' finish when neat.

    Sharp nose unwatered, very salty - with water it mellows. Finish is very salty neat, and smokier/muted when watered. Unsure of which I like best! Two whiskys...one bottle!

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Apr 5th 2012

    72
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Perfect Amber
    Nose
    Nothing really but a faint smoke.
    Body
    Oily and thick, coats the tongue.
    Palate
    Definite smoke, but not much else. Unlike cheap Islay I've had where it's huge smoke and then a nasty, alchol taste this is just smoke.
    Finish
    The smoke is still there, and you don't feel the liquor the way you do with some others. Entirely too smooth for my taste. If I wanted an Irish whiskey I'd have bought one.

    You know, I can understand why people like it but I don't care for it. Too smooth for my tastes, I like my scotch with a more kick.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Apr 4th 2012

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Rich amber with dark tones
    Nose
    very earthy with unique peat that first overwhelms then sooths the palate lasting a long time
    Body
    full body
    Palate
    smokey aroma followed by a slaty peat that turns to a long lasting pepper taste that stays with the palate
    Finish
    long tangy finsh that is somewhat hot

    Absolutely the best gentlemans scoth on the market. must be taken with a heavy cigar and one ice cube to release the maximum flavor. Enhances the flavor of a grilled steak or great cigar.

    Glenfiddich Special Reserve 12 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Special Reserve 12 Years Old Apr 4th 2012

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber
    Nose
    Very sweet and fruity. Pears, apples, orange peel and vanilla.
    Body
    Gentle and floral. Eases you in as opposed to a punch in the face.
    Palate
    Matches the nose nicely. Mostly sweet notes and the oak is very well integrated but doesn't dominate.
    Finish
    Medium. Carries through for a bit then the oak tannins take over to cleans the palate.

    Don't listen to the malt snobs. There's a reason this is the number one selling malt in the world. It's just an excellent value. A fine expression of Speyside as you'll find without breaking the bank. What's not to like?

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Apr 4th 2012

    58
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale
    Nose
    Peat
    Body
    Thin
    Palate
    Bilious, vile and bitter aftertaste
    Finish
    Latest batches are awful and Diageo customer service is worse. Avoid bottles in the new boxes with orange RNLI campaign. Previous batches were vastly superior.

    WARNING! Latest batches are terrible!

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Apr 3rd 2012

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber honey
    Nose
    sweet malt, honey, vanilla
    Body
    smooth and mellow all the way, creamy texture, cinnamon warmth of the finish that lingers for a while on the palate
    Palate
    the sherry plays a nice role mingled with honey, vanilla, touch of oak, brown spice (I can see the cinnamon), when I leave it on the palate and swirl it around I do get cinnamon – it reminds me of cinnamon toothpick
    Finish
    cinnamon warmth of the finish that lingers for a while on the palate
    Bowmore 12 Year Old

    Bowmore 12 Year Old Apr 2nd 2012

    79
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light billy bee honey
    Nose
    Very sweet and you can't miss the peat although not as pronouced as other Islays. Apple, pear and caramel vanilla notes
    Body
    Somewhat creamy at first but very brief.
    Palate
    mild sea salt, toffee and dark chocolate notes then followed by an earthyness almost dirt like quality.
    Finish
    Rather abruptly. There's a slightly bitter, earthy, peppery tanic finnish to this that I can't decide if I like or not. Comes on a little too early for my liking.

    This is my second review of this whiskey. Subsequent tastings have revealed an underlying earthyness on the palate I didn't detect initially. A little schizophrenic in my opinion. Starts sweet and creamy and ends dry and peppery. Still an interesting weekday dram for the price.

    Red Breast 12 Year Old

    Red Breast 12 Year Old Mar 31st 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Maplewood
    Nose
    Chocolaty and spicy, with a faint hint of banana.
    Body
    Slightly oily. It will leave a thin film on your palate.
    Palate
    Spicy, nutty, and woody.
    Finish
    Warm finish which pleasantly mellows into a nutty aftertaste.

    This is fantastic whiskey, and the best value in the $50 USD or less range. I like to drink it in a brandy snifter myself. If you are thinking of trying this one, please do, you will not regret it.

    Midleton Very Rare

    Midleton Very Rare Mar 30th 2012

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Old gold
    Nose
    Complex, slightly fruity and pepper.
    Body
    Full bodied
    Palate
    Mango, passion fruit, cassis, currants, cinnamon
    Finish
    Lingers long and warm

    One of the best for me.

    Rebel Yell Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Rebel Yell Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Mar 26th 2012

    72
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    straw yellow light amber
    Nose
    Aldehyde vanilla
    Body
    full bodied
    Palate
    copper tin wheat corn flakes
    Finish
    tingles down the hatch

    honey colour light amber

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Mar 26th 2012

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    vanilla, classic peatiness, oh so sophisticated and pungent at the same time. glorius!
    Body
    oily oily oily, thick and gracious. beautiful.
    Palate
    vanilla, peat, medicinal something or other and citrus. oh so classy!
    Finish
    way longer than me

    p.s. i'm giving it a 99 to offset the mental midget who gave it a 50 (3 times)

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Mar 26th 2012

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    solid gold!
    Nose
    different each time. peat, some fresh bandages, and i swear i smell the coconut but can't taste it. i could do this 10 times and come up with 10 different answers.?!
    Body
    haha i'm on my 3rd glass. there will be a 4th. medium body eh, a bit oily. good heavens this is nice. i'm an american typing with a scottish accent hehe!
    Palate
    geez us i'm not worthy. bacon, campfire, smoked salmon with some kind of dijon mustard in the background, yeah this bugger says pour another dram. a bit salty, this dram deserves a proper name, like sailor mike. i likes women.
    Finish
    long. and i mean like a longshoreman after a 6 month voyage. this is a conservative 93. by the way, i doubt this post will see the light of day but that's me.

    yeah alright, so this is about my 10th review and i still haven't registered a username. i love islays! the QC is no exception. loves me some lag 16 and the ardbeg uiggeadail. i recently tried the talisker 10 after a glorious meal at a brazillian steakhouse and it was heaven. this QC has got to be in my top 5. homeslice will be buying it again, and again...as they say.

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old Mar 25th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    Nose is very clean with a complex fruit signature; pricot, pear, peach, apple, pinapple. Lightly peated, with a sweet salty note lurking around in there.
    Body
    Crisp and clean but big and full bodied.
    Palate
    Big sweet fruit and barley sugar arrival, salty seawater notes sprinkled in.
    Finish
    Long, sweet, super clean and refreshing.

    Possibly my new favorite? Biggest and most complex whisky I have found at this price point. Dont waste this one on beginners! They wont appreciate it, im glad I waited to try this one.

    The Balvenie Portwood 21 Year Old

    The Balvenie Portwood 21 Year Old Mar 25th 2012

    84
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber-honey
    Nose
    vanilla bean-bourbon, sweet grains, oak
    Body
    medium body, smooth, little oily or a slight syrup feel
    Palate
    lightly sweetened honey dipped candy fruit on the delivery (tip of the tongue), warm green peppercorn feel on the mid palate
    Finish
    nice finish, warm vanilla-bean oak aftertaste
    Laphroaig Triple Wood

    Laphroaig Triple Wood Mar 24th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Amber
    Nose
    Lovely nose - the level of smokiness in the palate is surprising based on the sherried nose.
    Body
    See Comment
    Palate
    See Comment
    Finish
    Nice long finish - to the best of my understanding BUT see Comment

    2. Admittedly this was the go-to scotch that pushed me over the edge and now nearly $2,000 poorer I have acquired a number of bottles of varying sorts often depending on the gentlemen who have blazed the path before me. I have typically found that when there are several review in the hi 80s and lo 90s, one can have pretty good confidence that they won’t be disappointed. 3. I will confirm that I don’t think you will be disappointed with this scotch BUT only on the condition that you drink it correctly – otherwise you will have simply another strong smokey Islay – albeit one with a lovely nose due to the sherry finish (I assume). 4. So what is it to “drink it correctly”?? I have taken to drinking my scotch in slowly my mouth formed as a straw and leaving it in the very front part of my mouth for sometime – slowly letting it move to the full first third of my tongue (or so – measurement precision not essential) and then finally after a tender affair, swallowing (no jokes at this point, please!). It is precisely this approach that has brought out so much of the sweet taste of scotch, corralled scotch as wild as A’bunadh and brought the meaning of Triple Wood to its full taste seemingly eliminating a significant amount of the smoky taste – which, while I appreciate some but not in the amount that is produced by a quick swig. I don’t understand why the taste would be so different with this approach BUT that has been my consistent experience.

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old Mar 23rd 2012

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden
    Nose
    Tantalizing with sweet and spicy undertones
    Body
    Light and smooth
    Palate
    Sweet, smooth and fruity
    Finish
    Very nice lingering finish

    A Wonderful everyday dram

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Mar 16th 2012

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    smells like booze
    Palate
    Grey Flannel cologne
    Finish
    long

    This consistently tastes like Grey Flannel cologne to me.

    Cardhu 12 Year Old

    Cardhu 12 Year Old Mar 15th 2012

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber . Almost golden
    Nose
    Light smoke, citrus
    Body
    smooth
    Finish
    warm with a good finish

    Very enjoyable. Great for casual drinking. One of the best for its price.

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Mar 12th 2012

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber/Gold
    Nose
    Heavy hospital smell...
    Body
    Medium probably...
    Palate
    Lots of sea salt, oysters, peat, phenol
    Finish
    Medium with sharp resonant peak in the begining.Very,very peppery...

    Impossible to drink my 20ml first time Talisker. Not very pleasant hospital smell on the nose that covers anything else that might be there. Lots of sea salt and pepper on the tongue,razor sharp overwhelming and toatlly unbalanced. Reminded me of Balantine's. Even more pepper for finish. Opposite of smooth. What am I going to do with the rest 730ml left in the bottle? Highland Park blows this one out of the water any day!

    The Macallan 12 Years Old

    The Macallan 12 Years Old Mar 9th 2012

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Charred Gold
    Nose
    Woody, Very Light Smoke, Flowery with a hint of honeysuckle
    Body
    Medium, smooth, good viscosity
    Palate
    Walnuts, Orange peels, honeysuckle, vanilla, a wee bit of smoke
    Finish
    Decent finish length, dies out toward the end. Bit of a slow, warm spice but not overbearing in the slightest.

    When compared with other 12 years, The Macallan makes for a great drink. It is well worth every penny and doesn't fail to excite the palate.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Mar 9th 2012

    94
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    heavy smoke, hospital smell
    Body
    thick
    Palate
    Iodine and peat
    Finish
    definately a very long finish

    Classy and Refined. Definately intend to keep a bottle in my collection

    Ezra Brooks Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Ezra Brooks Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Mar 8th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    mid amber
    Nose
    alcohol, oak smoke, slightly sweet
    Body
    Mild body, light after taste
    Palate
    oak smoke, slightly peaty, vanilla
    Finish
    moderate duration.cool, vanilla and oak continues.

    Having compaired numerous Burbons, I can say without second thought, that Ezara Brooks ranks with the best. I like it.

    Lagavulin 12 Year Old Natural Cask Strength

    Lagavulin 12 Year Old Natural Cask Strength Mar 5th 2012

    60
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Almost clear.
    Nose
    light citrus. lacks peat and smoke.
    Body
    light with high alcohol.
    Palate
    very light version of the 16. lacking in flavor by comparison.
    Finish
    toned down version of the 16.

    Lacks color and flavor. Needs a few more years in the wood.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength Mar 2nd 2012

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale gold
    Nose
    heavy smoke, sweet tangy smell. trademark laphroaig but so much more dense and in your face.
    Body
    oily, stays on the palate.
    Palate
    salt, iodine, sweetness, peat. as i said, trademark laphroaig, but on steroids.
    Finish
    lingers for a while. basically if you have a sip of it, then a sip of water, it is essentially like taking two sips of laphroaig, if that makes sense.

    I was so happy to have found this bottle. It's a very affordable 10 yo cask strength. The flavor is super intense but you can drink it without water. It's not a harsh alcoholic flavor, it's just the regular laphroaig but so much more concentrated and intense. It's going from a regular IPA to a triple IPA. This and the quarter cask are my favorite whiskys. WOO!

    Sheep Dip Old Hebridean 1990

    Sheep Dip Old Hebridean 1990 Mar 1st 2012

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Old Gold
    Nose
    Rich, sweet Ardbeg peat smoke with molasses and leather and a hint of ash. Breathing in deeper, you'll discover a really fresh, lively zest underneath the smoke... orange and lime rind (more lime than orange), sea air and sharp aniseed. A real dichotomy of aged earthiness and sprightly youth. If it didn't taste so good, I could just breathe this in all day. Moving along...
    Body
    Thin, but full of flavor.
    Palate
    Slow graceful arrival--like the few old whiskies I've had. But in the later stages of the development there is a bit of a youthful suggestion on the tongue. I can't help but wonder if this is an effect of the new casks this blended malt was aged in after blending (I've read they age it for an additional 15 years, however the label only specifies "over a decade"). Quick and relatively subtle malt notes off the top. Evolution then to pipe tobacco, very mild mannered spice and bitter sea-salt chocolate.
    Finish
    Not as long as I usually like, but very nice nonetheless. Pipe tobacco sticks around but the chocolatey spice reveals hints of prunes and evolves to old, clean leather. It leaves with a soft, fresh, wet woodiness. Like a mossy wood stack after heavy downpour. Summary: This whisky left my glass much quicker than I wanted it to. As much because it is delicious as because it was a bit of an adventure trying to pick out the flavours. Just as I figured I had a flavour pegged, it would change or elude me... so I'd have to have another sip to rediscover or catch up to it again. Really wonderful stuff. And at this price point, an excellent value for someone wanting to broaden their "old whisky" experience without having to fork out a wallet-load of cash. Excellent!

    I'm going to preface this review by saying I haven't tasted a lot of old scotches--a handful, but not enough to claim any sort of extensive experience on this front. Of the three whiskies used in this malt blend (Ardbeg, Fettercairn, and Dalmore--respectively 25, 21 and 19 years) I have only tasted the Ardbeg, so I won't be able to tell you how each particular whisky contributes its characteristics to the overall blend. I will, however, be able to tell you this is a damned fine whisky. Moving along...

    Black Bottle Original Blend

    Black Bottle Original Blend Feb 29th 2012

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Straw
    Nose
    Most evident neat is actually a slightly honeyed malt. Gentle peat and smoke evident a bit behind it. Very slight iodine. Dry citrus there as well.
    Body
    Medium, somewhat heavy for a blend.
    Palate
    Laid-back but persistent peat, a hearty yet simultaneously restrained puff of cigar smoke, quality malt, some vague fruits, and...vanilla. Not surprisingly, Bunnahabhan is most evident in the taste, with Ardbeg and Caol Ila moments.
    Finish
    Not extreme, but somewhat long for a blend. Fading embers of peat fires and a bit of smoke. A n excellent introduction to Islay sensations for the newbie. Gentle enough to not intimidate, but manages to remain interesting and keeping the distinctly Islay-flavors strong enough to endeer. I can't help but keep considering this a simultaneously subtle, yet sporting some intensity, if I may without sounding I am waxing poetic for the sake of.

    One of the very top within the category of economy no-age-statement blended scotch (or even among any under $30 blend in general). A personal favorite blend of mine, alongside Teacher's, Islay Mist 8, and the Famous Grouse (with some water).

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old Feb 29th 2012

    76
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber. Slightly evident caramel, although not heavy enough to compromise flavor, I'd think.
    Nose
    Honey, speyside fruits, vanilla, sea air, and very restrained peat.
    Body
    Medium.
    Palate
    Vanilla, cinnamon, faint wood, and the slightest sensation of sea water. An ever so slight Highland tinge upon an otherwise Speyside-dominated dram.
    Finish
    Small hints of sherry smoke, peat, vanilla, and heather, me thinks.

    A solid economy blend. There are better, and for slightly cheaper, but a nice dependable taste of Speyside with some nicely done grain integration in the background. One of the few of the big sellers that is actually decent.

    Teacher's HIghland Cream

    Teacher's HIghland Cream Feb 29th 2012

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber plus one. A bit too much caramel. Am a bit forgiving, this being an economy blend.
    Nose
    Initially a North Highland style nose of sea air. Vanilla and slight peat enter the fold after a bit. Gets maltier (a nice rich malt, not the cheap kind many other inexpensive malts give)with some water.
    Body
    Relatively full-bodied for an inexpensive blend, nice coating mouthfeel.
    Palate
    The Ardmore shines through significantly here, and if you get a particularly good bottling, the core malt whiskies seem quite decent quality. What you get here is some Ardmore style peat and anise balanced with vanilla, fudge, and cinnamon tinged malt, and hints of Speyside sherry and dry fruits. Sea salt waves at you as well.
    Finish
    Nice and somewhat long by inexpensive blend standards. Fading embers of peat fires (gentle, but persistent), heather,

    Arguably the best in the category of economy, no-age-statement blends. Just goes to show how even in whisky, politics can hold beyond instrinsic quality (I allude to the fact that stuff like JWR, Dewar's, and J&B frequently win honors, while quality blends like Teacher's hardly ever anymore. Frankly, I do not respect standards that give high honors to extreme high-grain, cloying products conforming only to what gives sales. Thankfully blends like Teacher's still exist in some capacity.

    Bruichladdich Peat

    Bruichladdich Peat Feb 28th 2012

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber -2
    Nose
    Peat, Hay, Chocolate, Bacon, Leather, Tropical Fruit. Changes alot in the glass with time and water.
    Body
    Thick and creamy.
    Palate
    Soft earthy peat, mocha, a hint of pine, banana, pinapple
    Finish
    Long, sweet, and very smooth.

    No offense but the other reviews rated this malt far too low. This is one of the most complex scotches in its price range. Its worth twice what they charge, imho.

    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label Feb 28th 2012

    61
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber. A bit of caramel is in here, especially considering how young all of the whiskies in here probably are.
    Nose
    Alcohol, grain, slight smoke and peat.
    Body
    Light.
    Palate
    Grain sugar, a small dash of peat, a puff of smoke, and some cheap malt. Seems to get grainier with time.
    Finish
    Short whisp of malt, pepper, and slight peat.

    In the category of no-age statement, economy blended scotch, an okay blend. For a few bucks less, Teacher's and Black Bottle are superior buys, however.

    J & B Rare Blended Scotch Whisky

    J & B Rare Blended Scotch Whisky Feb 28th 2012

    65
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Straw
    Nose
    Lightly honeyed malt, slightly damp grass and a little sea air. Some graininess with a slight bit of alcohol apparent.
    Body
    Light bodied, for sure. I suspect this is a blend of no more than 20% malt content, possibly somewhat less. While grain whisky done right can be quite good, this is not like that.
    Palate
    Cheap malt, pencil shavings, wee peat, and the slighest hint of vanilla.
    Finish
    Short whisp of peat and offputting graphite.

    Something tells me decades ago it was Perhaps a solid blend, but with time, conformed to attempted mass appeal blend trends, opting for vague light flavor and sweetness over any kind of decent complexity or full flavor. While a highly mundane blend, at least it's not the worst I've had (that distinction would be reserved for Lauder's), and it has some brief enjoyable moments.

    George Dickel No. 12

    George Dickel No. 12 Feb 27th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    There are only two Tennessee whiskeys (not considering the variants of the two distillers). My opinion in a side by side taste test ... George Dickel's preferred. High score because there are only two of thses distinctive bourbons.

    Yamazaki 12 years old

    Yamazaki 12 Years Old Feb 26th 2012

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Gold
    Nose
    Warm honey, spicy fruits
    Body
    medium, slightly syrupy
    Palate
    Butter scotch, toffee, vanilla, orange marmalade, honey, fruits
    Finish
    Medium finish, warm.

    Lovely and complex, becoming a regular for me along with the 18yo. Best to let sit for a few minutes to let the flavors develop.

    Bruichladdich 10 Years Old

    Bruichladdich 10 Years Old Feb 26th 2012

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale and light.
    Nose
    Mild tones of fruit and subtle peaty undertones. Water makes the peat go away and the fruit come alive.
    Body
    Weak at first. Medium bodied at best.
    Palate
    Lightly pleated with long lived fruity sweetness. Add a little water and the sour apple will bring a smile to your face.
    Finish
    Short finish. Only downfall of this mostly fine scotch.

    An amazingly young and fruity scotch that everyone should try once. Not your usual Islay but well made with very distinguishable sour apple & pear flavor base.

    McClellands Lowland

    McClellands Lowland Feb 23rd 2012

    69
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Lightly Golden
    Nose
    Light and fruity, pear and apple with a short hint of white grape.
    Body
    Has a bite but zero complexity.
    Palate
    Very little peat, sweet yet shallow. Fruity in a bad way.
    Finish
    Short lived. No nibble after the bite. warm at times.

    Ok for the price. A single malt without the usual single malt qualities.

    Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky

    Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky Feb 23rd 2012

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    medium Amber syrup
    Nose
    Punch in the face whiskey
    Body
    Smooth
    Palate
    Rough
    Finish
    Thats a good swig

    Needs an aquired taste, but once you do, your hooked! This is a real whiskey.

    Isle Of Jura 21 Year Old

    Isle Of Jura 21 Year Old Feb 22nd 2012

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Medium/dark golden amber.
    Nose
    Earthy, dried orange, nutty/almond flavor, buttered honey, vanilla
    Body
    Full bodied - rich Strong arrival - deep/layered flavors - rich and full bodied - complex
    Palate
    Peat, cigar tobacco, baked honey, strong burnt oak
    Finish
    Very long finish with varied flavors coming through - smooth/gradual finish

    One of my top 5 favorites. Rich, complex, layered flavors, full bodied.

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old Feb 18th 2012

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber , like urine after taking b-6. (colour , not taste, never fear)
    Nose
    Alcohol-bite smell,but initial taste is sweet and dries centre of tongue pleasantly.
    Body
    Sweet, dry, warm and fuzzy.
    Palate
    Makes your tongue happy you spent the (reasonable) $$. Then your stomach says "Thank you , may I have another"
    Finish
    Ahhh. More please. A great single malt without smashing the kids piggy bank.

    My go-to regular scotch. Affordable and very palatable if you don't want to break the bank. I use my wife as my whisk(e)y gauge. She will sip this on occasion so. I know it's reasonably smooth.

    The Balvenie 14 Year Old Golden Cask

    The Balvenie 14 Year Old Golden Cask Feb 18th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    darker golden
    Nose
    Rum,cheap Johnny Walker. Not so special
    Body
    Thin,smooth
    Palate
    Very run of the mill whiskey taste.
    Finish
    Blah

    Not so great.

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Feb 18th 2012

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden caramel
    Nose
    warm honey,maple,light fruity backround.
    Body
    Thick and smooth
    Palate
    Honey,vanilla,very sweet
    Finish
    decent finish with a slight warming but not over powering.

    Very sweet

    Glen Moray 12 Years Old

    Glen Moray 12 Years Old Feb 18th 2012

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden
    Nose
    Sweet fruity and a hint of floral
    Body
    Tender and kind
    Palate
    If your looking for a cheek up of peet this is not for you
    Finish
    Mellow long lasting friendship with the palette

    An interesting single malt with a complex nose. A mild easy first taste with a pleasant lasting taste I prefered slightly chilled using stones not ice however pressed does release a softer side of a already soft spoken scotch. I was dry pleased to stumble upon it and will keep a bottle in my larder

    Jack Daniel's Old no7

    Jack Daniel's Old No7 Feb 17th 2012

    71
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light amber
    Nose
    full flavor
    Body
    medium body
    Finish
    strong to the end

    God Bless America

    Crown Royal

    Crown Royal Feb 17th 2012

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Nose
    smoky, doesn't agitate the nose, aroma is pleasant and complicated.
    Body
    full, long legs
    Palate
    great flavor,
    Finish
    great finish,no bite
    Jameson 18 Year Old

    Jameson 18 Year Old Feb 17th 2012

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden amber
    Nose
    less sharp then scotches we were tasting. More earthy
    Palate
    heaven in a glass
    Finish
    warm, long finish

    this is where it's at

    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve

    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve Feb 17th 2012

    72
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale
    Finish
    strong to the end

    pale... by comparison

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old Feb 17th 2012

    73
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden
    Finish
    smooth

    comparing this to Glenfiddich 12

    Glenfiddich 12 Year Old

    Glenfiddich 12 Year Old Feb 17th 2012

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    fruity
    Body
    light body,
    Finish
    mild finish
    Ballantine's Finest

    Ballantine's Finest Feb 16th 2012

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Brassy
    Nose
    Caramel notes, Buttery vanilla, Sharp spice, Grandad's garage.
    Body
    Dry, warm and round.
    Palate
    Caramel, spice, vanilla, smoked wood.
    Finish
    short and dry, licorice aftertaste.

    A nice blend for the price.

    Dalwhinnie 15 Years Old

    Dalwhinnie 15 Years Old Feb 10th 2012

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Gold
    Nose
    Citrus and heather
    Body
    Light and smooth
    Palate
    Oak, grass and a hint of smoke
    Finish
    light finish, pleasant, slight smoke

    Love this whiskey, smooth, slightly smokey

    Ballantine's Finest

    Ballantine's Finest Feb 7th 2012

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light golden
    Nose
    Somewhat mix of creme, pepper and wood smoke
    Body
    Thin
    Palate
    Different
    Finish
    Short finish

    Got as gift from a friend. Not sure whats the price here in India. If within 1500/- then it is indeed a drink which deserves to be open.

    Bowmore Legend

    Bowmore Legend Feb 7th 2012

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    darkened wheat
    Nose
    Light peat, and band aids. Something of a fruity scent I can't quite put my finger on.
    Body
    Not a lot going on here.
    Palate
    Band aids, sweet bandaids. Cotton candy mixed in. Peat hanging out in the background.
    Finish
    And this is where this scotch lacks. Not much finish really.

    This scotch is a wonderful value at $25.99. It's not a peat monster , but there is some going on here. Its not complex, but awesome value.

    Oban 14 Year Old

    Oban 14 Year Old Feb 4th 2012

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    medium amber, hint of gold
    Nose
    citrus, peach, rose, caramel
    Body
    medium light body. soft and smooth
    Palate
    peach, butter, caramel, orange
    Finish
    short finish. subtle but maintains character

    excellent

    Crown Royal

    Crown Royal Feb 4th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light carmel Color
    Nose
    Not a factor
    Body
    Outstanding
    Palate
    I just love the stuff. Let's don't get stupid
    Finish
    Not hot.....Very smooth.

    Just a very lovely import from Canada that tastes great. Very smooth.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength Feb 3rd 2012

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Sunset over wheat fields
    Nose
    Measured kick of peat, subtle smoke, a small peel of apple and the body shop you took your car to after that one accident you weren't expecting.
    Body
    Fills the tongue well and stays a few after swallow.
    Palate
    Tastes like the memory of your grandmothers soup cooking in an iron pot and your grandpa smoking his pipe in front of the hearth.
    Finish
    Finish is announced with trumpets, not violins.

    For those that enjoy good things.

    Talisker 18 Year Old

    Talisker 18 Year Old Feb 3rd 2012

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Copper
    Nose
    Smoke and fruit
    Body
    Medium full-bodied
    Palate
    Complex, taste of plums and fruit, pepper and smoke
    Finish
    Long finish, warm, peppery, fruity, and smoky

    This is truly great scotch. A complex, plummy taste, with smokiness that does not overwhelm the other flavors -- all this makes this scotch a real delight when you can find it.

    Bunnahabhain 12 Year Old

    Bunnahabhain 12 Year Old Feb 3rd 2012

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden amber
    Nose
    just a good scotch breath that makes me think of the distillers dream for a rich mild drink that would convey the sea air of the island and the clear cold spring water supply - no peat here and even though I love the peaty whiskeys, Bunnahabhain is perfect without it
    Body
    this has to be the quintessential rich but mild bodied whiskey that doesn't grow stale
    Palate
    you're drinking Scotch but it's smooth without being bland, the taste buds are fired but not killed - it verges on sweet without suggesting sugar and if you are poetic then you might hear/taste the sea and smell the surf it makes me feel that this American could be a real Scot rather than just a descendant
    Finish
    nice long finish of warmth and flavor fading away pleasantly and encouraging that next sip

    I was drawn to this whiskey by the sound of the gaelic name meaning something like Mouth of the River and found it to be a delightful drink - one that you could share with one of your none-scotch drinking friends without pulverizing his brain. I plan to always have a bottle in my small collection.

    The Macallan 12 Years Old

    The Macallan 12 Years Old Feb 3rd 2012

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    rich amber

    new at this review bit - so most of my wording for awhile will be rather tentative - but onward - at my wife's yearly get together, I tried The Macallan 12 year old, straight up at room temperatue. For my taste it was rather bland or unexciting although not medicinal. The bar man gave me a good three fingers and I sipped on it for an hour or so. Smooth enough that I had a small delight in drinking it but will not waste my money buying a bottle. (I tend to like peaty and what I think of as explosive openings so you may find the quiet of The Macallan to your liking)

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Feb 3rd 2012

    94
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    straw
    Nose
    Smokey, iodine, a a lot of salty ocean
    Body
    oily and rich
    Palate
    like eating a peat bog. but in a good way
    Finish
    the smoke stays with you for a long time after you finish

    My favorite whiskey out there. And One you can drink everyday

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Feb 1st 2012

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light fireweed honey
    Nose
    Smokey but subtle, touch of iodine, salty air, nutty like sunflower seeds with a hint of wildflower
    Body
    Oily which works great here
    Palate
    Initial sweetness gets washed away by malt and salty sea. Let it linger a bit longer and it shows you more earth but in a refined manner.l
    Finish
    Shorter but more memorable finish than the ten. Just enough heat neat. This is special!

    Was fortunate enough to try it side by side with the 10.

    The Macallan Fine Oak 10 Years Old

    The Macallan Fine Oak 10 Years Old Jan 31st 2012

    71
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale amber, not much e150a here.
    Nose
    Almonds, honey, slightly musty leather.
    Palate
    Arrival is a bit harsh. Some sweet honey notes, with dried fruit, with that musty overtone.
    Finish
    Musty flavors and smells dissipate quickly, and I'm left with a nice honey and caramel finish.
    Yamazaki 12 years old

    Yamazaki 12 Years Old Jan 30th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden
    Nose
    Spicy Vanilla, Oak, Earthy Honey.
    Body
    Medium to Full Bodied
    Palate
    Dried fruit, Creme brulee, Clove, backed up with Peat and Woods.
    Finish
    Very smooth initially and a welcome warmth at finish.

    The French and Italians didn't invent wine but became very famous for it, I suspect the same is happening with Japanese whisky.

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Jan 30th 2012

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Very clear amber. Delicious honey colors, looks smooth (and is)
    Nose
    The fresh scent of a new book, campfire smoke, alcohol, and a touch of fruit
    Body
    smooth, creamy almost, an array of flavors flows throughout the mouth gently stinging the nostrils.
    Palate
    Campfire smoke, wood, leather, slight citrus, sea salt
    Finish
    Very long finish, smooth and long. Tingles the back of the throat gently and leaves me with a taste of smoked wood.

    Fine, fine whiskey! would highly recomend

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Jan 30th 2012

    83
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Gold
    Nose
    Gentle honey with a bite.
    Body
    Rich `fullness'.
    Palate
    Tangy, softness, honey, indisputable whisky flavour.
    Finish
    Good long mouth lingering tangy flavour to mellowness.

    Just tried this

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Jan 29th 2012

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Body
    oily
    Palate
    Burnt rubber, cough syrup, metallic, leather.
    Finish
    Leaves my mouth feeling assaulted, taste buds somewhat in shock. Couldn't finish the measure I poured. Definitely an acquired taste, one that I won't pursue. But one that is nevertheless deeply layered and extremely complex.
    McClellands Speyside

    McClellands Speyside Jan 27th 2012

    71
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Nose
    Heavy smoke,peat, hospital smell
    Body
    thick, full bodied, smooth
    Palate
    peaty, smokey, smooth
    Finish
    warm, hot, medium finish
    Dalwhinnie 15 Years Old

    Dalwhinnie 15 Years Old Jan 27th 2012

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden amber (light beer like)
    Nose
    Light oak, honeysuckle and citrus
    Body
    Very light almost dainty
    Palate
    One note. Very light oak flavor with some light floral and fruit under tones.
    Finish
    Short finish that is very tame. Aside from the price certainly a good beginner’s scotch.

    Very under whelming scotch.

    Henry McKenna Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Henry McKenna Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Jan 27th 2012

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    caramel
    Nose
    strong on the vanilla
    Body
    full body
    Palate
    there's that vanilla with
    Finish
    warm to hot long finish

    Save it for mixed drinks

    The Famous Grouse Malt Whisky Aged 12 Years

    The Famous Grouse Malt Whisky Aged 12 Years Jan 22nd 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    apple buttercup
    Nose
    mild cuban cigar, orange peel slight peat alcohol
    Body
    warm, full, cheeky nippyness
    Palate
    slight smoke with citrus toffee chocolate with cigar box
    Finish
    oak wood cigar box with hot and tingly sweet

    seascape with caramel overtones

    George Dickel No. 12

    George Dickel No. 12 Jan 21st 2012

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    To my taste, beats Jack Daniel's thoroughly.

    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label Jan 19th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Carmel
    Nose
    Medicine
    Body
    Thin
    Palate
    Medicine forced down your throat as a child.
    Finish
    Long and bad. I couldn't get a sip of coke soon enough.

    Only good for a mixer. Probably not even that. It's horrible neat. I mean horrible.

    The Macallan 10 Years Old Cask Strength

    The Macallan 10 Years Old Cask Strength Jan 19th 2012

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale amber
    Nose
    fruit but unknown what kind
    Body
    full bodied and thick almost syrup texture.
    Palate
    unknown
    Finish
    long finish that is tingly and slightly warm
    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Jan 18th 2012

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden, dark amber
    Nose
    Sweet one day, peer the next. Smoky 30 minutes later
    Body
    Full thick and oh so nice
    Palate
    Sweet sherry, honey for me like eating a big hunk one day and a camp fire the next
    Finish
    Medium, and very fulfilling

    My favorite

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Jan 17th 2012

    96
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Nice amber, gold.
    Nose
    Heavy smoke, bbq
    Body
    Full body instantly brings happy thoughts of early hiking trips and campfires with burned meat and stories of the past.
    Palate
    Peat, wood, a touch of vanilla wit a touch of sweetness.
    Finish
    Nice long finish, not annoying to your throat. I guess, reading some of the reviews, this is not a drink for 'beginners'. Definitely one of my favorites!

    Wow, clearly a whiskey with an identity that you'll love or hate. I love it!

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Jan 17th 2012

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Burning Rubber, Cough Syrup, Hospital Smell, BBQ Brisket
    Body
    Smooth and rich
    Palate
    Bitter Melon, fresh laid asphalt,
    Finish
    Long, Strong, and draws attention from nearby people AND animals.
    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve Jan 17th 2012

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Caramel
    Nose
    Wet Tarmac Road, Bananas, Strawberries
    Body
    Smooth and light.
    Palate
    wet peat, sea salt, with a light flavor of burnt rubber.
    Finish
    Very short and wet finish.

    For the under $20 price, this is a MUST buy IF yo are an Islay lover. I drank this in a taste test side to side with my 16 year Lagavulin: Its very similar, but watered down in Comparison. It's like a watered down Lagavulin. Past reviewers who compared it to Gasoline should stick to their bud light beers.

    The Glenlivet 16 Year Old Nadurra

    The Glenlivet 16 Year Old Nadurra Jan 15th 2012

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    honeysuckle color or burnt umber...
    Nose
    deep cedar mixed with oak and burnt orange rind.
    Body
    full bodied smooth and glassy french kiss in a glass
    Palate
    smoothe palate easy on the sences....
    Finish
    strong warm finish peppery and warm to the very end

    great drink could be lil stronger.. good legs subtle undertones extra virgin casks..

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Jan 15th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Deceptively light
    Nose
    A campfire inside a hospital by the sea with the windows open. Pungent is an understatement. My wife could smell it from accross the table!
    Body
    Light to medium oilyness. Dryish bitterness in the middle which helps balence the strong flavors here.
    Palate
    A wollup of iodine and smoke up front. There's no missing the sea salt as well. Next is vanilla. Beyond that the muted honey and citrus eventually reveals itself.
    Finish
    This is where the upfront iodine give way to pure campfire smoke that seems to linger forever. I can't think of a more quintessentially Scottish flavor than this.

    If you crave smoke and sea this will more than satisfy. Other flavors are there must fight through the peat to reveal themselves. I agree its an acquired taste as its not as sweet as some but once acquired there's no going back.

    The Glenlivet 18 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 18 Years Old Jan 14th 2012

    94
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Amber with a bronze glow
    Nose
    Honey, Vanilla extract, Candied fruit
    Body
    Light to medium body with a slight oily feel on the tongue.
    Palate
    Vanilla custard, Honey, Slight toffee, & Nutmeg
    Finish
    Short finish with a Slight spice that quickly leads into a warm sweet conclusion.

    One of my favorite single malts to date.

    Benriach Curiositas Peated 10 Years Old

    Benriach Curiositas Peated 10 Years Old Jan 14th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    wet hay
    Nose
    Honey, dirt, toffee, peat, barley
    Body
    Oily, slightly gritty,
    Palate
    Slap in the mouth of peat, floral notes, honey, iodine.
    Finish
    Looong, and goood

    Wowser. Explosion of peat. Love it.

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old Jan 13th 2012

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale straw..
    Nose
    smoke and green olive
    Body
    good and thick
    Palate
    peat, peat peat.
    Finish
    pure smoke going on...

    being young had a hard a hard time some whisky mix...been a long time i didnt drink any...and this is one i can easily drink and feel...the smoke! so im not a really big whisky fan..and now i've found a..taste i like in beers and i can handle!

    The Balvenie 14 Year Old Golden Cask

    The Balvenie 14 Year Old Golden Cask Jan 13th 2012

    65
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Deep amber
    Nose
    A little fruity/floral
    Body
    Medium to light bodied
    Palate
    Noticeable bite, and a somewhat pleasant rum-ish flavor
    Finish
    Short, and unexceptional

    Not among my favorites. I really wanted to try the rum cask (17 year), but decided to go with this (a decision I regretted). I would not recommend overall, maybe The Balvenie intended this to be part of a blend, where it could bring a uniqueness to the overall experience.

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Jan 12th 2012

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber probably colored with caramel
    Nose
    Honey, peat smoke, dried grass, herbal, oranges. 29/33
    Body
    Medium thick Scotchy mouthfeel. Very nice.
    Palate
    Much like the nose. Grassy bitterness, honey-citrus sweetness. An obvious but mild and integrated peat smoke. Its a bit like Johnny Walker Gold 18 yr, but even smoother. Just lovely. 30/33
    Finish
    The finish isn't too long. This is a super smooth Whisky. The longer its in the glass, the less prominent the peat becomes. Take your time and enjoy this one. 30/33

    A very well made Whisky. It's smooth and complex with lots of flavors. Its a mysterious malt, the flavor profile changes. Sometimes mildly peaty, sometimes bitter - sweet. There is a lot going on with this one. The price was $60 US. I'm glad i bought a bottle.

    Laphroaig 15 Year Old

    Laphroaig 15 Year Old Jan 11th 2012

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark amber
    Nose
    Flowery, hints of wood
    Body
    Smooth
    Finish
    Strong, lasting finish. Develops hints of smoke

    Definately the best value/$ of all Wiskeys I've tried. Mixing it would seem to be a waste. Comparable to Johnnie Walker Black Label, but without the overwhelming sweetness.

    Glenfiddich Special Reserve 12 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Special Reserve 12 Years Old Jan 10th 2012

    84
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale amber
    Nose
    Very fruity and sweek like Christmas cake. The oak is present too.
    Body
    Medium bodied, fairly dry. Low on the creamy/oily scale.
    Palate
    Hints of dark chocolate, tobacco, vanilla from the oak balanced out by a citrucy twang at the end.
    Finish
    Starts sweet with mild heat but doesn't linger very long. Medium to short finnish.

    Nicely balanced and restrained. Complexity is there you just have to work for it. This is as classic as it gets. What I like most about this is it just tastes like scotch and I mean that in a good way.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Jan 10th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Peat, Peat, Peat, Peat...did I mention Peat? And why would this ever be a good thing?
    Body
    Painful
    Palate
    A kodiak bearhug ripping you to shreds, tongue first of peat.
    Finish
    Thank God!

    A lovely single malt for anyone who likes to have a big mossy mouthful of dirt that pickles the tongue and destroys the palate. No smoke, all peat...so horribly overrated. Didn't the peat bogs preserve bodies for thousands of years? Maybe that is the motivation for this atrocity.

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Jan 9th 2012

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark gold, nearly copper.
    Nose
    Sweet, Nutty (toasted almonds), light on the peat / smoke. Notes of vanilla, maple, apple, & cinnamon. A touch too much booze.
    Body
    Medium bodied.
    Palate
    Maple syrup, reminiscent of, but not too close to, bourbon dominates. Strong notes of honey & nut support, as if one lightly drizzled pancake syrup over baklava. The nose on exhalation is dominated by dry bakers chocolate.
    Finish
    Medium-short, but still quite spicy.

    One of my favorite 12 years, a good deal better than The Balvenie 14 year. May be a bit too bourbon-y for the average scotch drinker, but as a native Kentuckian, I don't mind a bit. Too much alcohol on the nose and too short a finish for a "Great" score, but overall, a very good after dinner drink, and solid value for money at ~$50.

    Bowmore 15 Year Old

    Bowmore 15 Year Old Jan 9th 2012

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    Peat, earth
    Body
    Full bodied
    Palate
    Walnuts
    Finish
    Strong to the end

    I got it as a gift from my girlfriend I would have to say I am verry impressed it smouth and goes excellent with a cigar

    Aberlour a'bunadh

    Aberlour A'bunadh Jan 9th 2012

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Deep reddish amber
    Nose
    Bread pudding, rum raisin ice cream, maple syrup and sherry.
    Body
    Thick and oily when neat, like cough syrup. Medium bodied after adding water to taste.
    Palate
    Sherry, rum, and creamy bread pudding.
    Finish
    Very long finish, regardless of how much water added. This will warm you up in a hurry.

    Batch 37, 59.6% abv. Disclaimer: I'm an Islay lover for the most part. I've tried to like this one, but of this but too much sherry for me. Mixed 3 parts of this to 1 part Oban 14 and 2 parts water: perfection!

    Glenfiddich 12 Year Old

    Glenfiddich 12 Year Old Jan 7th 2012

    74
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Straw
    Nose
    Spicy malt, Floural, Fresh cantalope
    Body
    Oily, Thick, Cool, Medium-Full, Easy
    Palate
    Spicy malt, Fresh Cantaloupe, Grass
    Finish
    Long and even, Spicy, Sweet at the end. Satisfying.

    Another under-valued bottle. A very well balanced Speyside. Satisfying.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Jan 6th 2012

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Deep, earthy peat smoke that is not overpowering, medicinal iodine with faint vanilla in the background. Reminds me of the seashore on a cloudy Autumn afternoon. Beautiful!
    Body
    Medium to full body. Wonderful mouth feel, slightly oily.
    Palate
    Peat smoke up front, followed with medicinal iodine and brine, and subdued sherry in the background.
    Finish
    Medium to long finish, smooth as glass, very well balanced, with a sweet ending.

    My first love in single malt scotch. A true classic.

    Jim Beam Black Sour Mash Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Jim Beam Black Sour Mash Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Jan 5th 2012

    65
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale gold.
    Nose
    Delicate, sweet, hint of rubbing alcohol.
    Body
    Medium to full-bodied.
    Palate
    Smooth corn syrup and oak.
    Finish
    Long and dry.

    Decent bourbon for the price. Makes a great Manhattan.

    Clynelish 14 Year Old

    Clynelish 14 Year Old Jan 4th 2012

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Bright sunshine
    Nose
    Apple cider, sugar cookies, ripe pears and lemonade.
    Body
    Light to medium body, clean and crisp.
    Palate
    Buttery, spicy, warm and tingly. Extremely well balanced between spiciness and malty sweetness. Maybe a faint touch of brine as well.
    Finish
    Medium to long finish, ends in wave after wave of spicy sweetness. I love this!

    This whisky has something in it for everyone, and will be a staple in my collection from now on. It's so different from my usual suspects (Islays), but also very different from the sherry monsters. I want another glass!

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay Jan 4th 2012

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dirty gold
    Nose
    Wet pine, mint toothpicks, moldy christmas tree, seaweed
    Body
    Quite thick and oily
    Palate
    Pine, wood, cracked pepper, peat
    Finish
    Medium in length, slightly sweet, not bad. The only redeeming quality of this whisky

    Perhaps I got a bad bottle, but this is the worst malt I have ever tasted. I didnt even finish my dram. The nose on this one makes my stomach curdle. There is something wrong here.

    Glenfiddich Solera Reserve 15 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Solera Reserve 15 Years Old Jan 4th 2012

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber
    Nose
    Pear.
    Body
    Light.
    Palate
    Spicy, fruity.
    Finish
    Minimal amount of afterburn.

    Very good upgrade from the standard Glenfiddich series.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength Jan 2nd 2012

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden
    Nose
    Heavy smoke, peat
    Palate
    Lots of peat, smoke, oily
    Finish
    Fairly dry

    Not for the malt novice. You must like a heavy smoke flavour.

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Dec 31st 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden
    Nose
    peaty
    Body
    full body, deep peaty taste
    Palate
    peaty
    Finish
    warm,heat,peaty

    excellent

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Dec 31st 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Darker than most
    Nose
    Rancid band aids. Hospitals
    Body
    Thick, oily
    Palate
    Iodine
    Finish
    Thank god

    Never want to taste or smell this again. Overdone in a big way.

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old Dec 31st 2011

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Sweet pears and prunes with a touch of sea air.
    Body
    Light to medium.
    Palate
    Deliciously sweet, slightly malty.
    Finish
    10 to 15 seconds, dry and salty.

    A terrific blend, easily as good as the cheaper single malts. Blows its price-range competitors such as JW Black out of the water.

    Crown Royal

    Crown Royal Dec 30th 2011

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light golden brown to burnt orange mahogany
    Nose
    caramel and honey with just a hint of smokey tone
    Body
    smooth with a light to medium body.
    Palate
    sweet. caramel and a gingery spice with slight notes of fruit.
    Finish
    very light tingle and a soft warmth.

    an old classic at a nice price

    Cardhu 12 Year Old

    Cardhu 12 Year Old Dec 29th 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Some call it sunny. I say it's just about yellow.
    Nose
    Sweet, with a dash of very pleasant heat attached.
    Body
    Thin. This single malt reveals itself very quickly and then is gone. But what a show.
    Palate
    On the thin, sweet side. That might sound disparaging, but it's not meant to be.
    Finish
    Not a long finish, in keeping with its quick-and-clean body. But it's a joy to drink.
    The Macallan 18 Years Old

    The Macallan 18 Years Old Dec 27th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber +1
    Nose
    Mellow sherry, butterscotch, faint apple and ripe pear.
    Body
    Medium body, silky and very smooth.
    Palate
    Sherry but not overpowering, dark rich fruit, maybe a little currant and cinnamon.
    Finish
    Long silky legs, exceptionally smooth and complex. Ends a bit dry which appeals to me.

    Normally prefer Islays, but this is a gem, and not too sweet for my palate.

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Dec 26th 2011

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Salt, smoke, pepper, iodine, cold sea spray
    Body
    Thin but intense
    Palate
    Peat, intense sparkly pepper! Like a sparkler on your tongue. Salty
    Finish
    Tingly, burn. A winter whisky

    Solid. I particularly enjoy the blue top on the cork and the simple label.

    The Dalmore 12 Year Old

    The Dalmore 12 Year Old Dec 26th 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Medium to light in colour
    Nose
    Good without being overpowering
    Body
    Warm and glowing
    Palate
    Slightly sweet but with no 'afterburn'.
    Finish
    Warm and soothing

    As far as I can tell this is the same as Aldi's Glen Marnoch. It is superb and as a result I no longer drink any blends. It is simply superb and very nearly as good as my favourites, the Glen Livet and The Macallan.

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey Dec 25th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Smokey, Sour Spicey Sweet.
    Body
    Smooth with a touch of herbal spice.
    Palate
    Banana and Oranges.
    Finish
    Warm and smooth finish.

    Currently only $20 for a superior Bourbon. I'm mostly a Scotch drinker. Of the bourbons I've had (Eagle Rare, Jameson, Maker's Mark) I get bored of them fast. Other than sweetness and smoothness, they don't have much else going for them...but Bulleit is different. The higher Rye content adds so much character and spice to the Bourbon that I cannot help but make it my mainstay Bourbon drink....for $20 not a difficult decision. Also, look for Bulleit American Rye @ 95%+ Rye Mash content....delicious.

    Cragganmore 10 Year Old Cask Strength

    Cragganmore 10 Year Old Cask Strength Dec 24th 2011

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden
    Nose
    Not much
    Body
    Lighter than the alcohol would indicate
    Palate
    Bourbon cask
    Finish
    Very short

    Drank straight it was quite well done with not much alcohol "heat". With a few drops of water it seemed to lose it's balance but for sure was entirely smooth tasting. I'm not sure it's worth the price when compared to similar Speyside whiskeys. The 12 year old standard issue is a much better whiskey.

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old Dec 24th 2011

    65
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Beautiful amber.
    Nose
    Silver tequila with underlying vanilla.
    Body
    Medium.
    Palate
    Light smoke. Not a whole lot going on.
    Finish
    Short and warm.

    Decent blend, but hardly anything to write home about.

    Connemara Peated Single Malt Irish Whiskey

    Connemara Peated Single Malt Irish Whiskey Dec 24th 2011

    73
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Heather, tobacco, dried orange peel.
    Body
    Thin to medium.
    Palate
    Nicely balanced peat, malt and salt.
    Finish
    Quite long, deliciously warm. Wood aftertaste.

    This is a decent single malt and a good stepping stone to Islays.

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay Dec 23rd 2011

    76
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Med. amber
    Nose
    Peat, vanilla, dried apricots
    Body
    A bit thin, with a burn, but some nice grain finish.
    Palate
    No iodine (I gather other reviewers have never worked with real iodine-as a researcher I do. Not very peaty - more salt sea spray.
    Finish
    Strong then tapers off quickly. Short finish, though not unpleasant.

    I'll counter the snobs here. This is what it is: a very drinkable, affordable whiskey (and yes, I've had some of the best). No, it's not an Ardbeg or Lagavulin (not even Highland Park), but it's also $22 a bottle. Fine for what it is; very nice neat or a mixer. Stop complaining, boys!

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Dec 23rd 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light caramel
    Nose
    strongly of honey, a bit boozie, lightly spicy
    Body
    smooth and surupy
    Palate
    honey, spice, smokey,slightly peaty, chocolate?
    Finish
    warm lasting and a little alcoholic

    this is my favorite whisky in the 50 dollar price range. i try to always have a bottle in my liquor cabnet

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay Dec 23rd 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light golden amber
    Nose
    Heavy smoke, antiseptic hints
    Body
    Thin, but legs would suggest otherwise
    Palate
    Burnt leather, iodine, hospital bed, peat, dirt, salty notes...not a pleasant taste to me.
    Finish
    Overpowering alcohol burn and smoke...unpleasant

    As a new scotch drinker I did not enjoy this bottle.

    J & B Rare Blended Scotch Whisky

    J & B Rare Blended Scotch Whisky Dec 22nd 2011

    72
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale straw
    Nose
    Fruity, very light hay and straw scent mingled with a light malt.
    Body
    Light and friendly
    Palate
    Light and fruity.Faint peat.
    Finish
    quickly gone with a blunt aftertaste.

    A starter scotch

    Teacher's HIghland Cream

    Teacher's HIghland Cream Dec 22nd 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light to medium golden sunshine.
    Nose
    Malty,some peat and a whiff of smoke.
    Body
    Full malt. Warm and peaty with a nice measure of smoke. Long finnish.
    Palate
    The malt, peat and smoke are a in balance and flavors of raosted cashews and maple sweetness come to mind.
    Finish
    Warm finnish with the smoke playing to the end.

    A wonderful Blended Whisky.A must for the liquor locker.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Dec 21st 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Copper / rich amber
    Nose
    Sea tang, iodine, smoke, peat.
    Body
    medium
    Palate
    Iodine, salt, peat are the main impressions. There's a touch of honey in there somewhere. Fairly smooth without the sharp bitey tastes of some other whiskies.
    Finish
    Long distinctive finish leaving you breathing smoke and phenols.

    This was the Scotch that got me into single malts. Wonderful, amazing stuff.

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old Dec 21st 2011

    65
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Very pale amber.
    Nose
    Wonderfully intense pear aroma, the smell of Indian Summer in an orchard.
    Body
    Medium body.
    Palate
    Slightly salty, little malt or peat. Dry and delicate.
    Finish
    Not very long, peppery.

    A fine introduction to single malts. Unassertive and inoffensive, but still good and affordable.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Dec 21st 2011

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Copper
    Nose
    Walnut, wood.
    Body
    Of medium viscosity, between water and oil.
    Palate
    Salt, iodine, leather.
    Finish
    Very little afterburn, and warm resonance that lingers.

    A very satisfying whisky with loads of character (still trying to work out all the tastes) without being based solely on overpeatiness.

    Ardmore Traditional Cask

    Ardmore Traditional Cask Dec 19th 2011

    81
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    dark gold, wood
    Nose
    Sweet Peat, earthy, grass, butterscotch, raw fruit rind
    Body
    Thick, round
    Palate
    Sweet Peat, smoky air, sweet cream, butterscotch, grass, salty
    Finish
    Very long and warm. Delightful.

    Extremely interesting scotch.

    Bowmore 12 Year Old

    Bowmore 12 Year Old Dec 18th 2011

    83
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Honey gold
    Nose
    Iodine, peat, smoke, tinge of orange peel.
    Body
    Oily and creamy.
    Palate
    Peat at first then reveals vanilla, dark chocolate and sea salt reminiscent of salted taffey.
    Finish
    Smooth at first then oak tannins provide a slight bitterness in the end.

    Not overly complex but whats there is smooth and pleasing. Highland park introduced me to the pleasures of peat and this takes it up a notch. At this price a good introduction to Islay.

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old Dec 18th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    Smooth Like Butter or a pair of Italian Shoes. A dram appreciated by those with an advanced palate able to appreciate a thoughtful blend of some solid malts.

    Crown Royal

    Crown Royal Dec 17th 2011

    81
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark Gold
    Nose
    Pepper, vanilla, not very complext
    Body
    Medium body, consistent
    Palate
    Complexity progresses from salt, to vanilla, to butterscotch.
    Finish
    Long tingly finish, lingering with warm spice.

    At its best with a splash of water or on the rocks (best when ice begins to melt).

    The Dalmore Cigar Malt

    The Dalmore Cigar Malt Dec 17th 2011

    57
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden caramel
    Nose
    Fruity with alcohol and the slightest hint of peat. Satisfying and exciting
    Body
    A little oily but full, an explosion of citrus and nut.
    Palate
    Expanding flavors with a solid injection of alcohol and oak.
    Finish
    Good at first, then everything goes dreadfully wrong, the building flavors collapse on one another in a cataclysmic and terrible finish. This killed the experience for me, this is the last bottle of The Dalmore 12 I will be buying

    I was severely disappointed with this malt. For a moderately priced scotch, i was expecting the whole package, not just 2/3 of the experience. Everything was great up until the finish.

    Tamdhu Fine Single Malt Scotch Whisky

    Tamdhu Fine Single Malt Scotch Whisky Dec 14th 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden
    Nose
    Light

    This is a great Scotch for $20. We've held blind taste and most people find it better than the more expensive Speyside single malts.

    Kilchoman New Spirit

    Kilchoman New Spirit Dec 13th 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Very Pale Amber
    Nose
    Lots of peat, spicy. Reminiscent of Ardbeg.
    Body
    Medium with a buttery consistency.
    Palate
    Light with a spicy, peaty, smoky zing. Only a touch of immaturity.
    Finish
    Strong, long, classic Islay peat finish.

    I tried the 2011 Spring Release which was a mixture of their 3 yr and 4yr malts. This is a truly amazing Islay Malt for the age. I did not know whisky could taste this good only 3.5 yrs in the barrel. For peat lovers, this will be one of the best once it reaches full maturity, but certainly worth a taste already.

    McClellands Highland

    McClellands Highland Dec 11th 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Amber
    Nose
    It smells hot. It smells of alcohol.
    Body
    Light with no real body. Airy, ghostly, elusive.
    Palate
    Alcohol. Molasses. Carrion.
    Finish
    It seems to have a bitter, skunky finish unbecoming a scotch.

    This is the first scotch I've ever had to mix with soda. It's atrocious.

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Dec 10th 2011

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light caramel color
    Nose
    Honey, citrus, almond, vanilla, maple
    Body
    Medium body
    Palate
    nice balance of woody taste & citrus
    Finish
    Mediun Finish

    I agree a little water does open up the bouquet a bit and mellows the bite over the palate.

    Oban 14 Year Old

    Oban 14 Year Old Dec 10th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dull amber.
    Nose
    Floral, honey.
    Body
    Sinks in your palette.
    Palate
    Medium peatiness, slightly spicy.
    Finish
    Punchy alcoholic aftertaste.

    An exceptional whisky, but can get better value elsewhere.

    McClellands Highland

    McClellands Highland Dec 9th 2011

    74
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden blonde, wet hay
    Nose
    Rainy beach, honey, butter scotch
    Body
    Round, syrupish
    Palate
    Peat, honey, floral bitterness , fruit mixture
    Finish
    Warm, medium, kinda painful but in a good way

    I enjoyed this better than their lowlands variety. Nice.

    Glenfiddich Ancient Reserve 18 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Ancient Reserve 18 Years Old Dec 4th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale Amber
    Nose
    Mostly Peat
    Body
    Full Bodied, smooth
    Palate
    Peat, Earth, hints of Sherry and Charcoal .. woody with a teenie bit of fruit.
    Finish
    all the aforementioned flavors just fade off tempting you for more

    Fantastic .. when I pulled the cork on her I knew I'd love this one .. like the bottom of a peat bog way up in the Highlands of Scotland with an essence of Sherry and USA Charcoal barrels .. loved it from the beginning to the end.

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old Dec 4th 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light amber
    Nose
    Heavy Smoke and heavy smoke... like being trapped in a 10 year old meat smoker.
    Body
    full bodied and thick
    Palate
    enveloped in smoke..
    Finish
    I was really excited about drinking the Ardbeg .. while many folks on here will love the smokey flavors and scent of this swill .. it did not suit my pallet, I much prefer the Peat, Cherry, and Charcoal taste of other blends. Wish I'd read the reviews on here first, but hey, now I know.

    Unlike other Scotch, the Ardbeg 10 year contained a very narrow band of smokey flavors and a powerful smokey scent. Probably better as a blend than straight. I didn't like it much, prefer the peat or carbon taste. It was like drinking that liquid smoke at the Supermarket.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Nov 30th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Deep golden honey
    Nose
    Peat
    Body
    Some lovehandles but not too heavy
    Palate
    Medium peat to heavy sweet
    Finish
    Godzilla fire

    Entry level bliss

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Nov 28th 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    medium amber
    Nose
    Citrusy, orange and lemon with a light hint of the smokey peat to come
    Body
    a medium weight with complex flavors but body has feels clean pure grain essence when opened up with a splash of water.
    Palate
    Initial peat iodine but not overbearing as in some Islays. Quickly fades to reveal honey and heather balenced by a citrusy backbone. A pleasing tanic bitterness in the end cleans it away preparing for another sip.
    Finish
    brings back the light peat smoke with a pleasing dry unlit cigar bitterness.

    A very well balenced whiskey. As close to a true hybrid between the phenolic peakiness of Islay and the more restrained maltiness of Speysides as you'll find. At this price its my go to house single malt.

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Nov 24th 2011

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Straw
    Nose
    Peat, iodine, sea salt
    Body
    Full, oily
    Palate
    Peppery, leather, some nuts
    Finish
    Long lasting pepper
    Bushmills Malt 21 Year Old

    Bushmills Malt 21 Year Old Nov 21st 2011

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Antique gold
    Nose
    Very inviting. Sweet malt and spice
    Body
    Medium feel, not too oily
    Palate
    Incredibly smooth, unlike any other. Lucious carmel, toffee, and honey on top of malty thickness
    Finish
    Medium to long finish. Very pleasant, screams out drink more!
    Aberlour a'bunadh

    Aberlour A'bunadh Nov 19th 2011

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    dark ,dark sherry
    Nose
    woody emptied cask
    Body
    too thick,syrupy
    Palate
    medicinaly nutty
    Finish
    short stinging.lacks complexity.overpowering neat.

    I tried a few different times inferior to cask strenth Glenfarclas and Macallan.I like the traditional Aberlour scotch.disappointed in this malt

    Aberlour a'bunadh

    Aberlour A'bunadh Nov 17th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Brownish Red
    Nose
    Amazing nose of sherry, vanilla, chocolate, oranges, maple syrup, apples and quince
    Body
    Full, mouth coating, very slightly oily
    Palate
    Sweet all the way through, hot but not overdone considering 59.7% ABV. Very smooth and sweet...
    Finish
    Hot but long lasting sweetness

    Great NAS whisky for the price!

    Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select

    Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select Nov 10th 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Medium amber, cognac colour
    Nose
    A spicey vanilla aroma with a caramel and sweet cream with spice compliment
    Body
    Very oily and heavy, but well balanced throughout
    Palate
    Nutty, with a melting feeling similar to pure-cane rock sugar
    Finish
    finishes long and warm with spice that's very clensing like nutmeg and cinnemon stirred into honey

    This bourbon is probably one of the few smooth bourbons that still retains an enormous amount of flavor.

    Bushmills Black Bush

    Bushmills Black Bush Nov 10th 2011

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    Sweet malt and alcohol
    Body
    thin
    Palate
    smooth, toffee and some chocolate.
    Finish
    clean not overpowerin.

    This a fine whiskey and very enjoyable. That being said a few years ago I bought a bottle of Bushmills single malt 10 year old and this was one of the absolute best if not the best Irish whiskey I have ever tasted.

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old Nov 9th 2011

    76
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Earthy
    Body
    Mild body
    Palate
    A touch of peat.
    Finish
    Good strong finish.

    Not bad for a lower end 12 year old. Has a nice finish that competes with some of the higher end 12 and 18 year olds.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength Nov 5th 2011

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Medium amber.
    Nose
    Awesome! Blast of smoke, peat, bacon, black forest ham, smoked salmon, ocean breeze, leather and surprisingly sweet trail mix nuts.
    Body
    High viscosity for a Scotch dram, full body and them some.
    Palate
    100% Laphroaig character, just what you would expect from this brand, the real thing, the one and only, the opposite side of Kentucky. A stout vs. a lager.
    Finish
    Finish is 8 out of 10, not bad, just wish it was longer. With the addition of water (recommended)

    Outstanding Islay malt! Expensive, be aware that 2 bottles of cask strength equal 3 bottles of 4o% abv regular 12 yo Laphroaig based on alcohol content figures. Flavor wise I find this cask strength better. Top on my list. Overall: Second to none!!!! AMAZING SCOTCH WHISKEY!

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old Nov 5th 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light amber
    Nose
    sweet rubbing alcohol
    Body
    watery
    Palate
    Iodine
    Finish
    Warm and tingly.
    Scapa 12 Years Old

    Scapa 12 Years Old Nov 3rd 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Goud
    Nose
    Fruit, fruit en nog eens fruit. Zalige zoetigheid.
    Body
    Vol. Zelfs een ietsje olie.
    Palate
    Fruitig: zowel vers fruit als opgelegd fruit.
    Finish
    Lang en rustig. Geen peperachtige afdronk à la Talisker.

    Deze heerlijke Orkneywhisky geproefd in de onvolprezen Glengarry in Gent. Ik vond die stukken "beter" dan de ook geproefde Highland Park.P

    Old Ezra 7 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Old Ezra 7 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Nov 1st 2011

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    PERFECT
    Nose
    JUST RIGHT
    Body
    SWEEEET
    Palate
    HUH ?
    Finish
    SILK

    BEEN DRINKING WISKEY FOR 40 YEARS, JUST TRIED OLD EZRA, SORRY JIM BEAM BUT I AM HOOKED. IS THERE PLENTY OF OLD LEFT?

    Aberlour 15 Year Old Sherry Finish

    Aberlour 15 Year Old Sherry Finish Oct 31st 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Typical of sherried whiskys
    Body
    Cask strength produces a wonderful full body with great depth.
    Palate
    Strong sherry notes, vanilla.
    Finish
    Very clean and full.

    Tasted and purchased at the distillery, Summer 2010. Cask strength.

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old Oct 31st 2011

    71
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Yellow
    Nose
    Medicinal, flat, one dimensional, flower extract, light hints of WD-40 and kerosene.
    Body
    Thin, typical legs of 40% abv spirit.
    Palate
    Drinkable with ice, soda or lemonade. Do not try this on a Glencairn glass. Overall medicinal with flower extract in the background.
    Finish
    Not much here either. Goes away fast.

    When I try spirits like these after the initial anger and disappointment I realize how misleading and insignificant an age statement can be. Glenlivet, after 12 years of maturation are you sure you can't do any better than this? For less money both Black Bottle and Chivas 12 blends blow this this Glen away. Nice bottle and tube though.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Oct 29th 2011

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Border line between yellow and gold
    Nose
    Somewhat weak on the nose with hints of peat, salty water and smoke.
    Body
    Medium to Light.
    Palate
    The current 40% abv version of Laphroaig 10yo appears to be chilled filtered for appearance, there is a significant loss of oils and flavors that were present in the early versions. It could be attributed to the filtration process but that is only an opinion. In general this spirits retains the salty+peaty+smoky=Laphroaig equation. but in a more moderate/mild manner. It is sweet on the pallet like a lager beer. Overall very centrist.
    Finish
    Lingering is a 7 out of 10

    Not as good as the Cask Strength expression but still acceptable, an entry level relatively affordable Islay Malt. If you like dry, peaty and smoky spirits this is the bottle to start your evening until you have a chance to try the "real thing"

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old Oct 29th 2011

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    YELLOW
    Nose
    Strong
    Body
    Good.
    Palate
    If I said salt, I would go ahead and start sitting down to pee. It tastes like Whiskey you bunch of posers.
    Finish
    I am.

    I bought a case. It tastes like whiskey. All you punters who say tastes like fruits and vegetables and anything else sound like pratts.

    Teacher's HIghland Cream

    Teacher's HIghland Cream Oct 28th 2011

    68
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Paler than it used to be ... it looks likes Dewars now.
    Nose
    Used to be the best combination of smokey and sweet of the blended scotch whiskys, but not with my most recent bottle.
    Body
    Was, but no longer full bodied in my most recent bottle.
    Palate
    Sweet Peat
    Finish
    Used to be a longer and warmer finish. Most recent bottle is watery and more delicate ... not what I'm looking for. My final score on this bottle is a bare 70, whereas for the past 30 years I would have given Teacher's my highest rating (high 80's) among all blended scotches. As you can tell, I'm very upset if they have muddied my long-time go-to blended scotch.
    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay Oct 26th 2011

    55
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    does it matter? i dont really get why this is in all the whisky books. to avoid counterfit?
    Nose
    Definitely tries for the Islay trio. Peat, smoke and medicinal. Sickly sweet undertone, which is made worse with the addition of a little water. Overwhelming alcohol makes it difficult to find subtler notes, if present.
    Body
    Burning. Someone mentioned inconsistency between bottles. Perhaps this one is oddly strong.
    Palate
    Peat, bitter, odd sweetness that doesn't seem to mesh. Better flavor without water and mouth closed. Without water and mouth open causes vapor induced coughing fit. Water makes the sting more bearable, but opens up the flaws.
    Finish
    Acid reflux.

    Yeesh. I know people are saying this is an everyday scotch, but at $30 a bottle I would rather go the extra 10 and get a Laphroaig or a blend. This is a young, harsh and not particularly enjoyable whisky. I can think of one I like less, and it was also an immature bottling strictly for profit.

    Midleton Very Rare

    Midleton Very Rare Oct 22nd 2011

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    A beautiful amber
    Body
    Smooth, oh so smooth
    Finish
    warms the heart

    A present from the gods

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Oct 21st 2011

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    A good amber color
    Nose
    A lovely smokey peat aroma with a hint of iodine/seaweed.
    Body
    Full bodied, just right.
    Palate
    Initially a nice iodine laced seaweed, then a lovely smoking peat.
    Finish
    Long finish. First you taste a distinct seaweed flavor full of iodine. It develops to a strong peaty taste.

    To date this is my favorite Scottish whiskey. It takes me back to my time in Scotland where I would smell the divine aroma of burning peat by the sea. Anyone who has this experience will find this nostalgic...

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old Oct 19th 2011

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber - 3 (very light, lighter than Kilchoman Winter 2010.
    Nose
    Peat, iodine, brine, ozone, seawater, and smoke. Hint of sweetness as well.
    Body
    Thick and bold. Utterly amazing. Nice legs (Angel's tears).
    Palate
    Very different from Laphroaig IMHO. This is very refined for such a young whisky. The 10 y.o. Lap will immediately blast you with peat, but with the Ardbeg 10, it is a much more sophisticated peat blast. The intensity comes in increments and then suddenly you are rushed with intense peat and smoke. A hint of sherry and vanilla can be felt in the background. Marvelous whisky indeed.
    Finish
    The finish stays with you, long after you've realized... What an excellent bottle.

    This is a fantastic whisky. If it was slightly cheaper, it would have become my every day drammer. Absolutely marvelous. At 46% abv & non chill-filtered, it's remarkable how this whisky holds up. Don't let the light color fool you, this whisky is playing for keeps.

    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label Oct 16th 2011

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber

    Enjoyable on the rocks

    Forty Creek Barrel Select

    Forty Creek Barrel Select Oct 16th 2011

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber, Vanilla, Spice
    Nose
    Wonderfull
    Body
    Medium bodied
    Palate
    Soft
    Finish
    Kind, and Warm

    Very Smooth, great for youngsters, and refined whiskey drinkers alike

    Jack Daniel's Master Distiller

    Jack Daniel's Master Distiller Oct 16th 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Finish
    Classic Jack Daniels Punch!

    First whisky i had ever tried.

    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve Oct 14th 2011

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    just over straw,pale green/gold
    Nose
    big big peat hit,nose prickle if you linger too long ,rubber doggy toys,inner tubes, but a fishy hint,and a bit of mint,does remind me of a caol ila crossed with ledaig,
    Body
    smooth yet dry, can't really call it oily
    Palate
    smokey and dry, peat an iodine rule,slightly salty
    Finish
    medium finish but very dry and salty, slight burn and hint of pepper/spice

    If you are into Islays you are in for a treat

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Oct 12th 2011

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Warm gold.
    Nose
    Malt and barley-sugar with bubbling undercurrents of smouldering peat and air-dried seaweed.
    Body
    Oily and prickly. Equal measures of creamy smoothness and attitude.
    Palate
    Heavy malt, seaweed & brine, salty caramel, russett apples, oaky smoke and damp turf & sparklers.
    Finish
    Like putting a sweet oily blanket over a box of lit fireworks... the action lingers for ages, and the flavours keep changing. (I'm drinking it as I write!) , mmm....

    If ever a whisky describes the landscape from where it was produced, this does it to perfection... sea, rugged mountains and ever changing skies. This stuff is genius. I drink a lot of this whisky and it's always the same - always different! mmmmm.....

    Connemara 12 year Old Peated Single Malt Irish Whiskey

    Connemara 12 Year Old Peated Single Malt Irish Whiskey Oct 12th 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Enticingly warm and golden, with a worrying arora of green.
    Nose
    Kippers, furniture polish, spent matches and barley-sugar sweets
    Body
    A stick-insect with the mouth of Mick Jagger.
    Palate
    Fake smoke and cardboard wrapped round a hard-boiled candy.
    Finish
    Like a thief who gets away without being noticed, but leaves an unpleasant fart behind him.

    One of the best things about living here in Ireland is the smell of peat on a damp wintery day, so I was incredibly excited by the thought of a peated Irish whiskey. It makes so much sense. However, what I got was a veneer of peat smoke - like the cheapest of kippers had been squeeze into the mash. Expensive and disappointing, with non of the class, breeding or complexity of its western Scottish peers. Need a lot of work to improve it.

    Chivas Regal 18 Year Old

    Chivas Regal 18 Year Old Oct 12th 2011

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber + 2 (Due to E150A)
    Nose
    Sweet, subtle, and fruity. A bit malty.
    Body
    Medium body, did not test legs (angel's tears) unfortunately.
    Palate
    Sweet, butterscotch, reminiscent of glenlivet, aberlour, vary faint peat and smoke, fruity, raisins, probably from glenallachie malt, very very very smooth. Smoothness probably from good grain casks. High complexity level for a blend. Outstanding.
    Finish
    Decent finish. Do not add water, it will drown the whisky. Drink neat, adding ice will tarnish the flavors. If you must add ice, use a large cube if possible. Beautiful stuff. Highly recommended.

    Amazing Blend. Truly a great buy and puts some malts under the shade. Hints of Aberlour, Glenlivet and some slight smoke and tiny peat. Very refreshing and a good finish. Unfortunately, it is chill-filtered, has E150A, and lower than 46% ABV, but has a competitive sophistication and complexity compared to its primary competitor(s).

    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label Oct 11th 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    This whiskey is only good in coctails, that's all there is to it, nothing more my fellas; but even in cocktails I'd use a J&B Rare instead of JWRL.

    Aberlour a'bunadh Batch 16

    Aberlour A'bunadh Batch 16 Oct 9th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    perfect
    Nose
    earthy, a bit hospital, smokey
    Body
    fill bodied. thick, velvety
    Finish
    long finish. Wonderful on the tongue and taste buds.

    Drink once before you die.

    Glen Garioch 21 Year Old

    Glen Garioch 21 Year Old Oct 4th 2011

    83
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden amber
    Nose
    Big toffee
    Body
    Full bodied
    Palate
    Caramel pudding
    Finish
    Long and comforting

    I got a 21 glen garioch from the smws single cask bottling. It's a real delight to drink,but for a 21yr old its bit lacking in depth.nice whisky,fully flavoured,just lacking that ompth a 21 yr may be expected of.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength Sep 25th 2011

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden amber.
    Nose
    The smoke and peat charge up your nostrils with unrepentant glee.
    Body
    A deep, substantial, testosterone-laden experience.
    Palate
    Reminiscences of burning embers around the campfire, mixed with the rotting, briny fragrance of the seashore at low tide.
    Finish
    A long-lasting, satisfying warmth that will carry satisfyingly far longer than could be imagined.

    Warning! If you do not revere the whiskies of the western islands, don't even THINK of trying this magnificent creation.

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old Sep 23rd 2011

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    peat and spices
    Body
    full bodied with hints of oak
    Palate
    a cabinet of smokey spices and slightly sweet
    Finish
    clean with very little flavor but good bouquet

    This was a pleasant tasting scotch but for its price and being blended it was harsh the morning after

    Bunnahabhain 12 Year Old

    Bunnahabhain 12 Year Old Sep 22nd 2011

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber + 3 (truly dark for a no E150A and at 12 y.o. - amazing)
    Nose
    Brine, maritime, hints of smoke, very small amounts of peat and sherry. Beautiful.
    Body
    Thick, lovely legs. Oils and esters apparent in glass. With water, scotch mist is exposed, truly this is a quality dram.
    Palate
    Maritime, figs, sherry, hints of bourbon, tiny amounts of peat, a'bunadh and uigeadail characteristics, low taste of petrol, sweet, candied fruits, butterscotch, caramel, lovely stuff.
    Finish
    Finish is long and sweet. This is truly a quality of a dram. Very far from the original.
    Jameson 12 Year Old

    Jameson 12 Year Old Sep 17th 2011

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden
    Nose
    Leathery with a light honey smell
    Body
    Medium
    Palate
    Sweet and very warm
    Finish
    Smooth

    Excellent on the rocks.

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Sep 16th 2011

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    the first rays of sunrise whence rousing
    Nose
    shaking a cowboys hand while questioning ones sexuality
    Body
    full. lathery. sensual yet firm.
    Palate
    the pleasure of falling off your horse and getting sand it your mouth, but still feeling like a man. rolling in the hay after a long day of sweat rolling down your face and into your mouth.
    Finish
    lying on your back looking at the stars, not caring if the world were to end right now.
    Ardbeg Uigeadail

    Ardbeg Uigeadail Sep 16th 2011

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber + 2
    Nose
    Peat, smoke, slightly medicinal, sea salt and brine.
    Body
    Thick, syrupy and nice legs indeed.
    Palate
    Wow. What a wonderful dram. This is why Serg Valentin and Ralfy rates this Whisky so well. It has the complexity a young whisky yet is arrives like a refined aged, malt. Absolutely complex and rewarding. I tried earlier bottlings - consistent and elegant. Fudge chocolate, peat, smoke, good salmon, raisins, orange fruit, and some avocado. Beautiful.
    Finish
    Long lasting and rewarding. This is the all time greatest malt of our day. If your friend or family member gives this to you, he/she really loves you. I'm serious. ^_^

    What a beautiful whisky. This is not a beginners dram, try this once you've tried your blends, lowlands and mastered Laphroaig. Uigeadail also leads you into becoming a sherryhead, truly interesting indeed...

    The Dalmore 12 Year Old

    The Dalmore 12 Year Old Sep 9th 2011

    84
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark yellow amber
    Nose
    Citrus and fruit
    Body
    Very slightly oily with a touch of grit, not a lot of body. Mild to lightly medium.
    Palate
    Smoke, some cherry, a woodsy taste, not much earth. Differs from the nose.
    Finish
    Short finish. Does not last as well as an older dram might.

    Color and smell are very nice. The have the promise of an excellent find. The finish is the separater between this and something that is truly great. Not to say that this not worth the purchase of a bottle. This is an excellent whiskey that can be drank everyday. Great for a beginner or experienced nose.

    Knob Creek

    Knob Creek Sep 9th 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Rich caramel
    Nose
    Smokey, like a fine tobacco
    Body
    Full body
    Palate
    Oak, hint of sweetness
    Finish
    Lingering warmth

    My go to bourbon. A big step up from Jim Beam, Grandad, and Makers. In my opinion it is on par with much higher priced bourbons.

    Glenfiddich Gran Reserva 21 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Gran Reserva 21 Years Old Sep 9th 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber indicative of it's age
    Nose
    Floral sweet smells with a hints of sweets like toffee
    Body
    Has a solid body, sticks to the tongue and mouth
    Palate
    Fruit, leather, a hint of smoke and earth towards the end
    Finish
    Has a warm long finish and changes a few times after consuming. Sticks to the mouth and changes flavor as you lick your checks.

    This is my favorite whiskey. The 21 has very pleasant smell and smooth initial taste. It rounds off with a touch of smoke, earth and leather a little while after swallowing. Were the flavors to die off shortly after leaving the mouth, this would have earned a score in the 80's for me, but the change and definite tingle push it into the top spot. A real treat!

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old Sep 2nd 2011

    79
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber + 1 (due to E150A)
    Nose
    Typical JW nose, slightly peaty, floral, and sweet.
    Body
    Medium body for a malt blend. Not bad. Decent legs. Be careful not add too much water because it will drown the whisky.
    Palate
    Peat, slightly medicinal, floral, raisins, has a sherry character to it, decent quality for a JW brand.
    Finish
    Finish fades quickly. Not a memorable dram but decent enough for a family gathering.

    It's a JW Black but with refinement and sophistication. Slightly higher ABV strength but I have to give this an 79 because the selling price is outrageous, it's chill filtered, and due to the E150A artificial coloring.

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label Aug 25th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden Amber
    Nose
    Smokey, Very Peaty, Dewey, with pronounced hints of vanilla and citrus
    Body
    Very light yet rich, almost like cream.
    Palate
    Peat, oak, almond, and a bit of spice. Extremely smooth
    Finish
    Long yet unobtrusive, very warming and resonating.
    Johnnie Walker Blue Label

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label Aug 23rd 2011

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light golden amber
    Nose
    Faint flowers and fruit. Maybe a little peat.
    Body
    Medium-light. Seems to get lighter with every sip.
    Palate
    A little honey, smoke and flowers all rolled together. Peat is almost absent.
    Finish
    Finish is somewhat short and wimpy.

    This is smooth and balanced; just as you would expect from JW. But the profile doesn't match the price.

    Bowmore 12 Year Old

    Bowmore 12 Year Old Aug 19th 2011

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Medium amber
    Nose
    Lots of smoke, mild peat.
    Body
    Very, very smooth. When I first picked up the bottle, it was very smokey indeed. Now I definitely taste some peat.
    Palate
    Peat and smoke--maybe a touch of grass.
    Finish
    Medium finish. Warm and pleasant. I would have no qualms about picking up another bottle!

    My absolute favorite whiskey (admittedly I haven't tried all that many--maybe thirty or so, including blended scotch)!

    Bowmore Darkest

    Bowmore Darkest Aug 5th 2011

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark honey
    Nose
    I get peat, oak, a flowery scent and as it develops, a little honey
    Body
    Medium-full body
    Palate
    Peat, slight saltiness. Confirmation of the nose.
    Finish
    Balanced finish, long but not overwhelming like a Lagavulin. A little dry. Good stuff.

    Complex peat. Can be served after a Highland Park ans before an Ardbeg, in terms of the amount of peat. I will come back to it. Very nice addition to my collection.

    Jack Daniel's Gentleman Jack

    Jack Daniel's Gentleman Jack Aug 1st 2011

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber
    Nose
    Vanilla-carmel tones, mildly woodsy.
    Body
    Light, but full at the same time. Clean.
    Palate
    Woodsy, spicy, and a hint of carmel and vanilla.
    Finish
    Warming, but not hot. Lasts long enough to enjoy, but short enough to where you can enjoy something else later.

    This is a good whiskey for everyday drinking. Smooth, flavorful, and less harsh than Old no.7. I enjoy this whiskey.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength Jul 27th 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber -1
    Nose
    Lap 10 to the 10th power. Strong, powerful, smokey, peaty, blast of smoke.
    Body
    Thick, full, and luscious. Nice legs on this.
    Palate
    Medicinal, peat blast, smoke blast, slightly citrus, very sweet but the smoke over powers your tongue and senses. Wow, not for the beginner, you need some time to get to know the spirit.
    Finish
    Long lasting, finish. Smoke stays in the morning even after brushing my teeth. Now that's amazing.

    This review is for the "vatted" red stripe cask strength, pre-batch period.

    Glenmorangie 10 Years Old

    Glenmorangie 10 Years Old Jul 25th 2011

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light gold
    Nose
    Fruit (citrus, pear), vanilla, and sweet spice, getting to honey or caramel.
    Body
    Light.
    Palate
    Did not confirm the nose. It went on an acidic note, almost getting to bitter places. Short finish. After 20 minutes the whiskey evolved very nicely and I was able to pick strong oak and vanilla.
    Finish
    Short finish. Not a highlight of this whiskey.

    Good whiskey to round your collection, although not one of my favorites. Would buy again.

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Jul 20th 2011

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber, light to medium dark
    Nose
    Surprise. Light, fruity, citrus, oak, vanilla. Also a strange wood smell resemblant of the smell of Martin guitars. Smoke is hardly noticeable, but overall a highly interesting nose.
    Body
    Light.
    Palate
    Vanilla, citrus, chocolate, oak. Very pleasant and light.
    Finish
    Almost non-existent. Disappointment.

    Certainly an interesting and pleasant whisky with a fantastic nose, but overall disappointing for the price tag.

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label Jul 15th 2011

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber -1
    Nose
    Citrus, lemon, orange, slight peat, and a tad bit of smoke.
    Body
    Medium bodied, nothing too impressive on the legs.
    Palate
    Very slight peat, very smooth with citrus flavors, strawberry, and peaches.
    Finish
    Decent finish but ends too quickly.

    This is a decent dram but the price does not justify the quality of the spirit inside the bottle.

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Jul 15th 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber -2
    Nose
    Typical medicinal laphroaig but fruitier. Lemony, burnt apples, and sea salt.
    Body
    Medium bodied to light. Shows it's a young whisky indeed.
    Palate
    Again, lemony, fruity like apples, oranges, and less medicinal like the original Lap 10.
    Finish
    Finish stays but not as long as the regular 10 or the cask strength 10.

    The QC of laphroaig in my opinion seemed lacking if not half baked... I'd rather spend the much more affordable Lap 10 or upgrade to the CS 10 instead... The QC is decent but it won't be an everyday sipper for me...

    Oban 14 Year Old

    Oban 14 Year Old Jul 11th 2011

    79
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Full Gold
    Nose
    Fresh peat, a little maltiness
    Body
    Firm, smooth
    Palate
    Fruity seaweed and a little smoky. Dry
    Finish
    Aromatic and smooth

    I think this is a good scotch. I would put it in the top 10 of those I've had, but not top 5. I felt it was a bit too light for my palate

    Ballantine's Finest

    Ballantine's Finest Jul 9th 2011

    60
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold
    Nose
    Appel
    Body
    Thin
    Palate
    Apple, Vanilla, Caramel. Simple.
    Finish
    Not anything to write home about.

    Feels simple and cheap

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label Jul 9th 2011

    96
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light gold
    Nose
    Fine
    Body
    Thick, oily, perfect.
    Palate
    Candy, explosion, complex, sweet, fruit. Mix of many tastes coming in high frequency sequences. Mild.
    Finish
    Explosion of tastes, in medium time fades into a singel distinctive taste that holds for a very long time.
    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Jul 9th 2011

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light gold
    Nose
    Smoke
    Body
    Full bodied, Strong binded
    Palate
    Smoke, pepper, sweet chillipepper
    Finish
    Short to medium, more spicy than warm.
    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve Jul 8th 2011

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Yellow
    Nose
    Earthy
    Body
    Thick and Rich
    Palate
    Hot Peat
    Finish
    smokey, strong and long

    My favorite so far , but have tasted only a few.

    Monkey Shoulder NAS

    Monkey Shoulder NAS Jul 3rd 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    I really enjoyed this whisky and have suggested it to a few friends. will definitely drink it again

    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve

    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve Jul 3rd 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    I'm color deficient, but I'd say light gold
    Nose
    Citrus, but rather bland
    Body
    Very light and fluid
    Palate
    Watery, faint coffee and carmel
    Finish
    Smooth medium finish
    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Jun 25th 2011

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Deep gold
    Nose
    Peat, salt, smoke
    Body
    Light body, not oily or creamy
    Palate
    Slate, cacao, tabacco, hint of iodine
    Finish
    Medium finish, ends dry and quiet with more granite and slate

    A bit austere; not at all sweet. A nice changeup from sweet Highlands scotch. Not as peaty as Laphroiag, which I liken to Anbesol.

    Glenfiddich Special Reserve 12 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Special Reserve 12 Years Old Jun 24th 2011

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale gold
    Nose
    Refreshing green fruit[apple and pear],honey
    Body
    citrus,sugary sweet, green fruit[perhaps green apple],peppery, salty
    Palate
    honey sweet follow by souring. hint of green apple,caramel flower
    Finish
    short warm peppery with flora sweet
    Glenfiddich Ancient Reserve 18 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Ancient Reserve 18 Years Old Jun 22nd 2011

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    Fantastic and smooth just on the rocks! Only scotch I can drink straight and love it!

    Jack Daniel's Old no7

    Jack Daniel's Old No7 Jun 20th 2011

    60
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark amber - don't let it fool you. It doesn't mean it's better.... Sorry to say.... All caramel and no character indeed...
    Nose
    Charcoal, petrol, young whisky.
    Body
    slight legs, not as thick as I expected, somewhat of a let down on the body.
    Palate
    No peat, young whisky, plenty of charcoal. In fact, the charcoal hides all the flavors.
    Finish
    Finish is bitter and immature. At 40% ABV, that's unfortunate.
    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Jun 18th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Similar to the skin tone of a beautiful thai girl on the beach.
    Nose
    Oak, peat, alluring
    Body
    Full bodied similar to a Sumo wrestler. It packs a wonderful punch.
    Palate
    Warmth, oak, salty, a welcome assault of the taste buds.
    Finish
    A long finish that often prompts me to have another wee dram!

    A fabulous whisky that should all be given to me!

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay Jun 12th 2011

    81
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Nice golden honey brown with good legs.
    Nose
    Smoke, Peat, leather, spices and slight alchohol. Fairly complex.
    Body
    Medium body but yet soft at the same time.
    Palate
    Slightly sweet spices at the beginning of the tounge fallowed by a strong but not unpleasant leather/ peat and very slight alchohol burn at the back of the throat. Fairly interesting because the flavor is different than expected by the nose.
    Finish
    Not the longest finish ever by anymeans but good. Slight alchohol burn. The leather is replaced by a mildly sweet fruit/ spice finish.

    I'm new to all Scotch other than the basic Speysides so I don't know my Islays too well though I've sampled plenty of different American and Canadian Whiskeys/ Bourbons as well as other distilled drinks. I've never tasted anything like this. Probably a good entry into the world of Islays. It's priced low. If most the other Islays fallow the lines of this I'd be pretty damn happy! Score is based on the value of the Scotch. I'd drink this over Glenfiddich or something generic like that.

    Aberlour a'bunadh

    Aberlour A'bunadh Jun 9th 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Deep Red Copper
    Body
    Full
    Palate
    Chocolate and Orange and Sherry fruit
    Finish
    Long, warm, tingly.

    Feel it in yer ears

    Jameson 18 Year Old

    Jameson 18 Year Old Jun 9th 2011

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Slightly dark amber
    Nose
    Flower fragrance and new leather couch
    Body
    Of medium viscosity
    Palate
    Caramel, orange, apple
    Finish
    Minimal afterburn and a warmth that hugs the back of the tongue.

    This is an awesome release. If you've only tried the standard Jameson, get hold of this -- it's world's apart -- can vouch your money won't be wasted.

    Monkey Shoulder NAS

    Monkey Shoulder NAS Jun 7th 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber gold
    Nose
    Vanilla, citrus, woodsmoke
    Body
    Smooth, disconcertingly light.
    Palate
    Dark chocolate, almonds, woodsmoke
    Finish
    A long warm and smooth finish.

    Monkey Shoulder is a delight, the whiskey for non and new whiskey drinkers, as well as a consistent pleaser for more experienced whiskey drinkers. The nose is misleading as it gives the impression of a heavy drop, with a hefty impact. In reality, it's smooth and almost gentle, but with enough grunt in the finish to keep you interested. A whiskey for every day.

    Bushmills Malt 10 Year Old

    Bushmills Malt 10 Year Old Jun 5th 2011

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    sun bleached wheat
    Nose
    floral, sherry, coying sweetness
    Body
    smooth; competent but nothing to write home about.
    Palate
    big copper tang, ash? something bloody or metallic.
    Finish
    medium finish, unremarkable.

    A competent Irish whiskey that for the price still left us with the buyers remorse. Unlikely to offend but highly unremarkable to experienced Scotch drinkers.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Jun 4th 2011

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Earth and granite. Some peat evident
    Body
    Full and earthy
    Palate
    warm, stony, and natural
    Finish
    A long finish, reminds me of a nice cigar.

    Smoky and refined, I always come back to this!

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Jun 4th 2011

    97
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden Amber
    Nose
    Medicinal, with a faint trace of fine pipe tobacco...
    Body
    Pure nectar, a wonderful feel, slightly syrupy...rich and luxurious
    Palate
    Slightly salty, dazzling smokiness, with the faintest traces of vanilla and almonds...
    Finish
    A wonderful afterglow, extremely long and satisfying....A kingly Islay malt that will put a smile on your face

    Not for the inexperienced....must be sipped from a Glencairn nosing glass to truly be appreciated...a monstrously good scotch...highly addictive to Islay scotch fans..sure to be a favorite among the purists

    Monkey Shoulder NAS

    Monkey Shoulder NAS Jun 1st 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    AMBER
    Nose
    SWEET
    Body
    OILY
    Palate
    INITIALLY SMOOTH
    Finish
    BAD AFTERTASTE

    GOOD TO THE NOSE AND REASONABLE INITIAL TASTE BUT EXTREMELY BITTER AFTERTASTE WHICH WAS MOST DISAPPOINTING I WILL NOT BE DRINKING THE REST. GREAT BOTTLE, WILL PROBABLY HAVE TO SERVE IT TO MY BOGAN FRIENDS WITH COKE

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Jun 1st 2011

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    penny
    Nose
    Peat peat and more peat
    Body
    Think
    Palate
    More peat, but in a great way
    Finish
    It is a very warm finish that is long and lingering.

    So I hated Laphroaig 10 at first but after a few fingers of it, I fell in love. The quarter cask is even better. Its so unique and its amazing the 180 degree turn I did on this. If at first you dont like it, Give it a few more chances, you will love it.

    Bushmills Original

    Bushmills Original May 28th 2011

    74
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Very pale compared to american bourbons
    Nose
    Vanilla
    Body
    Light bodied.
    Palate
    Honey sweet taste but not too sweet
    Finish
    Slightly sour and metallic. Warm.

    Very smooth. First sip threatened boring but improved as I continued drinking it.

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old May 28th 2011

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light pale anber
    Nose
    salty earthy
    Body
    light
    Palate
    carmelly
    Finish
    warm and good after taste

    Looking for Irish single malt, settled on the twelve year scotish.

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old May 24th 2011

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber -1
    Nose
    Fruity, orange and banana with mangoes.
    Body
    Light bodied, decent legs.
    Palate
    The fruit smoothy of scotch whisky.
    Finish
    Decent, wonderful finish.

    Great starter whisky. Highly recommended.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Cask Strength May 24th 2011

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber + 2, suprisingly darker than Laphroaig 10 & Quarter Cask.
    Nose
    Smoke, peat, heather, burnt wood, ozone.
    Body
    The thickest, oiliest scotch I have ever seen. I thought the Lagavulin DE and the Ardbeg Uigeadail was thick, this thing is creamy!
    Palate
    This is truly the flagship of the Laphroaig expressions. Wonderfully smooth, yet exhibits a tremendous amount of peat, smoke, sea salt flavor, leather, dirty rocks, dirty boots, dirty socks, all in a good way. Not for the faint of heart...
    Finish
    Delightful, lang lasting, finish. Stays with you until your next sip. Outstanding.

    This is a review for Batch 002. Peat blast, smoke blast, completely in your face. Phenolic, seaside beach party, Smooth, lovely, long finish. Slight taste of alcohol. The only thing lacking is the complexity and the fruity flavors the Laphroaig 10 regular held. I gave the regular Lap 10 a "95," but I must point this as a 91 due to the expensive price (-2) and lack of complexity (-2) it holds. For extreme peat lovers, my goodness you cannot miss this dram.

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old May 21st 2011

    94
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Caramelo Dorado
    Nose
    Fuerte, te abre el pecho, tipo vick vaporub y un poco de ahumado
    Body
    Punzante, es como que le sentis todo el cuerpito
    Palate
    Picante, Dulce y Suave
    Finish
    Largooooooo, te pone en pausa

    Se siente todo, de principio a fin es una experiencia. Todos los momentos son intensos desde que se paga pasando por abrir la botella hasta que se traga.

    Black Bottle Original Blend

    Black Bottle Original Blend May 20th 2011

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber
    Nose
    Peat, light smoke, butter.
    Body
    medium body, decent legs, wonderful texture.
    Palate
    Light smoke, light peat, butter scotch, slightly phenolic, very gentle on the tongue. Not the typical Islay peat blast like Islay and Ardbeg. More reserved for it's character. A good affordable/starter dram for those curious about Islay whiskies. Wonderful craft indeed. Highly recommended.
    Finish
    Slight warming finish but goes away quickly. Still a good dram.

    This is a decent blend. What makes it so attractive is the wonderful price and the quality!

    Tamdhu Fine Single Malt Scotch Whisky

    Tamdhu Fine Single Malt Scotch Whisky May 19th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    brownish clear
    Nose
    my own
    Body
    average
    Palate
    no thanks, i just ate
    Finish
    Goodbye

    very cool name

    The Balvenie Portwood 21 Year Old

    The Balvenie Portwood 21 Year Old May 18th 2011

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Burnt orange
    Nose
    Wood, smoke, citrus and flowers.
    Body
    Heavy, but not harsh.
    Palate
    Lots of sweet port, smoke, freshly-squeezed oranges. It gets even better at the bottom of the glass.
    Finish
    The finish is extremely dry and long-lasting. Like smoking a good cigar.

    Wow. This is what Scotch is all about--and I've tried a lot. The flavors and aromas are extraordinary.

    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve May 17th 2011

    97
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale amber.
    Nose
    Reminiscent of laphroaig 10 y.o. but not as strong.
    Body
    Medium body.
    Palate
    Very tasty, reminds me of laphroaig but not as strong - decent enough.
    Finish
    Peaty finish. Warm and tasty. Highly drinkable. If you want to start your peat exploration, this is a good start bottle.

    Great bottle. Has braille on the bottom of the bottle for the blind. Excellent. Finlaggan is the first bottle I came across who's taking consideration for the handicapped. Nicely done. This is a big point booster.

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old May 14th 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale amber
    Nose
    Hospital smell
    Body
    NyQuil
    Palate
    Mentholatim mixed with whiskey.
    Finish
    The medicine taste lasts 20 seconds or longer.

    Tasted like cough syrup.

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old May 10th 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    hint of oak
    Body
    full bodied
    Palate
    a sweet woody taste
    Finish
    very nice finish

    A very fine smooth Scotch with a hint of fruit & vanilla

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old May 10th 2011

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Bright shining gold
    Nose
    Intense peat and alcohol.
    Body
    Medium build, nice legs, slow descend.
    Palate
    You won't get Ardbeg or lagavulin with this one, this is strictly laphroaig in all it's glory. Hazelnut, hint of sweetness, dirt in a good way, ash in a good way, smoke, and wonderful peat. In-Your-Face status. If you give your non-appreciating guests this drink, they will stir away from scotch for all time. For the scotch enthusiasts - provide a blind tasting and they won't know the difference between this or the Brora 30 year old you're saving.
    Finish
    Long lasting finish that will have you coming for more. Great everyday dram.

    Best bang for your buck tipple. Everyday sipper status while not burning a whole in your wallet. I'm scoring this a 95 due to price and quality. The price is just excellent for a single malt of this caliber. Become a friend of Laphroaig and ditch the "J" walker.

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay May 9th 2011

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light honey color
    Nose
    Moderate peat and light smoke with some indistinct fruit in the background.
    Body
    Moderately rich and smooth with good legs up and down the glass.
    Palate
    A half-bale of peat to be spread in the garden.
    Finish
    A good, but light finish, warming alcohol feel, but tailing off.

    About the best budget whiskey I've had as yet. Very drinkable; a real single malt experience; a peaty taste of Islay. Bought at a state liquor store with a rebate for $16, it can't compete with Ardbeg on merits, but at 1/3 the cost, it sure does on price.

    Bunnahabhain 12 Year Old

    Bunnahabhain 12 Year Old May 6th 2011

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    dim orange gold
    Nose
    burnt sugar, raisins, mild peat
    Body
    full, oily
    Palate
    starts out almost brandy like, raisins again, toffee, pretty consistent with the nose
    Finish
    peat comes out in a long finish, touch of salt maybe

    This is for the new 46.3 proof. Lovely

    Glenfarclas 12 Years Old

    Glenfarclas 12 Years Old May 4th 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale amber
    Nose
    Vanilla oak
    Body
    Light on the tongue, then thickens.
    Palate
    An elegant level of peat (not too soft, not too strong)
    Finish
    A slight afterburn.

    Can be sipped straight. I think this could be my new favorite over Laphroaig.

    McClellands Highland 16 Year Old

    McClellands Highland 16 Year Old May 1st 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Pleasing
    Body
    Smooth
    Palate
    Rich taste
    Finish
    Warm & pleasing

    Best of the McClellands Scotch areas. Enjoying one rightnow

    The Macallan 18 Years Old

    The Macallan 18 Years Old Apr 29th 2011

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Subtle gold.
    Nose
    Hints of fruit and sweetness.
    Body
    Surprisingly thick and coating.
    Palate
    Honeyed sweetness with traces of fruit. Also a nice crispness that hints of citrus.
    Finish
    Clean and pleasant. Remarkably crisp.

    Simply lovely. Not nearly as aggressive or challenging as the Islays that I usually love, but this is an absolutel pleasure to drink. Smooth, flavorful, and well-balanced.

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Apr 13th 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    what am I, Martha Stewart?
    Nose
    smoke and oak.
    Body
    thinner, slightly more viscous than Laphroaig 10, due to the higher alcohol content
    Palate
    Laphroaig peat, Tarred railroad ties, after the rain. Burning wet oak. This is the only thing you will taste for about 20 minutes.

    I am a huge fan of the Laphroaig 10, and Ardbeg, as well. But this malt goes too far. If you've ever wanted to drink a barrel, this is the scotch for you.

    Yamazaki 12 years old

    Yamazaki 12 Years Old Apr 13th 2011

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden brown.
    Nose
    Woody and earthy, with a hint of fruit.
    Body
    A bit syrupy.
    Palate
    A bit of fruit. Tastes of nuts and definite wood flavors.
    Finish
    Surprisingly smooth for the all of the initial flavor and punch. Taste doesn't linger long at all.

    My first Japanese whisky and it made me want to sample some more. I still prefer my Islay Scotches, but this was a worthwhile experience.

    Yamazaki 10 Years Old

    Yamazaki 10 Years Old Apr 12th 2011

    79
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Cheap laminate flooring, a not-quite-right yellow brown.
    Nose
    Mixed peels, nutmeg, woodsmoke, something sweet that's not quite vanilla. Fairly complicated.
    Body
    Warm, round, quite full. What the nose leads you to expect.
    Palate
    Dry, quite sharp fruit. Seaweed. Dry rotted wood. A little dusty, but in a good way.
    Finish
    Slightly alcoholic, nasal. Tapers quickly.
    Ezra Brooks Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Ezra Brooks Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Apr 10th 2011

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber Deep Gold!
    Nose
    Orange, and maple syrup vanilla.
    Body
    Creamy.. but hot... Smooth and firm..
    Palate
    Maple, vanilla cream... sherry?
    Finish
    Warming... and sweet like melons

    Honey and maple... Kicks you hard but very smoothly!!!

    Yamazaki 12 years old

    Yamazaki 12 Years Old Apr 9th 2011

    79
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden.
    Nose
    Slightly sweet with earthy undertones.
    Body
    Slightly thick and syrupy.
    Palate
    Can definitely taste the sweetness of the sherry casks. Hints of fruit and a touch of cream.
    Finish
    Smooth, yet with just a hint of a burn. Doesn't last very long.

    A nice Japanese whiskey that seems to be in the Speyside style. A little lacking in complexity, but definitely a worthy whiskey. This proves that the Japanese whiskeys can hold up to the Scotch single malts, no problem.

    Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky

    Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky Apr 9th 2011

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Honey brown
    Nose
    Sweet molasses, cinnamon spice, carmelized orange peel
    Body
    Thick and chewy
    Palate
    Orange and cinnamon with hint of dark chocolate and pepper
    Finish
    Longer than regular Makers with a touch of wood embers on the end

    This is for the new Maker's 46 where oak staves have been added to classic Maker's barrels for a few extra months of maturation. It adds a bit of spice and lengthens the finish. Very nice full flavor that builds on Maker's classic base.

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Apr 8th 2011

    97
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Light smoke, cherry
    Body
    Oily
    Palate
    A waltz into peat and smoke with a sweet pepper finish
    Finish
    Long lasting tingly numbness

    Laphroig fans will love this

    Ballantine's 12 Year Old

    Ballantine's 12 Year Old Apr 6th 2011

    76
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden honey
    Nose
    Smokey and earthy smell.
    Body
    Thick and firm body.
    Palate
    Peaty, smokey, vanilla, slightly sherry, cocoa, brine, young, fresh dirt, salmon, newly lit cigarette ash and burnt hair.
    Finish
    Lovely finish - Flavors hit all at once. Ice is a must unless your a purist. Lovely finish.

    The best blended scotch whisky for the budget minded whisky enthusiast.

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Apr 6th 2011

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden amber.
    Nose
    Signature laphroaig smell. Islay at your doorsteps type feeling when smelled.
    Body
    Thick and full bodied.
    Palate
    Earthy, big peat, smokey, sea salt, briny, seaweed, sashimi driven, soap, and fresh dirt.
    Finish
    Wonderful finish with a smooth lasting flavor for every sip.

    An improvement for the 10 year old. The quarter cask has become my every day sampler.

    Jack Daniel's Old no7

    Jack Daniel's Old No7 Apr 6th 2011

    71
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark copper
    Nose
    A hint of cocoa, brown sugar, and vanilla.
    Body
    Light body.
    Palate
    Smokey, sweet, grassy taste, dry popcorn with no peat whatsoever.
    Finish
    Lovely, smooth, and long lasting finish. It's a sipper for sure.

    Absolutely lovely whiskey on the rocks.

    Bowmore 12 Year Old

    Bowmore 12 Year Old Mar 31st 2011

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light gold
    Nose
    smoke with some peat very distant light fruit
    Body
    thin and oil
    Palate
    peat smoke tiny hint of salt, spice, nice and peppery
    Finish
    long though not very complex but definatly islay

    a decent scotch for the price, though it could have more depth

    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label Mar 28th 2011

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Reddish amber.
    Nose
    Simple, earthy notes with a hint of vanilla.
    Body
    Light body.
    Palate
    Slight peat taste, smoke, amber, dark fudge and vanilla. This taste does not linger on but fades as soon as you sip another.
    Finish
    Hot and heavy finish for an 80 proof bottle. Drink it only if you have nothing else in your disposal.

    This is a sipper indeed. Grab your ice with this one. Add coke only if you have too.

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old Mar 28th 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark amber
    Nose
    Sweet, spicy, and iodine smell. Very subtle and simple indeed.
    Body
    Light body.
    Palate
    Mint chocolate, dark fudge, slightly peaty, smoke, and ash. Not very intimidating and simple.
    Finish
    Nice, decent finish. Lingers on until your next dram.

    A wonderful blended whisky for first time whisky drinkers.

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label Mar 28th 2011

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale gold.
    Nose
    Hardly any smell at all. The smokiness that black label provided is gone.
    Body
    Thick body.
    Palate
    A bit geriatric in nature. Slow and flavorless. I expected more for something this expensive.
    Finish
    No kick, maybe a quick bite but nothing more. A one night stand gone wrong.

    For the Black label enthusiasts, you won't get a hint of "Black" in this "Blue."

    Aberlour a'bunadh

    Aberlour A'bunadh Mar 28th 2011

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Intimidating red
    Nose
    Medicinal and extremely masculine.
    Body
    Subtle body but don't let it fool you. This is one gritty whisky.
    Palate
    Vanilla sweetness barely creeps up but the alcohol conquers. Truly for the alcohol veteran. Not for the weak indeed.
    Finish
    You just got sucker punched and met your your match at the bar. Suddenly, your going for round two. Hot, heavy, and intense. Speysider Monster in the mist.

    I think I might need some extra work on this one. I wasn't able to adjust on the flavor. I'm the type of person that enjoys his whisky's nice and neat, but this one really needs some water... The flavor is absent considering all you taste is the alcohol...

    Talisker Distiller's Edition

    Talisker Distiller's Edition Mar 28th 2011

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark copper look.
    Nose
    Peaty, smokey, small hint of sea salt, banana, toffee, cocoa, dark fudge, slightly medicinal, yet refined.
    Body
    Thick, oily and sticky.
    Palate
    Peaty smoke comes rushing but takes a back seat after the sweetness and vanilla/chocolate flavor kicks in. Absolutely marvelous full flavor.
    Finish
    Long lasting finish. Warm and natural.

    Superb Single Malt. Distiller's Edition is a must have for the whisky enthusiast.

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old Mar 27th 2011

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Amber
    Nose
    Smokey
    Body
    Full Bodiedw
    Palate
    Smokey
    Finish
    Long and satisfying

    After sampling the Black label, i gave this a try. The work of art on this scotch is more than an understatement. Very satisfying to enjoy in small sips, and on the rocks. It has so much smooth and smokey flavor to it. Very pure and satisfying!

    Bruichladdich Links

    Bruichladdich Links Mar 27th 2011

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Reddish gold.
    Nose
    Subtle, with hints of leather and wood.
    Body
    Thick and syrupy.
    Palate
    Hints of iodine and peat, with a kind of bitter fruitiness - like slightly sour grapes or apples.
    Finish
    Very smooth, with a leathery quality.

    I had the St. Andrews issue. Almost put me in mind of Speyside as much as it seemed like an Islay.

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Mar 27th 2011

    72
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Nice light bronze.
    Nose
    Very sweet and aromatic.
    Body
    Smooth and a bit syrupy.
    Palate
    I got a creamy sweetness more than anything else. Most of the flavor seemed concentrated on the tongue, with little kick in the back of the throat.
    Finish
    Hints of vanilla. Very smooth.

    This had a nice sweet taste, and was easy to drink, but lacked the complexity and multiplicity of flavors that I look for in Scotch.

    The Glenlivet 16 Year Old Nadurra

    The Glenlivet 16 Year Old Nadurra Mar 26th 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale amber
    Nose
    hint of smoke and herbs
    Body
    Medium to full bodied
    Palate
    a hint of herbs and honey
    Finish
    very warm and aftertaste with a hint of liquorice

    Mine is 56.2% bottled in March 2008, and drinking in 2011

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Mar 25th 2011

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber with dancing firelight
    Nose
    Peat, honey, iodine hit first
    Body
    silky, heavy, oily
    Palate
    big hit of peat, then a seasalt emerges, and finally, a sweetnes right on the very tip of the tongue
    Finish
    Long finish, warm and delicious that begins on the upper palette and extends down

    This the first single malt I have ever had and I don't feel the need to try anything else; this one's perfect

    Ardbeg Uigeadail

    Ardbeg Uigeadail Mar 24th 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale amber, slight copper look.
    Nose
    Subtle. Hint of floral and peat.
    Body
    Full bodied.
    Palate
    Peaty, smokey, cocoa, cherry, caramel, mint, latte', and cheese cake.
    Finish
    Wonderful long finish. Almost like the Isle of Islay just washed ashore in my throat.

    Marvelous, full of flavor, and utterly unforgettable. Uigeadail conquers.

    Ballantine's 12 Year Old

    Ballantine's 12 Year Old Mar 19th 2011

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light gold
    Nose
    Hot and thin.
    Body
    Velvety and full.
    Palate
    Sugarish, some iodine. A complex blend for the price range. Satisfying.
    Finish
    Somewhat hot. Candyish. Coats the mouth well and sweetly.

    Wonderfully low-priced surprise. Old school reputation encouraged me to buy, and it was worth it.

    Bruichladdich Links

    Bruichladdich Links Mar 19th 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark Amber
    Nose
    Port and earth
    Body
    Full Bodied
    Palate
    walnuts
    Finish
    Long finish

    Each of the courses commemorated is actually a different scotch. You can't just label them "links." Please specify the particular bottle you sampled. I am discussing the Vancouver Club course. I have had many Bruichladdich bottles in my time. This is by far one of my favorites. It is a 16 year.

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label Mar 14th 2011

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Caramel
    Nose
    Saw Dust, Cotton Candy, Pencil lead.
    Body
    Perfection. This is one of Blue's strong suits.
    Palate
    Lemon, Toffee, Spice.
    Finish
    Still going.

    Spectacular. I am a long time scotch drinker. I drink more red wine than anything lately though. In my late twenties I drank quite a bit of whisky. I never had the money then to try some of this, but always loved Gold Label. I figured I would give it a go. I believe I can summarize my experience by saying "I have tasted many $100 bottles of wine, and thought, this is good, but not worth more than the typical $30 bottle. This "Blue" is worth every cent."

    Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Mar 14th 2011

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Caramel brown
    Nose
    Toffee, raisins, spice, currant, leather
    Body
    Smooth and luxurious like velvet.
    Palate
    A twinge of spice with plenty of almost dark chocolate aftertaste ... A nice lingering finish.
    Finish
    Lengthy but subtle. The earthiness shows up right at end in a pleasant sendoff.

    Took four months to finally find a bottle and I was not disappointed.

    Cragganmore 12 Years Old

    Cragganmore 12 Years Old Mar 12th 2011

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Straw
    Nose
    Fragrant with honey, salt, and some floral notes
    Body
    Very thin but not watery...just not much viscosity. Very light mouth feel.
    Palate
    Sugary...flavor goes straight to the roof of my mouth. Have to resist urge to gulp it down. Very tasty but almost too light.
    Finish
    Short, dry finish, but pleasant taste. No warming either. Satisfying but it's gone too quickly.

    Finally got to try it...enjoyable but didn't blow me away

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Mar 10th 2011

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold
    Nose
    Peat, Smoke, Vanilla
    Body
    Full Full Full
    Palate
    Salty with a strong almost iodine taste
    Finish
    Delicious, lingering smokiness

    Sensational on cold winter nights this is a flavour explosion well worth trying. A classic peaty, smokey Islay malt

    Glen Moray 12 Years Old

    Glen Moray 12 Years Old Mar 10th 2011

    79
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    gold
    Nose
    sweet, fruity
    Body
    medium
    Palate
    Vanilla, honey
    Finish
    Smooth

    As a value for money proposition this is a terrific scotch. Quite sweet with a medium body it is an ideal introduction to single malts.

    The Macallan Fine Oak 10 Years Old

    The Macallan Fine Oak 10 Years Old Mar 9th 2011

    79
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale Amber
    Nose
    Expensive caramel, spring rain, slight ring of fine bourbon, some smokiness.
    Body
    Medium-bodied, no real grit.
    Palate
    Mostly salty, with sweet overtones. Heavy caramel, but mixes well with the smoky texture.
    Finish
    A very long finish, with a spreading warmth that is felt in the fingers and toes. Distinct flavors radiate from the back of the throat.
    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Mar 8th 2011

    77
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dull gold
    Nose
    Some smoke, honey
    Body
    Moderate
    Palate
    Honey continues with peat intensifying just a bit
    Finish
    medium finish with an off-putting bitter note at the end
    McClellands Highland

    McClellands Highland Mar 5th 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light
    Nose
    smooth
    Body
    Killer round body
    Palate
    sneaky
    Finish
    Like an orgasm

    Great whiskey for a good price

    Bowmore 12 Year Old

    Bowmore 12 Year Old Mar 3rd 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Palate
    Cough-syrup

    I'm not an expert. I've thoroughly enjoyed Macallan's 12, Glenlivet's 15, Balvenie's Double 12, Glenrothes' 21, and Glenfiddich's 30. I did not enjoy this. It has a distinct cough-syrup aftertaste. Sorry if I'm offending anyone.

    Jameson

    Jameson Mar 3rd 2011

    65
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale amber
    Nose
    Light oak, slight sweetness
    Body
    Thin
    Palate
    A little bit of oak, malt, maybe a hint of smoke
    Finish
    Smooth, hint of alcohol.

    Surprisingly smooth. I would take this in a pinch.

    Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Feb 23rd 2011

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber.
    Nose
    Oak. A dash of cinnamon and other spices. Vanilla. Fermented fruit. Alcohol.
    Body
    Medium. Slight oil.
    Palate
    Fruity and spicy without being excessively sweet. A bit hot.
    Finish
    Long for a bourbon. Dried cherries. Warm tea near the end.

    One of my favorite Bourbons in its price range. Good enough to drink straight, cheap enough to be a great mixer.

    Longrow 10 Years Old Tokaji

    Longrow 10 Years Old Tokaji Feb 19th 2011

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden honey
    Nose
    Citrus, orange peel, lavender, fresh cut firewood, hint of cocoa
    Body
    Slightly viscous, coats the mouth without feeling heavy or oily
    Palate
    Honey, banana, hint of black pepper - spice mingles well with sweet, hints of peat and a subtle earthy musk
    Finish
    A silkiness that warms with honey and vanilla lingering

    A wonderfully comforting dram that strikes a marvelous balance between having a weighty enough palate and body to demand attention, yet retaining enough subtlety to keep from overwhelming you. You'll have to excuse yourself for having forgotten how many you've had, given how easily one pour follows the last -- at least I did.

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay Feb 16th 2011

    60
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Honey
    Nose
    Smoke, Iodine, Burnt Rubber
    Body
    Nicely smooth, slightly oily
    Palate
    Iodine, and Burnt Rubber
    Finish
    Very dry, short finish

    Very strong Iodine. Not much burn but overwhelming smoky, burnt oak and tar flavor. Regardless of price, I could not imagine drinking an entire dram.

    Jack Daniel's Old no7

    Jack Daniel's Old No7 Feb 16th 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Mild Amber
    Nose
    Oranges, glue
    Body
    Thin
    Palate
    Harsh, sour
    Finish
    Harsh

    harsh taste and lacking in complexity

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Feb 13th 2011

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    honey/amber/caramel
    Nose
    light peat and earthy tones
    Body
    medium very smooth body
    Palate
    a nice sweat twang with hints of sherry and light peat
    Finish
    the finish of this whiskey is great. Sherry undertones that melt into fading hints of vanilla and citrus

    For the money it does not get much better then this whiskey. A great whiakey thats easy to drink and easy on the wallet. Enjoy.. I know I will again..and..again..and ..again

    Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky

    Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky Feb 12th 2011

    96
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    almost burnt honey, slightly golden
    Nose
    sweet
    Body
    smoothe and medium thickness
    Palate
    reminds me of gentleman's jack
    Finish
    It has an easy punch at the end if taken chilled. your blood will warm up rather quickly.

    I remember my first time I tasted this whiskey, and it was one of the best whiskey brands I have had. It was a nice smoothe drink with great flavor. This is a must own for anyone's liquor cabinet.

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label Feb 11th 2011

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    Do a blind taste test between JWBlue and Teachers blend. Tell me if JWBlue is worth the extra $170! Try it, seriously! BTW Laphroaig 1/4 Cask is my favorite but for an everyday swill, Teachers can't be beat!

    Jack Daniel's Single Barrel

    Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Feb 7th 2011

    96
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Roasted Walnut and dark maple
    Nose
    heavy alcohol, vanilla and maple, Oak and sweet woods
    Body
    Full and thick. Stands up well to ice and leaves long legs on the glass
    Palate
    sweet alcohol with a smokey sweet oak taste. Vanilla and nutty oak linger
    Finish
    Very long finish of alcohol, sugar, maple oak and vanilla

    A great whiskey full in flavor/ I dont know why JD gets all the negative comment I am not from the states and am more a single malt Macallan or glenlivet man. This is a special whiskey that should be charished

    Bowmore Dusk

    Bowmore Dusk Feb 5th 2011

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden Light Brown
    Nose
    Peat, smoke and ginger
    Body
    Very full and thick and smooth.
    Palate
    Peat, ginger and some smoke
    Finish
    A long finish and a solid end.

    A wonderful scotch, somewhere between a strong peaty flavor with a complex mix.

    Jack Daniel's Gentleman Jack

    Jack Daniel's Gentleman Jack Feb 1st 2011

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light golden brown
    Nose
    Charcoal, vanilla and honey
    Body
    Full bodied, thick and smooth
    Palate
    Charcoal, light smoke, vanilla, touch of corn and leather
    Finish
    Leaves you with a complete finish of a Tennessee whiskey. Warm with a little bite but mainly rich with flavorful hints of vanilla, caramel and oaky wood.

    If your looking for a good American sipping whiskey. Gentleman Jack is one of the best value plays out there. This sips smooth and has that unique Jack Daniels flavor we've come to know and love.

    Bushmills Malt 16 Year Old

    Bushmills Malt 16 Year Old Feb 1st 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Red amber brown
    Nose
    Fruit, rose, malt
    Body
    Clean and smooth.
    Palate
    Cherry, honey, corn, pomegranate and a hidden touch of tobacco
    Finish
    A warm smooth long lasting complex finish

    At first this whiskey will touch your palate with a sweet and smooth experience. It continues to maintain that state throughout your swallow. Only growing with a complex fusion of flavors from the different casks it was matured. This whiskey finishes with a beautiful blend of bourbon, sherry and port. Extremely interesting whiskey and one I highly recommend trying. Drink neat for there is no other way necessary.

    Glenmorangie Port Wood Finish

    Glenmorangie Port Wood Finish Jan 26th 2011

    94
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    copper
    Nose
    dried fruit, light smoke, mild cinnamon.
    Body
    super smooth, velvet comes to mind.
    Palate
    smooth with dried fruit, slightly nutty.
    Finish
    medium to long finish, sensational warm feeling in the belly.

    One of the Best. I highly recommend any of the glenmorangie range.

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label Jan 15th 2011

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Rich amber
    Nose
    Fine oak ssmoke with mild spice. Peaty
    Body
    Medium body. Comfortable
    Palate
    Oak fire with citrus spice. Earthy, peaty ,nutty
    Finish
    Medium finish. Comfortable.

    Put in the same class as JW Gold Label. Lesser nose than JWGL. Too pricey for what is so much like JW Gold.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Jan 13th 2011

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    heavy smoke,peat&phenol
    Body
    full body thick& yet smooth
    Palate
    peat iodine salt & smoke
    Finish
    nice long finish & warm.Good winter drink neat!

    the best!

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old Jan 12th 2011

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden
    Nose
    Floral
    Body
    On the lighter side but not thin, definitely some body there.
    Palate
    Oranges, oranges, oranges. I don't have the most sophisticated palate, but the orange flavor seems overwhelming to me. That's not a negative. Others mention toffee and salt. I detect a very faint saltiness, but the orange quality, coupled with floral hues, is up front.
    Finish
    Virtually non-existent -- but who cares? If I want a long finish, I'll opt for Laphroiag

    A very enjoyable, lighter Scotch, that goes down easily. Definitely a "go to" dram that will be a regular in my cabinet. It's also a great value. Binny's (Chicago area) has it for under $40, and it's recently been on sale for $28, a tremendous value. I bought two bottles.

    The Macallan 12 Years Old

    The Macallan 12 Years Old Jan 11th 2011

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber, red oak
    Nose
    Blackberry and red current with a bit of spice
    Body
    Medium bodied, luxurious and decadent
    Palate
    Spiced sherry with a bit of caramel and brown sugar
    Finish
    Smooth, a quick heat that doesn't linger but leaves a nice, warm honey like flavor in its wake

    My first "real" single malt and still one of my favorites. As adventurous as I get, I keep coming back to this as my "rock".

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Jan 11th 2011

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Caramel, golden hue like iced tea
    Nose
    Smoky with a mix of earthiness and orange spice
    Body
    Bites quickly but mellows even faster with a surprisingly light mouth feel
    Palate
    Toffee with a bit of smoke and nuttiness
    Finish
    a moderate finish with just a touch of heat, smooth and easy going down

    Incredibly well-balanced and easy to drink. Nice flavors combined with just enough heat.

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Jan 11th 2011

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Rich, honey/amber gold
    Nose
    Honey, citrus, almond, vanilla, maple
    Body
    Chewy, yet light. Coats the mouth with an almost honey like glaze.
    Palate
    Warm apple, caramel and brown sugar, sweet and spicy flavor that sticks to the roof of your mouth. Much better without water which it doesn't take well. Needs its thickness to hang around and let flavors develop.
    Finish
    Moderate finish - a little warming but not much. Drier than I expected. But barely any finish with water. Drink it neat.

    A very drinkable, flavorful dram that brings a smile to your face. A great scotch for kicking back by the fire on a cold winter's day.

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old Jan 8th 2011

    94
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Malty with slight sweetness and perfect peat
    Body
    Full
    Palate
    Complex
    Finish
    Long and satisfying

    Best scotch I've tasted in awhile

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Jan 8th 2011

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden amber
    Nose
    Peat, iodine, vaguely floral at the back. Very distinctive.
    Body
    Elegant. Supple without being syrup.
    Palate
    Not sure but the first time I tried it, I was grinning like a madman. Happens every time...
    Finish
    Goes on and on and on. Remarkable. Changes markedly with water (not my preferred way).

    One of the most extraordinary tastes in my life. Quite unique.

    The Glenlivet 18 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 18 Years Old Jan 7th 2011

    96
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    A rich dark gold maple syrup
    Nose
    Ginger Bread, lots of caramelized fruit with a very slight peat and smokey finish which hides behind the rich spice of this scotch
    Body
    Full Bodied and oily.Even at 43% the alcohol is far in the background behind the wonderful holiday spices and dark fruit. Does well with a small ice cube for every 1 and half or2 shots of scotch.
    Palate
    Over ice the Fruit, spice and peat come to life in such form you will forget you are drinking wherever you are and transcend to Scotland . Bottom line this Scotch just feels and reminds of Scotland.Smooth,great holiday spice followed by sweet sweet dark fruit and all without any bite on the palate. Neat- Obviously the alcohol is brought more to the fore front with the same but more intense holiday spice before cooling your palate with caramelized Pears, black cherry and cranberry. In fact neat is the only way i drink this when pairing it with an Anejo Fuente or Opus X cigar.
    Finish
    An excellent long and oily, smoked fruit finish with a slight hint of Christmas spice and peat. The finish really reminds you you are drinking a fine single malt. 43% you keep waiting for a bit that doesn't come which is common with Scotch aged properly over 15 years. The Glenlivet really took care of this stuff and it shows in the taste and quality.

    An unbelievable single malt. Its amazing what 6 extra years does to this Scotch. Smooth with just the right amount of oil along with holiday spice and caramelized dark fruit.

    The Macallan Fine Oak 10 Years Old

    The Macallan Fine Oak 10 Years Old Dec 30th 2010

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale amber
    Nose
    Vanilla and maybe a hint of grass
    Body
    Medium bodied, not at all like the Macallan 12 year old which is viscous, even syrupy
    Palate
    The vanilla continues with, of course, an oakiness
    Finish
    A short and rather cool finish with some alcohol burn

    Surprisingly dry. Rather like the Macallan 12 year old with the caramel and sherry flavors removed. So it lacks the comforting feel of the 12. I found this one to lack character. If I want something this light for the money, I'd go with the Acnoc 12 year old or the Benromach Traditional, both great values and better than this.

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old Dec 30th 2010

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Medium-dark amber
    Nose
    Smoke, citrus, wood, alcohol
    Body
    Medium to heavy. Very smooth.
    Palate
    Fruity and smoky. Light on peat.
    Finish
    The finish is spectacular. Long and smoky with a dash of fruit.

    Better and smoother than Black Label, although justifying the cost is difficult. If you're a JW fan, you won't be disappointed.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Dec 29th 2010

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden
    Nose
    Smoke and peat, followed by salt, and balanced with a hint of banana, liqourice, and caramel. A hint of vanila and wood lingers in the background
    Body
    Full bodied. Creamy.
    Palate
    Smoke and peat, with chrismas pudding, sticky date pudding, and banana bread coming though, balanced by nuts, charcoal, and woodfired pizza.
    Finish
    Long, strong, and elegant, it coats your mouth and throat in peat as it goes down, warming your body from the inside out.

    The most balanced and elegant whisky i have ever tried, and prehaps it is the most elegant islay of them all. Im a sucker for islay scotches and this is no exception. Gets a 92 so i have room for even better whiskys i may yet come across. Im barely 21.

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Dec 26th 2010

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Bronze
    Nose
    Smoke, Peat.
    Body
    Full bodied
    Palate
    Very spicy, smoky, iodine.
    Finish
    Very long aftertaste. Warm.

    Similar to Caol Ila 12 YO, but with a whole bunch of spices upon it. Very rich, lots of character. First whisky that opened up the world of whiskies for me.

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey Dec 26th 2010

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    medium copper
    Nose
    nice musky oak
    Body
    Medium
    Palate
    Sweet on the tongue
    Finish
    butterscotch, vanilla

    This is upscale whiskey.

    Isle Of Jura 16 Year Old

    Isle Of Jura 16 Year Old Dec 24th 2010

    68
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Beige
    Nose
    Boring
    Body
    Boring
    Palate
    Boring
    Finish
    Boring

    This is really dull stuff. Murray in his "Whisky Bible" calls it "flat," and he's not joking. I had this between a dram of the Acnoc 12 and the Laphroiag Quarter Cask, and it was a bit like intermission in the middle of a really good show. Not worth the $70, that's for sure.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Dec 21st 2010

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Tea
    Nose
    Like a guy named Pete smoking a cigar
    Body
    Liquid, moves around the glass
    Palate
    Burns my mouth for the first 3 or 4 glasses
    Finish
    It lasts as long as it takes to drink it

    The World's best Flavored Scotch !

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Dec 16th 2010

    97
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Honey Amber
    Nose
    Earthy Peat,salt air, Iodine, Boozy Alcohol.
    Body
    Thick,slick,oily.
    Palate
    Huge Peat and Iodine, salt. It taste like it smells, but explosively. With a slight touch of water it opens up to a Sweet and fruity smoky nectar. Delicious. Easy on the water, don't kill it.
    Finish
    Long, long finish. And, no surprise, lots of peat and alcohol, with a lingering fruity sweetness that makes you want to do that again.

    Not for beginners. Laphroaig is an acquired taste that becomes an addiction. There are other Islay Single Malts, but Laphroaig is the King. Slàinte!

    Talisker 175th Anniversary Edition

    Talisker 175th Anniversary Edition Dec 15th 2010

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Burnt Amber.
    Nose
    Peat and earthy. Sweet tamarind.
    Body
    Well rounded.
    Palate
    Burnt marsmallow.
    Finish
    Warm and sweet.

    A true delicacy. Well rounded....

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Dec 13th 2010

    83
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    GOLD
    Nose
    VANILLA, OAK, SLIGHT HINT OF SMOKE, PEAT, HONEY, TOFFEE, SOME CITRUS
    Body
    MEDIUM BODIED
    Palate
    HONEY, SHERRY, LIGHT PEAT, SMOKE, OAK, SPICEY, PEPPER
    Finish
    A VERY DRY MEDIUM FINISH

    ROBBIE

    Jameson 12 Year Old

    Jameson 12 Year Old Dec 13th 2010

    84
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    AMBER
    Nose
    MALT, A HINT OF VANILLA, CITRUS
    Body
    FULL
    Palate
    STRONG VANILLA, SHERRY, SPICY
    Finish
    A LONG SWEET FINISH

    ROBBIE

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old Dec 13th 2010

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    YELOW/GOLDEN
    Nose
    EARTH, LIGHT SMOKE, OAK, FLORAL, CITRUS, FRUITY
    Body
    MEDIUM BODY
    Palate
    SMOKEY, FRUITY, EARTH, SALT, OAK, PEAT
    Finish
    A LONG WARM DRY FINISH

    ROBBIE

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Dec 13th 2010

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    DARK GOLD
    Nose
    PEAT, LIGHT SMOKE, IODINE, HEATHER, HINT OF SWEETNESS, HONEY, OAK, SALT
    Body
    FULL BODY, OILY
    Palate
    A GREAT PEPPER TASTE, LIGHT PEAT, SALTY, OAK, SPICY
    Finish
    LONG, A BIT DRY, A PEPPERY BURN

    ROBBIE

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Dec 13th 2010

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    AMBER GOLD
    Nose
    SMOKE, HEAVY PEAT, SALT, MEDICINAL
    Body
    FULL BODIED, OILY
    Palate
    LOTS OF PEAT, SMOKE, SALTY, MALT, SWEET, CITRUSY, OAK
    Finish
    A LONG WARM FINISH

    ROBBIE

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Dec 13th 2010

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    LIGHT GOLD
    Nose
    HONEY, HEATHER, MILD SMOKE, HINT OF PEAT, CITRUSY ORANGE PEEL, MALT, CHOCOLATE, SHERRY,
    Body
    MEDIUM BODY AND SMOOTH
    Palate
    HONEY, HINT OF SMOKE, LIGHT PEAT, A LITTLE SALT, HINT OF VANILLA, A LITTLE SOUR
    Finish
    A NICE LONG SMOOTH FINISH

    RBBIE

    Caol Ila 12 Year Old

    Caol Ila 12 Year Old Dec 13th 2010

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    LIGHT STRAW
    Nose
    SMOKE, PEAT, CITRUS,
    Body
    THICK, OILY
    Palate
    MALT, SMOKE, SALT, PEAT
    Finish
    LONG FINISH, SMOKY, EXCEPTIONALLY DRY

    ROBBIE

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Dec 13th 2010

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    LIGHT GOLDEN/AMBER
    Nose
    HEAVY SMOKE, PEAT, SALT, EARTH, IODINE
    Body
    WET, FULL, STRONG
    Palate
    PEAT, SMOKE, SALT
    Finish
    VERY LONG AND WARM FINISH

    ROBBIE

    McClellands Highland

    McClellands Highland Dec 10th 2010

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light honey, amber
    Nose
    light wood, musk, fruity, wet sand
    Body
    light, thin
    Palate
    raw, floral, slight citrus, sweet
    Finish
    tickly, petrol, peppery

    worth trying to see if you like, but nothing special that I would buy again. There are many blends that I would rate higher. There is an omnipresent raw floral taste to this that I cannot escape and limits its appeal. It is not particularly complex or enjoyable but not terrible either. Your mileage may vary.

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old Dec 7th 2010

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light golden, honey coloured
    Nose
    Hint of Vanilla, caramel, honey, faint rasberry
    Body
    Starts off light and builds, slight smoke and spice, traces of fruit
    Palate
    Pears or apples, slight peat
    Finish
    Not much to the finish, lingering aftertaste of apple or pear, pleasent warm sensation after swallow, dry enough to be mouth watering

    Overall a pleasing single malt. Would be even nicer if the finish was stronger but the flavour is bold and meaty

    Strathisla 12 Year Old

    Strathisla 12 Year Old Dec 6th 2010

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Honey Amber
    Nose
    Oaky, equal parts of chocolate and butterscotch
    Body
    It has a fine gritty texture to it. Like mango. A thin texture.
    Palate
    Oak, Salt water taffy.
    Finish
    warm, but not too strong. Heat stays, flavor doesnt last as long as I would like.

    Love at first nose!

    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve Dec 4th 2010

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Peat, mild smoke
    Body
    Surprisingly light and delicate for an Islay
    Palate
    Peat, iodine
    Finish
    Relatively short finish. I disagree with a reviewer on one web site who suggested this had a bad aftertaste. No such aftertaste discerned.

    I've tried most of the Islay Scotches and am fond of the Laphroaig 10, Caol Ila 12, and Lagavulin 16. Given the price, I had to give this one a try, especially after reading one reviewer's "gasoline" description. Now I can't say whether this is a Lagavulin cast-off, as some contend, or a Laphroiag or something else, but I can say that it is excellent -- not at all like gasoline or any other form of motor fuel. As Islay Scotches go, in fact, the Finalggan is downright mild-mannered, and I do mean positively shy and retiring. This is a rather light Scotch, smokiness notwithstanding. You want gasoline, you go with the Ardbeg 10 year old. That stuff is in-your-face gruesome, a bitter mouthful of bog. The Finlaggan Old Reserve is to the Ardbeg 10 as a ballerina is to a professional wrestler. For Islay Scotch drinkers (something Mr. Gasoline obviously is not) this is a real bargain. Buy it!

    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label Dec 4th 2010

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold
    Nose
    Alcohol
    Body
    Alcohol
    Palate
    Alcohol
    Finish
    Alcohol

    Whisky? i wouldnt even call it Whisky.. Since it's taste is very poor and only smells Alcohol.. please spare your money for something better

    Springbank 10 Year Old

    Springbank 10 Year Old Dec 2nd 2010

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light gold
    Nose
    Lots of mild notes mingling with each other. Ocean, light smoke, wet vegetation, honey.
    Body
    medium bodied, slightly oily
    Palate
    Brine, a good amount of peat, hazelnut, honey, vanilla
    Finish
    Relatively long finish featuring peat and toated nuts with honey. Excellent finish.

    Craft presentation with no color added and no chill filtration. There is a good amount of peat here which seems to drown out some of the other subtle notes. Overall, a very good scotch!

    Glenmorangie 15 Years Old Sauternes Wood Finish

    Glenmorangie 15 Years Old Sauternes Wood Finish Dec 1st 2010

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold
    Nose
    Hint of burnt orange, nutty
    Body
    Strong yet mellow and smooth
    Palate
    Smooth, dry, hot on the tongue
    Finish
    Warm, tingly

    Surprisingly good given that I am no bourbon fan. Tastes more like a traditional scotch than a bourbon. Far too easy to like!

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old Nov 30th 2010

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale Yellow
    Nose
    Smokey Goodness, my favorite is to leave the glass out over night. The smell in the morning is beautiful
    Body
    Light oil
    Palate
    Nice Smoke , Salty
    Finish
    Long finish , leaves me wanting the next sip

    My favorite entry level dram, I dream about the nose on a regular basis

    Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select

    Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select Nov 18th 2010

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    certainly not golden, darker.... copper, darker yet than honey.
    Nose
    sweet oak.. quiet sweet, fruit and caramel..
    Body
    light to medium bodied.
    Palate
    Spicy, rye is present, oak and carcoal.. caramel... at 90.4 proof there is fleeting spirit present.
    Finish
    medium to long finish, certainly warm, malty. Alot of online reviews claim this as a top shelf whisky, at first i wasn't so sure, but after a few over a couple of days its only gotten more distinctive.
    Johnnie Walker Gold Label 18 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Gold Label 18 Years Old Nov 11th 2010

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Nice golden
    Nose
    Burnt nuts, smoke, earthy of moss
    Body
    Heavey,smooth. The whiskey wants you to keep it in your .mouth
    Palate
    Burnt nuts, smoke, earthy. sweet.
    Finish
    Long finish. Plesant stay. Warm with mild bite.

    Very smooth, easy on the pallet. Take your time with this whiskey. Savor it. It will surprise you.

    Cardhu 12 Year Old

    Cardhu 12 Year Old Nov 10th 2010

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Honey
    Nose
    A great nose for a beginner who has yet to be able to smell "fruity". Strong pear smell.
    Body
    Thick, almost syrupy.
    Palate
    Typical honey and spice of the speyside. If you like Balvenie, Dalwhinnie, and Aberlour you will like this. Perhaps a tad of bitterness?
    Finish
    Lingering smoky-spicy aftertaste that is of medium duration.

    Obvious why this is the drink of choice in Spain. It is pleasant, but more importantly it is utterly inoffensive. It's hard to get in the US at the reasonable price it is listed at in Spain... A drop of water opens it up tremendously.

    Forty Creek Barrel Select

    Forty Creek Barrel Select Oct 31st 2010

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Rich amber.
    Nose
    Sweet almonds, strong chocolate, warm earth.
    Body
    Medium to full body. Very smooth.
    Palate
    Chocolate and coffee, cooked apples, cinnamon.
    Finish
    Even and smooth finish, warm and lasting.

    Absolutely wonderful - really a happy surprise, especially considering the low price. Don't be fooled by the tag; this is a very, very high-class drink. Reminds me of a good dark rum in its character - that is, rich and sweet and smooth, without any cloying overtones or iodine. A very satisfying drink, truly top-grade.

    Aberlour a'bunadh

    Aberlour A'bunadh Oct 28th 2010

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark Reddish brown
    Nose
    At 60% alcohol even the nose can burn so I often added a little bit of water to this scotch. Upon first opening this one up it gave off a sweet apple aroma. The bit of water brings out light light smoke.
    Body
    It is full bodied and gives you an enjoyable numbness of the tongue.
    Palate
    It was very complex having flavors of apple, sherry, smoke and butter.
    Finish
    It is a little bit sweet and produces a nice burning tingle. What is especially great about the finish is the smokiness. The spice of the smoke flavor is wonderful because it is not overly peaty.
    Isle Of Jura 10 Year Old

    Isle Of Jura 10 Year Old Oct 26th 2010

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light caramel
    Nose
    (just poured) orange, spice, cloves... (let it sit), oak, vanilla, sweetness
    Body
    thick but light, gentle but for a small bite on the tip of the tongue
    Palate
    fruity, perhaps a hint of chocolate and nutmeg
    Finish
    like a warm hug that is released at just the right time

    First impression - it's rich and wholesome. Spend some time with this one. Better than expected. This unique whisky (only one from Jura) has earned its place in my liquor cabinet as I explore the different regions of Scotch single malts.

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old Oct 25th 2010

    83
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber
    Nose
    Floral, citrus, light smoke, distinct mescal note
    Body
    Medium
    Palate
    Dry, dry, dry.
    Finish
    Hot. Tingly.

    There are better choices for the price point (at least in Washington), but it's still quite good.

    Knob Creek

    Knob Creek Oct 23rd 2010

    83
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light mahogony
    Nose
    honey, and vanilla
    Body
    thick and syruppy
    Palate
    woodsmoke and fresh spices
    Finish
    deep burn in the throat

    This Bourbon (not Tennessee Whiskey) has grown on me. Not comparable to a Jack Daniels(Tennessee Whiskey) or Jim Beam, which are both possibly only good for mixing. Lots of burn, but some underlying complexity that comes out with a bit of water. Traditional Bourbon vanilla and honey. Not truly worth the price tag though.

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Oct 20th 2010

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber hue with a shimmer. Think Stanley Park at sunset.
    Nose
    This is such a layered scotch. Much moreso than, say, Macallan 12. When served neat, the nose is that of a dirty Q-tip; when on rocks for a minute or two, the honey tones come right to the top.
    Body
    Expansive. It holds a splash or melted ice quite well. Body is not diminshed when cooled due to the fact that the sweetness comes out so prominently.
    Palate
    When neat, the strong nose prepares the mouth adequately. First 2 seconds seem like spice, but is in fact peat. Subsides with a slight burn beginning in the back of throat and ending mid-chest. On rocks and cooled, the honey nose engenders a relaxation of the face as the preparatory command for a relaxing drink. Honey palate closes the deal. Expands in the mouth and goes down like silk.
    Finish
    Sting lingers when neat and has a dehumifiying effect - water back is helpful and a saltine cracker is as well to give the next drink some dry powder to work with. On the rocks, the finish is superbly clean and clarifying, expanded sweetness in the mouth recedes naturally and completely within about 5 seconds.

    This is the only scotch I drink at home though I have tried, and continue to try, others at Brandy Library and other such places in NYC. But, I always come back to this. The 12yr is even better than the 15 and 18, which drop the honey tones with increasing severity. The honey nose and body are what make this such an agreeable companion. I plan to begin buying this by the case.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Oct 6th 2010

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold to amber
    Nose
    Peat and dried apricots.
    Body
    Smooth, full bodied
    Palate
    Smoky peat and unsweetened apricots
    Finish
    Very long finish, and strong to the end

    Excellent

    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve Sep 15th 2010

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Wet straw.
    Nose
    Mild cedar, pinesol. Peat, dried dulce on a beach. A nose only appreciated by the initiated.
    Body
    Silky. Cough medicine.
    Palate
    Clover honey, smoke, almond extract.
    Finish
    Enveloping and lasting. Radiant warmth.

    This is old reserve owned and bottled by Bruichladdich. It's not Lagavulin per se as some have surmised here, but it does have those honey notes and the thick legs that you'd expect there. It is sold by Bruichladdich on the island and there is a bit of a hint that it was bottled by Bruichladdich in that Jim MacEwen is quoted on the box. It is a great bargain because you are getting the best of all Islay worlds: peat, seaspray and honey.

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old Sep 15th 2010

    79
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark amber
    Nose
    Grass cuttings and nutshells from Talisker, ditto the raisiny fruitiness that increases as the dram settles.
    Body
    Eucalyptus oil
    Palate
    Nutshells, wood, peat, smoke, giving way to raisins and other preserved fruits. None of the brininess of Talisker remains, nor does the pepper finish.
    Finish
    Short and woody.

    The most famous whisky of all time and Winston Churchill's favourite drink. A standard-issue bottle to have, but surprisingly subtle when you get down to it.

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Sep 15th 2010

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    White pepper, brine, oyster shells, nut shells, iodine, cut grass
    Body
    Turpentine
    Palate
    My first "serious" flirtation with single malt so far. Dazzling and at first a bit frightening: old fishing boats, the sand under a rotting pier, chopped grass, fish scales, burping after a seafood dinner. Later, was impressed by the sheer "savoury" nature of the dram - literally appetising, the combination of smoke, fish, salt and pepper being oddly mouthwatering. Later, on airing and watering, more fruity notes come up, like raisins and cherry glaces. Briny/fleshy odours more obvious when the whisky is swirled a bit.
    Finish
    I was at first impressed by the long, long white pepper finish; after ten, fifteen minutes began to wish it would last a little less long.

    Diving into the Atlantic ocean on a drizzly afternoon with a mouth full of cut grass and fish scales

    Strathisla 12 Year Old

    Strathisla 12 Year Old Sep 10th 2010

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Orange
    Nose
    Stale peat.
    Body
    Light.
    Palate
    Peat, orange.
    Finish
    Very consistant and no afterburn.

    A great value whisky.

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey Aug 9th 2010

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber, honey,
    Nose
    sweetish, alcohol, nothing special stands out.
    Body
    I couldn't really tell as I was trying not to spit it out. It speed bags the taste buds at the back of the palate like upcoming hurl.
    Palate
    Initial nasty flavor. Soon after that shock it settles into a reasonable bourbon taste.
    Finish
    Seemed to have a very long finish as I wondered what the heck just happened and looked at Joe who was wondering the same.

    This was a big letdown for me. The initial thought is it's polluted. It hits the tongue with a decidedly unpleasant and unexpected flavor. Surprisingly it settles out to be a decent bourbon after a few seconds. My bourbon buddy described the same experience.Not nearly as good as other bourbons in the price range. Initially it hits the back of the tongue like $3.50 rot got.

    Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select

    Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select Aug 6th 2010

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Polished Copper
    Nose
    Peat, mild sugar sweetness, and
    Body
    Medium Bodied. Smooth and well balanced.
    Palate
    Vanilla, caramel, and hints of peat.
    Finish
    Long and warm finish, but not overpowering.

    One of the better Bourbons. I regularly enjoy it neat or on the rocks, never mixed.

    Springbank 15 Year Old

    Springbank 15 Year Old Jul 15th 2010

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dull Caramel
    Nose
    Very Earthy, hints of Vanilla and Orange
    Body
    Full and heavy, but not exceptionally thick.
    Palate
    Very peaty and smoky. Grass and dried leaves.
    Finish
    Medium length. Warm, but not intense. Quite pleasant.

    A scotch drinker's scotch. Its strong peat will scare off a novice. Lots of smoke, excellent for a cold winter night. Very nice.

    Old Pulteney 17 Year Old

    Old Pulteney 17 Year Old Jul 12th 2010

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    dark gold
    Nose
    Honey, heather, earthy, vanilla, slight chocolate
    Body
    medium bodied
    Palate
    light peat, sea salt, slight iodine
    Finish
    medium finish with the vanilla-oak lingering in the bacground

    A bit smoother than the OP 12

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Jul 12th 2010

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark Gold
    Nose
    Sweet
    Body
    Light
    Palate
    Sweet
    Finish
    Brilliant finish with the taste of Scotch lingering, and not the ethanol.

    Superb whisky. Good value high end single malt.

    Suntory Yamazaki 12 Years Old

    Suntory Yamazaki 12 Years Old Jul 10th 2010

    81
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Slightly pale gold.
    Nose
    Like a newly upholsterd Japanese bar seat.
    Body
    Light
    Palate
    Delicate crevice of subtle citrus.
    Finish
    Afterburn.

    Excellent whisky.

    Dalwhinnie 15 Years Old

    Dalwhinnie 15 Years Old Jul 9th 2010

    74
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Sprightly gold
    Nose
    Spicy
    Body
    Soft but grainy
    Palate
    Dual taste of peaty salty flavours and ethanol.
    Finish
    Unpleasant.

    Not as good as expected from a 15 year old matured single malt.

    Glen Moray 12 Years Old

    Glen Moray 12 Years Old Jul 9th 2010

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale
    Nose
    Flowery
    Body
    Semi viscous
    Palate
    A hint of vomit. Peat.
    Finish
    Not very mellow; bit of a burn.

    Cheap for a single malt 12 year, but better tasting blendeds are more value.

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old Jul 9th 2010

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale yellow.
    Nose
    Burnt orange shrub.
    Body
    Yellow viscous fuel.
    Palate
    Orange, peat, salt.
    Finish
    A bit of afterburn.

    A fine fine whisky.

    Ballantine's 12 Year Old

    Ballantine's 12 Year Old Jul 4th 2010

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Caramel
    Nose
    Solid wooden block smell with peatiness.
    Body
    Smooth at first, then thickens.
    Palate
    Orange, peat, wood.
    Finish
    The pleasurable first taste is spoilt a bit by aftertaste which is strong and not mellow.

    Probably the pick of the common blended regulars on shelves (Johnny Walker, Chivas etc). Good value for money, but not immensely pleasurable straight. Best with a bit of water or on the rocks.

    Cragganmore 12 Years Old

    Cragganmore 12 Years Old Jun 28th 2010

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light gold
    Nose
    Lovely: peppery and fruity
    Body
    fairly thin, light
    Palate
    Corkboard and leather, pipe tobacco
    Finish
    Wood and tobacco coming on late, salt lingering. Finish is modest in length.

    This has become a favorite to have on hand. I find it never demanding, but there is enough subtlety there to keep things interesting.

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Jun 27th 2010

    96
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light golden
    Nose
    Earthen fire
    Body
    Soft
    Palate
    Tangy, Ocean spray upon a Galleon
    Finish
    Alcohol hits a few seconds in, crescends, then drifts away like a surfing wave.

    Exceptional whisky, an intenser version of Laphroaig 10

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Jun 25th 2010

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Medium gold
    Nose
    Peat, fair amount of smoke, and some kind of citrus fruit
    Body
    Oily and full
    Palate
    Simple and beautiful. They know they don't need to doll it up with other crap. Lots of peat; more than average smoke, and some sweetness; maybe honey?
    Finish
    Long, but not overlong, and surprisingly little burn for a young scotch.

    One of a kind; exceptionally peaty and smokey. A true Islay. Peat is more prominent than in any other malt I've tasted, but it is less smokey than Lagavulin, in my opinion. If you enjoy in-your-face flavors in your scotch, this one is for you.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Jun 22nd 2010

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark golden caramel
    Nose
    Like warm earth heated over shurbs.
    Body
    Viscous.
    Palate
    Nutty, peaty, orangey.
    Finish
    Lingering ascendancy making you thirstily want more.

    Have tried Glenlivet, Dalwhinnie, Bruichladdich, Glen Moray, Glenmorangie, Suntory, Ardbeg and this is absolutely deliciously the best.

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old Jun 16th 2010

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Yellow, golden
    Nose
    complex and balanced. Sweet peach, citrus rind balanced by sea breeze. Very inviting
    Body
    Light and oily
    Palate
    Initially salty and mouthwatering, mellows into a rounded malty flavour with hint of vanilla and nuts.
    Finish
    lingering finish, rounded and leaves you wanting more. Hot and peppery quickly fades to dry and warming.

    I fell in love with this whisky from the moment it hit my lips. Unusual and stands on its own. Many people criticise this whisky for tasting too salty or strange, however I must disagree. This whisky is subtly complex and is a refreshing change from the powerhouses. This malt is modest and a perfect everyday dram.

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay Jun 15th 2010

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light gold
    Nose
    Lightly smokey, slightly floral, earthy
    Body
    Light, with a wee harsh bite
    Palate
    Harsh oak flavours with a background of oak, sweet floral bouquet.
    Finish
    Calm and fading, still gritty but with a soft aftertaste

    A surprisingly good single malt for the price. It shows its young age with its harsh oak-flavored bite, but carries sweet secondary flavors of peat, salty sea spray, and floral. Distinctly Islay, which makes it unique among Scotches. An excellent value, and quite enjoyable.

    Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky

    Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky May 14th 2010

    79
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    orange/copper
    Nose
    Orange rind, burnt caramel, toasted bread
    Body
    smooth and light
    Palate
    toast, oranges, caramel, oats
    Finish
    a quick, but not spirited exit. a modest finish with sweet notes

    A good whisky for the price. Good enough for rocks, but needs a little more complexity for straight.

    The Macallan Fine Oak 15 Years Old

    The Macallan Fine Oak 15 Years Old Apr 29th 2010

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale,yellow
    Nose
    floral,fruit,light peat,orange
    Body
    thin syrup,light
    Palate
    bannanas and toast
    Finish
    smooth, lingering, warm

    Jim Murray rated this whisky a 94, I would have to fully agree. Not all scotch is about PEAT and Smoke, smooth fruit and floral notes are what this scotch is all about.

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old

    Chivas Regal 12 Year Old Apr 22nd 2010

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden
    Nose
    smoky bite. apple and nuts
    Body
    full bodied
    Palate
    bites with nuts and spice. Friut comes later
    Finish
    Long biting finish. Nice warm flavor to the end. Yes it tingles.

    Nice for a change. Enjoyable with friends and a good steak.

    Bushmills Original

    Bushmills Original Apr 22nd 2010

    59
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale gold
    Nose
    rubbing alcohol and wood smoke
    Body
    grainy
    Palate
    bitter smoke, peppery
    Finish
    too long bitter alcohol. Not to be rude but not enjoyable.

    Suitable as a whiskey to go with beer. Doesn't stand alone.

    Glenfiddich Special Reserve 12 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Special Reserve 12 Years Old Apr 22nd 2010

    74
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale gold
    Nose
    light smoke with gentel spice.
    Body
    smooth easy on the tongue.
    Palate
    light oak smoke with a sweet spice.
    Finish
    short finish, smooth, Like a "light scotch"

    Nice flavor however not impressive. There are blends that are better.

    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label Apr 16th 2010

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Alcohol and nutty
    Body
    Thick
    Palate
    Alcohol is the strongest, but a little bit of nutty and spice.
    Finish
    Hot and long.

    I have tasted JW Red Label side by side with Ballantine’s Finest, both blended whiskies and 8 years aged. A friend of mine was present helping with his opinions. Both of us reached the same opinion: Ballantine’s Finest was much better than JW Red Label. I can say that JW Red Label is one of the most overrated whiskies I’ve ever tasted. The alcohol taste is very present and the smell is very poor.

    Edradour 10 Year Old

    Edradour 10 Year Old Apr 16th 2010

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Honey.
    Nose
    Medul dates, almonds, rubber garden hose, sherry notes, and a touch of orange zest and wood smoke.
    Body
    Full, slightly oily.
    Palate
    Very creamy, with something like sherry or brandy. The alcohol tickles the back of the tongue just before the finish begins. Ginger. Slightly like weak rum. Bananas.
    Finish
    Smooth, warm, medium-bodied; not overpowering but not weak. Sweet creamy notes linger on the back of the tongue.
    Blanton's The Original Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey

    Blanton's The Original Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey Apr 11th 2010

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Citrus Orange and mild pepper
    Body
    Smooth and Even, like velvet
    Palate
    Caramel, brown sugar
    Finish
    Smooth lingering flavors. Close your eyes and enjoy.

    The only whiskey I have tasted that one should hide to avoid drinking a bottle in one sitting.

    Jack Daniel's Old no7

    Jack Daniel's Old No7 Apr 11th 2010

    51
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Mid Amber
    Nose
    Smoky, overwhelming alcohol smell
    Body
    Thin and watery
    Palate
    Hard to get past the harshness, also too sweet
    Finish
    Harsh
    The Glenlivet 15 yo French Oak Reserve

    The Glenlivet 15 Yo French Oak Reserve Mar 13th 2010

    71
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Full gold
    Nose
    Light citrus fruit, a hint of oak and ginger
    Body
    Thin and light
    Palate
    Sweet vanilla with smooth woodiness-hints of light fruit
    Finish
    The finish is what killed it- thin and quick with an antiseptic feel

    A decent whisky but not worth the money

    Jack Daniel's Old no7

    Jack Daniel's Old No7 Mar 12th 2010

    51
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Burnt orange
    Nose
    Sour, charcoal and alcohol.
    Body
    Excessively heavy and thick.
    Palate
    It's harsh, sour and burns the mouth.
    Finish
    Just bad.

    There is really nothing appealing about this whiskey. It's popularity is puzzling.

    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve Mar 9th 2010

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    warm amber
    Nose
    light peat and earthy
    Body
    soft, somewhat light with a satisfying aftertaste -- more refreshing than most Spesides
    Palate
    complex and hard to pin down -- subtle
    Finish
    not as warm as expected but also not harsh

    I like this whisky. Am not an expert, but have been to Scotland several times and have tasted my share

    Knob Creek

    Knob Creek Feb 26th 2010

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    rich caramel
    Nose
    Vanilla bean, overripe cherry, smoky oak
    Body
    Full and smooth
    Palate
    Vanilla, burnt sugar, orange peel simmering in water on the stove with cinnamon and cloves, numbing hits and reminds you that you're drinking 100 proof bourbon
    Finish
    Finish is long and perfectly warm, vanilla filled and rich with oak

    Knob creek is what bourbon is supposed to be warm and strong, just complex enough

    Knob Creek

    Knob Creek Feb 25th 2010

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Deep caramel
    Nose
    This one wakes up your nose and screams "bourbon". Heavy on the oak and leather.
    Body
    Probably among the fullest bodies out there. Thick, almost caramel-like.
    Palate
    Roasted maple, leather and caramel balanced with light notes of cinnamon.
    Finish
    A long, strong finish. Nicely warms the heart.

    This is a whisky best appreciated by a seasoned bourbon drinker. One to be savored. Don't you dare mix it.

    Crown Royal

    Crown Royal Feb 25th 2010

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale caramel
    Nose
    Very mellow wood , floral and candy notes.
    Body
    Light bodied. Gentle on the palate. Slightly sweet.
    Palate
    Nothing especially overwhelming. Just a good, all-purpose blend.
    Finish
    A surprisingly warm, mellow and creamy finish.

    This is by far the smoothest whisky I've ever enjoyed.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Feb 24th 2010

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    dark caramel
    Nose
    Sherry releasing peat smoke, iodine.
    Body
    Oily and substantial
    Palate
    Powerful peat smoke rising to sea air/seaweed
    Finish
    Big peat finish
    Black Bottle Original Blend

    Black Bottle Original Blend Feb 16th 2010

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale amber is good - paler than most blended standard stuff
    Nose
    Heather! Whiff of peat as well.
    Body
    Light-to-medium. A very pleasant tipple!
    Palate
    Heather is even more prevalent in taste than it is in the nose.
    Finish
    Long-ish and nicely floural.

    Lovely! You could pass this off as a single malt to many whisky drinkers (if decanted) and get away with it.

    Red Breast 12 Year Old

    Red Breast 12 Year Old Feb 12th 2010

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale amber
    Nose
    earth
    Body
    thick
    Palate
    the peat bogs of Ireland
    Finish
    warm and zesty

    best I ever had

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old

    Old Pulteney 12 Year Old Feb 5th 2010

    84
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold.
    Nose
    Hint of seaside, dried fruits.
    Body
    Light.
    Palate
    Hint of smoke and sea salt.
    Finish
    Pleasantly lingering.

    Very, very lovely!

    Jack Daniel's Silver Select

    Jack Daniel's Silver Select Feb 2nd 2010

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    classic jack
    Nose
    orange,alcohol
    Body
    thick
    Palate
    alcohol,bitter orange,sugar
    Finish
    i didnt like it

    after a couple of single malt drams,i really dont like this!it was like PETROL in taste...

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Jan 12th 2010

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    perfect
    Nose
    I prepare to smell my own way, try to avoid generalized terms.
    Body
    Also prepare to drink my own way, cliches not always suitable.
    Palate
    hint of smoke, lovely notes struck. Not bravura but v delicious
    Finish
    Admirable balance, not the most dramatic of its outer island cousins but lovely nonetheless

    Always thought this was beautiful whisky. KL

    Aberlour a'bunadh

    Aberlour A'bunadh Jan 10th 2010

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Copper
    Nose
    Almost like pure maplewater with a kick
    Body
    Light to medium in body but smooth as silk for the digestion when taken without water - the only way
    Palate
    a marvellous blend of seetness with adequate spice & earthy tones
    Finish
    you know you've taken a good saple of this as it does hang around for a considerable time.....very smooth with it however

    I've been introducing my Friends in Canada to this exceptional cask strength for approxiamtely 10 years. without exception, evryone I have introduced tis to is now fully aware of how a cask single malt should taste. Can't much more about it really other than although difficult to find int he Montreal area (only due to the increased patronage to the stuff locally) it maintains a constant presence in my bar. Good stuff.....

    Knob Creek

    Knob Creek Jan 9th 2010

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    A tiny bit of squeetness masked by potent fire.
    Body
    Very light and smooth, even textured.
    Palate
    A very woody taste once you settle into the glass.
    Finish
    Fiery from start to finish, the first few sips smolder in your throat.

    My favorite "storebrand" whiskey. It's high proof and reminds you as such, with alcohol a dominant present in the nose and throat upon first sip. Once you settle in though, it gets comforting, warm and a bit woody. It makes its brothers in the JD line taste like pale, sour imitations of real whiskey, but it doesn't really try too hard to be anything special. You can still taste a bit of that JD/JB "sourness" (I call it) in the mix. JD is bottom shelf whiskey at middleshelf price. Knob Creek knows its place and aims a little higher. An excellent stock whiskey for drinking neat, if you don't mind a little burn.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Dec 29th 2009

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Copper
    Nose
    very complex, at times peaty smokey camp fire like other times sweet slight vanilla
    Body
    medium
    Palate
    also complex, campfire, little spicy earthy/peaty/smokey other times sweet, smoked walnuts and toffe
    Finish
    medium long

    This replaces my previous review which I scored it a 50. At first reminded me of Talisker with the fish/oyster taste. Do not go off of first dram. A very good winter malt that grows on one. Excellent winter whisky.

    Henry McKenna Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Henry McKenna Single Barrel Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Dec 29th 2009

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden
    Nose
    spicy smell
    Body
    This high proof bourbon is warm,
    Palate
    nutty warm, some browned caramel finish
    Finish
    long finish, warm a long time

    A resonably priced bonded bourbon, at 100 proof, a great buy with tons of charater. Like the personalized barrel number and date.

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Dec 26th 2009

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    dark gold
    Nose
    vanilla,toffee, caramel a little wood
    Body
    creamy,med-full
    Palate
    honey, hot spicey, litte vanilla and a taste I cant describe maybe it's the sherry
    Finish
    same as palate, short to mediun length

    very good for the 12 yo range and price. Sister Co. to glenfiddich. Quite of bit better than the 15 yr. Fiddich. will purchase again

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Dec 26th 2009

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    water that had dead fish swimming in it.
    Body
    medium
    Palate
    A great pepper taste, but all was ruined because of the taste of dead fish swimming in or around the aging process.
    Finish
    long pepper finish.

    I also find it very hard to believe any one likes this single malt. SO much POTENTIAL but all is ruined by the over whelming dead fish water taste.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Dec 26th 2009

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark amber
    Nose
    Water that had dead or alive fish
    Body
    thin
    Palate
    like drinking water that had fish swimming in
    Finish
    extremely long

    I find it very hard to believe any one likes this whisky. It has NO SMOKE taste or smell. I love smokey tasting single malts but this is like drinking water that had dead fish swimming in it.

    Glenfiddich Solera Reserve 15 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Solera Reserve 15 Years Old Dec 23rd 2009

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold
    Nose
    Honey, caramel, vanilla
    Body
    silky, various layers, full bodied
    Palate
    vanilla, raisins
    Finish
    smooth, sweet, hot
    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve

    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve Nov 23rd 2009

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden
    Nose
    some smoke, peat, scottish rain
    Body
    full body, not gritty and not bland
    Palate
    blended honey oat cheerios with the peat of laphroaig
    Finish
    smooth but with a good simmer of length

    I enjoyed this run. It had a very smooth relaxing after dinner taste with the winding down of a long day.

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label Nov 21st 2009

    51
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    smokey, oaken, complex
    Body
    silky
    Palate
    slight sweetness, almost fruity
    Finish
    lingering, malty aftertaste

    while jw blue is indeed a fine blended whiskey, relative to the scores i've seen on many other fine, equally smooth, and altogether more distinctive whiskeys on this site, it scores too high. so in an attempt to even things out a bit, i'm trying to adjust the average. seriously, look at some of the other scores of the fine whiskeys. the best average you'll tend to see is around 85; while jw blue is nice, it's a big homogeneous and indistinctive, worthy of no higher a score than the average earned by many other fine whiskeys on this site.

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Nov 18th 2009

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold or light straw
    Nose
    Honey or light fruit with the right balance of peat.
    Body
    Medium
    Palate
    Honey,Smoke,Peat, Light Fruit
    Finish
    SMOOTH. Calming.

    For the price and quality you get this is a wonderful scotch whiskey. One of my favorites. A nice all round whiskey for any occasion.

    Black Bottle Original Blend

    Black Bottle Original Blend Nov 14th 2009

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber
    Nose
    Medium Peat, slightly medicinal, slight citrus candy
    Body
    medium body
    Palate
    Nice combination of peat, definitely Islay but unique in itself
    Finish
    Cozy comfy and smoke sets in and lingers

    Great blended whisky, takes out the heavy peat and of a couple of Islay whisky and transforms it to a truly affordable and enjoyable dram

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old Nov 14th 2009

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale Straw
    Nose
    Peat, mid salt
    Body
    Full, oily
    Palate
    The moderate peat blast gives way for the sweet grain/citrus to come through.
    Finish
    Peat subsides to a little bit of salt and carries into a long, pleasant taste of fresh seaweed.

    Probably one of the best Islay values--and the best Ardbeg value--in my opinion. Very good scotch and it doesn't make a huge dent in your wallet.

    Ardbeg Airigh Nam Beist

    Ardbeg Airigh Nam Beist Nov 14th 2009

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden straw
    Nose
    Woody, peat, floral, mildy fruity, amazing.
    Body
    Medium to full, buttery
    Palate
    Peat, aged wood, sweet grain, citrus, vanilla, marshmallow (once again, amazing)
    Finish
    After the palate flavors settle down, there's a smooth transition to fresh seaweed

    This stuff is unforgettable. I really like the 10 Year, the Corryvreckan's a beast (in a good way), but I was disappointed with the Uigeadail (as I don't care for sherry). Airigh Nam Beist is elegant, refined, yet doesn't forget it's roots. Absolutely spectacular.

    Jack Daniel's Old no7

    Jack Daniel's Old No7 Nov 5th 2009

    52
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    A dark Amber color
    Nose
    Strong sour charred oak.
    Body
    Thin like stale water. I agree with another reviewer here.
    Palate
    Strong Sour charred oak. A really sour whiskey.
    Finish
    The finish is no different from the palate.

    I will give it some points for consistency. It's resistant to oxidization. Too bad it's a horrible whiskey. Hard to believe that so many people actually likes this. Marketing sure does wonders.

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey Nov 5th 2009

    51
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    A light brown/orange color
    Nose
    A very light nose. Almost absent. Something slightly sweet (slight vanilla). Alcohol is a little pronounced. Very little oak. Hard to believe that this is a bourbon.
    Body
    Thin like cold water.
    Palate
    Not much on the palate. Very light. The tiniest hint of oak. Vodka like. It has a slight kick to it. Slightly hot, spicy, and bitter. Acidic and sour.
    Finish
    Weak, short and disappointing. Acidic.

    This is "brown vodka". Definitely not worth the $23. A horrible whiskey. The acidic taste and finish makes you want to drink a good amount of water. STAY AWAY FROM THIS!

    Benriach Curiositas Peated 10 Years Old

    Benriach Curiositas Peated 10 Years Old Oct 29th 2009

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    gold
    Nose
    unique nose sweet and smokey?
    Body
    oily but nice
    Palate
    a real kick in the buds
    Finish
    sweet spicy

    wow well impressed with this

    Jack Daniel's Gentleman Jack

    Jack Daniel's Gentleman Jack Oct 28th 2009

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light brown

    I found this basically a watered down version of JD

    Dalwhinnie 15 Years Old

    Dalwhinnie 15 Years Old Oct 24th 2009

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold
    Nose
    Sweet, berrys, brown sugar
    Body
    Full bodied
    Palate
    Silky, berrys flavor is intensified,
    Finish
    Long finish, warm, but not so strong to the end
    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Oct 22nd 2009

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Rich straw.
    Nose
    Flowers, honey, malt, smoke.
    Body
    Medium.
    Palate
    Sugared fruit, malt, grains, vanilla, honey, smoke, lemon tea.
    Finish
    Medium-long, honey and fruit, malty, barley (like a nice Belgian Palm beer)

    Very balanced whisky for such a young age. Not too heavy and therefore good as an aperitif. Altogether very special.

    Glenmorangie 10 Years Old

    Glenmorangie 10 Years Old Oct 22nd 2009

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale straw.
    Nose
    Flowers, vanilla, fruity (pear? melon? papaya?) banana.
    Body
    Medium.
    Palate
    Bourbon, vanilla, flowers, some smoke, sweet fruit, grape-fruit, soapy.
    Finish
    Medium-long. floral, banana, vanilla, fading with a whiff of smoke.

    Light whisky, which is well-balanced and complex, but a bit dull. Reminds me of Jim Beam, because of the vanilla and floral notes, but it's subtler. Not my favourite, but a nice malt nonetheless.

    Glenfarclas 21 Years Old

    Glenfarclas 21 Years Old Oct 22nd 2009

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Full amber
    Nose
    Sherry, apple, vanilla, toffee, herbal.
    Body
    Full.
    Palate
    Very complex. A little smoke, sherry, raisins, dark chocolate, hazelnuts, woody.
    Finish
    Long and fruity. Dry sherry, herbs (bay leaves?), smoky, white grapes (?)

    Very complex malt, which keeps on revealing new notes, Took me a long time to see the power of this one. Only the third time I had some I started to appreciate it, The sherry is prominent, but not overly. Very ripe and subtle indeed.

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old Oct 22nd 2009

    83
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    gold
    Nose
    Sweet, fresh apple. Sugary, with citrus fruit.
    Body
    Full, syrupy.
    Palate
    Honey, raisins, sherry-sweetness, vanilla, apple.
    Finish
    Long. Again some apple, vanilla, honey.

    Pleasant, fruity whisky. Certainly doesn't need any water. Great honeyish flavour development. Crowd pleaser because of its sweetness. I like this one for dessert.

    Bowmore 18 Year Old

    Bowmore 18 Year Old Oct 22nd 2009

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    Smoky, with some peat, nougat and cookie-dough. Slightly briny.
    Body
    Full, chewy.
    Palate
    Nougat and caramel are followed by smoke, some salt, a whiff of sherry, chocolate, ripe banana. Definitely some wood as well.
    Finish
    Lang and dry. Salty, peaty and smoky, some nutty flavours (almonds?) and wood.

    Lovely evening malt. The nougaty flavours are unique, for as far as I kow, and realy pleasant. The peat and smoke are less prominent here than in the 12 yrs old Enigma, but definitely present in a refined way. Best savoured neat or with a little water.

    Blanton's Gold Edition

    Blanton's Gold Edition Oct 21st 2009

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Ofrom amber color to gold-colour
    Nose
    finely wooded, marked by dried fruits, evokes spices (cinnamon) and heady flowers (honeysuckle)
    Body
    Full bodied
    Palate
    The lively, elegant and thoroughbred mouth evolves on fruits (plum) and spices (clove).
    Finish
    Finale long develops on notes of vanilla, pecan nut and burned wood.

    The Gold version of the Blanton is the most achieved.

    Springbank 10 Year Old

    Springbank 10 Year Old Oct 20th 2009

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light gold
    Nose
    pricky before adding water, oaky, peat smoke and wet morning by the sea
    Body
    medium-bodied
    Palate
    briney, ginger spice, light smoked fish.
    Finish
    medium length finish, warm, complex, a little burny in the throat w/o water.

    An very good 10yo single malt with surprising complexity. It's a very hot and sexy drink. Will remain my infatuation for a long time.

    Ballantine's 12 Year Old

    Ballantine's 12 Year Old Oct 20th 2009

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    exquisite shiny gold.
    Nose
    sweet, oaky, smell of sea breeze.
    Body
    what a smooth operator!
    Palate
    oaky sweet, honey, ever-so-softly briney hint, complex yet so perfectly balanced.
    Finish
    long, smooth, and slightly velvety finish, with a gentle warmth - like being caressed in lover's bossom!

    Quite simply the best and value-for-money 12yo blended scotch whisky you'll ever get in a duty-free shop. Beats the rest in the class hands down. Rules like Man Utd! I will not buy any other 12yo blended whiskies for life!

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Oct 19th 2009

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    Heavy smoke, Peat, Earth, Hospital
    Body
    oily and pungent
    Palate
    peat, Iodine,
    Finish
    very long

    Excellent - great with a cigar as it amplifies the smoke.

    Crown Royal

    Crown Royal Oct 17th 2009

    55
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Rich Amber
    Nose
    Wet trees and grass, lemony cork.
    Body
    Light, nimble, solvent.
    Palate
    Peat, salt, rubber.
    Finish
    Warm finish, bitter to the end.

    May be good as a mixer, not easy to enjoy neat.

    Ezra Brooks Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Ezra Brooks Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Oct 17th 2009

    72
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Cola, Dark Amber
    Nose
    Sweet and Hot, Molasses
    Body
    Hot single dimensional,
    Palate
    Sweet, dried corn nut, some maple
    Finish
    Short and hot

    A super deal and was initially very appealing when compared to Jim Beam or Jack D. Worth A try I add a few drops of water to open it up and cool it off.

    Bushmills Malt 10 Year Old

    Bushmills Malt 10 Year Old Oct 13th 2009

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    sweet and earthy with a hint of "fire"
    Body
    smotth body that lets you know its there.
    Palate
    Hints of caramel and white chocolate throughout the various rich eathy notes.
    Finish
    Its a bit hot a first but goes down very smooth. has a very nice mid to front pallette finish. stays with you for a little while.

    A very satisfying single malt.

    The Macallan 12 Years Old

    The Macallan 12 Years Old Oct 7th 2009

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    deep, darrk, sort of burgundy-red.
    Nose
    Woody, nutty, hints of sherry.
    Body
    Full bodied
    Palate
    Strong, nutyy, woody flavor.
    Finish
    Long, stong, Warm finidh

    Excellent finish, very strong and warm. Enjoyed well on its own.

    Crown Royal

    Crown Royal Oct 7th 2009

    71
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale Amber
    Nose
    Vanilla, nutty
    Body
    Light, mellow
    Palate
    Pretty light and sweet
    Finish
    Warm, Vanilla sweet taste. Lingering.

    Tasty. Verry light and mellow, easy to drink.

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Sep 22nd 2009

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Peat, smoke, fruity, citrus, sweet
    Body
    Full
    Palate
    Rather unbalanced. I was not at all impressed with the combative contrast of the sweetness and the smokiness.
    Finish
    Long

    I really wasn't very happy with this scotch. I don't plan on trying it again.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Sep 22nd 2009

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Peat, smoke, salt water, citrus
    Body
    Full, bold
    Palate
    Extremely salty, heavy peat
    Finish
    Long salty finish

    I liked everything about this scotch except for the fact that, to my palate, it tasted like someone took half a sprinkler bottle of salt and poured it into my dram....way to salty for me. I'll stick with Laphroaig and Arbdeg.

    Glenmorangie 10 Years Old

    Glenmorangie 10 Years Old Sep 19th 2009

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber
    Nose
    wheat, moss, slight acidity and small smokey notes
    Body
    Light, refreshing and homey. Not too overbearing but enough weight
    Palate
    Old books, nectarines and light peat
    Finish
    Soft finish with nasal overtones. No heavy lingering.

    This is a nice whiskey. Its mild but has enough base to tempt the palate. A great entry dram and with enough history and presence to be appreciated by all.

    Suntory Yamazaki 18 Years Old

    Suntory Yamazaki 18 Years Old Sep 4th 2009

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Coppery gold
    Nose
    Honey, Caramel, Floral?
    Body
    Full bodied and creamy
    Palate
    Cream, Honey, Buttery, Smoky, Smooth, Delicious
    Finish
    Long, full, rich, not too sweet.

    Wonderful! Similar to Highland Park 18 in fullness richness and complexity. The most expensive bottle I've ever purchased (about US$125) but completely worth it.

    Bushmills Black Bush

    Bushmills Black Bush Aug 31st 2009

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    who cares
    Nose
    This is a good back up for the Bunnahabhain, but not as interesting...malty and raisiny.
    Body
    It's OK.
    Palate
    Chocolate, sweetish, malty but slightly grainy.
    Finish
    fine.

    Cheaper alternative to the Bunny 12

    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve Aug 26th 2009

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    Horrid hospital iodine
    Body
    Bites and then I pucker and wish I never tried it.
    Palate
    Just as well drink gasoline
    Finish
    Long and strong, and with this scotch whiskey, long is a bad thing.

    I tried it briefly and poured it down the drain.

    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve Aug 11th 2009

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Lagavulin
    Nose
    Lagavulin
    Body
    Lagavulin
    Palate
    Lagavulin - with a bit more smoke and lacking a hint of richness
    Finish
    Lagavulin - slightly shorter and drier than the 16 year old.

    I actually have two bottles of Finlaggan - one of them is the 40% "Old Reserve", which is unabashedly and unmistakably Lagavulin. The silliness about the "most secret distillery" is all utter rubbish. There is no mystery, other than its age. Compared to the standard 16-year bottling of Lagavulin, I'd guess this at ~12-14 years, since it doesn't quite have the same richness or length of finish. Now the other bottle I have truly _is_ a mystery. It's a cask strength (56%) bottling, which is both (a) unrecognisable, and (b) undrinkable. It is horrible, HORRIBLE stuff--not just poor or bland, but aggressively unpleasant, unbalanced, and just plain nasty. Everyone who has tried it agrees--we'd rather be drinking cheap rye than this cask bottling. If 50 is the lowest score, than that's what this would get. However, it galls me to assign a value of 50 to this stuff. AVOID!

    Rebel Yell Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Rebel Yell Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Aug 10th 2009

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber - it's the caramel of course
    Nose
    Good old corn liquor
    Body
    More than adequate. Because of this, it can not only be savored straight or on the rocks, but mixes well for an Old Fashioned or a Manhattan
    Palate
    Pure good Bourbon flavor - no romance
    Finish
    Smooth feeling from entry along the palate and down the throat.

    I have been drinking Bourbon since the age of fifteen, that is to say, for fifty-one years. I was introduced to Rebel Yell in 1985 when I was encouraged by business associates who noticed my penchant for Bourbon, to buy some in The South while on vacation. When I returned North, I found a distributor who would sell it to a local liquor store. It is now more commonly found. Rebel Yell is the drinking man's Bourbon for those who savor the flavor. If you want panache, buy something written up in The New Yorker Magazine and flatter yourself. If you enjoy your liquor, and I do not mean alcoholism, buy Rebel Yell. It mixes well for cocktails that are enhanced by additives, not overpowered. People who drink sissified drinks taste my 80 proof Rebel Yell and think that it is much stronger. This Bourbon is just plain old "GOOD."

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey Aug 3rd 2009

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark Amber honey
    Nose
    Slightly fruity with a bit of spice
    Body
    medium-full body
    Palate
    Vanilla, a bit of cherry and brown sugar in there too.
    Finish
    As another commentor stated it is almost "medicinal". Has a long warm finish that is slightly numbing, without affecting the palate for the next taste!

    For this price point I don't know what else they could do better! 5 stars in my book!

    Celtic Nations Celtic Blended Malt Whisky

    Celtic Nations Celtic Blended Malt Whisky Jul 31st 2009

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    just opened a bottle, it's fantastic! peaty and spicy, rich and warming, off to refill my glass...

    Yamazaki 12 years old

    Yamazaki 12 Years Old Jul 28th 2009

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden amber
    Nose
    Vanilla and peat.
    Body
    Medium body but great for the age.
    Palate
    Vanilla, peat, spice
    Finish
    Light finish. Warm and delightful.

    Very good whiskey, Suntory has done a good job. Best scotch outside Scotland. Great buy for money!!!

    Bowmore 12 Year Old

    Bowmore 12 Year Old Jul 9th 2009

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Amber
    Nose
    Sea Salt, Smoky and Woody.
    Body
    Oily
    Palate
    Hint of honey, Charred wood and smoke, Dark Chocolate, Sweet and bitter.
    Finish
    Starts strong,long and smoky. Ends with a smooth chocolate coffee finish.

    A great whisky for the price !

    Old Ezra 7 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Old Ezra 7 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Jul 9th 2009

    94
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    dark
    Nose
    spicy, sweet, rich
    Body
    full-bodied, but not thick. clean, but rich.
    Palate
    caramel, vanilla, toasted something, rich and strong.
    Finish
    very warm, but complex.

    this stuff is very, very good. holds up on it's own or in a mixer. (but it's best neat, rocks, or with water). probably my favorite bourbon.

    Jameson

    Jameson Jul 5th 2009

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    gold
    Nose
    orange
    Body
    medium bodied
    Palate
    intensive and waspish
    Finish
    pepper, sharp

    I am disapointed with this whiskey, in my opinion it is not worth drinkng at all. In comparison with soft Speyside Aberlour 10yo whisky, Jameson tastes like poor quality alcohol.

    Aberlour 10 Year Old

    Aberlour 10 Year Old Jul 2nd 2009

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    lager beer color
    Nose
    vanilla, a bit of alcohol
    Body
    soft and sweet
    Palate
    caramel, sweetness, honey
    Finish
    warm rounded finish with creeps of alcohol in the mouth

    Soft whisky, suitable for beginners or for those who like soft and sweet tastes, definitely drinkable.

    Jack Daniel's Old no7

    Jack Daniel's Old No7 Jul 1st 2009

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Molasses
    Nose
    A bit sharp, hollow, sugar
    Body
    Clean, gassy
    Palate
    direct alcohol. faint twizzler. wheat.
    Finish
    strong at first, stays alcoholic.

    Not very complex, but a classic.

    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve

    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve Jul 1st 2009

    58
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light
    Nose
    Medicinal, very light smoke
    Body
    Thin
    Palate
    Wood wood woody wood.
    Finish
    dry

    Ugh, this was awful. Its like drinking a tree. It has no character. Barely drinkable on its own.

    Jameson

    Jameson Jul 1st 2009

    81
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    translucent gold
    Nose
    sweet, fruity
    Body
    viscous
    Palate
    very sweet, molasses & caramel. peach.
    Finish
    smooth, medium. alcohol comes off your tongue.

    Pretty pleasant, doesn't need water, but too sweet for my sipping tastes. Does well as a shot. I'll have to try the older ones.

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey Jul 1st 2009

    64
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    reddish
    Nose
    Alcoholic, sting
    Body
    Fluid
    Palate
    bitter, stinging, sharp. No mellow flavors.
    Finish
    Yuck.

    This stuff is nasty. They didn't work anything subtle into this drink.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Jul 1st 2009

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Urine
    Nose
    Wow. Strong salt, smoke, ...seaweed.
    Body
    Oily, peat comes through immediately.
    Palate
    Plasticky smoke. Salt under your tongue. Add a drop of water to calm it - becomes much more pleasant.
    Finish
    Inlaws - not going anywhere any time soon. Stupid grin comes ten seconds after swallowing.

    Though immensely strong, the flavors are just fantastic. Welcome to Islay. A man's drink.

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old Jul 1st 2009

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    A bit of the orange side of honey
    Nose
    Light smoke, lighter earth, faint cotton candy
    Body
    Smooth but whole
    Palate
    Alcoholic, earthy and faint smoke. A bit of water brings balance. Sweeter on the next sip, and the next.
    Finish
    Short finish, smoke as you exhale, then clean.

    This was surprisingly good. Not a knock-out punch like Islay malts, but very nicely balanced and smooth. Also affordable. Very good default sipping whiskey.

    The Macallan 12 Years Old

    The Macallan 12 Years Old Jul 1st 2009

    73
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Darker than most
    Nose
    Sweet, a bit tannic, light smoke
    Body
    Oily, piercing
    Palate
    Unpleasant. Sherry overpowers everything. Not balanced.
    Finish
    Lingering sherry, a little sting.

    I found this to be highly overrated. Most flavors are meek, and the strong sherry just ruins it for me. I don't like it when my whiskey tastes like wine.

    Bowmore 12 Year Old

    Bowmore 12 Year Old Jul 1st 2009

    86
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale Honey
    Nose
    Pleasant, easy smell. Light smoke, hint of peat, but unlike Laphroaig, no salt.
    Body
    Fluid, light, smooth
    Palate
    Very slight sting of alcohol, molasses, soft smoke. Mild.
    Finish
    Again, smooth and light, but with very nice flavors. Graham cracker & fireplace.

    A lot of nice flavors without being overpowering. A nice intro to Islay, that won't explode your face like a Laphroaig. Happily for me, does not have the nasty taste of sherry like Macallan.

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old Jun 22nd 2009

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Clear light straw
    Nose
    Light smoke almost matched by alcohol.
    Body
    Thicker end of medium. Sliky.
    Palate
    Sipped this gives a wondrous mellow wave of smokey peat. This makes me think of proper oak smoked salmon. A larger slip opens the taste to the smoke of burning embers of wood. A cooling leaves a slight medicinal tint to the peaty taste. The larger the sip the more brutal the impact of the alcohol. Overall a balanced taste with a slight sweetness initially quickly before balancing out nicely.
    Finish
    Warming and the flavours of smokey peat linger. The mouth dries over time giving a drier taste. Transitions to an oily taste/texture towards the very end. The aroma lingers longer than the actual taste.

    If I was to compare this as a red wine - between Cheval Blanc and supermarket plonk this would come in at about 25/bottle. A single dimensional taste rather than presenting a layered palette of taste however a good clarity of that taste delivered in silk if tasted by sipping.

    The Dalmore Cigar Malt

    The Dalmore Cigar Malt Jun 21st 2009

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    maple syrup
    Nose
    extremely rich, desserty, chocolate and bit of orange liqueur but w/ more caramel/toffee/butterscotch notes. Bourbon. A wildly delicious-smelling drink.
    Body
    thick and full.
    Palate
    See aromas. Tastes are similar but less startling.
    Finish
    long and sweet finish.

    yummy but not for everyone, esp if you like it dry, or peaty, or any of the more usual single characteristics.

    The Macallan Fine Oak 18 Years Old

    The Macallan Fine Oak 18 Years Old Jun 20th 2009

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Medium Amber
    Nose
    Oak and fruit, floral notes in between
    Body
    Medium-heavy body, nicely coats the tongue and cheek.
    Palate
    A woodsy sherry taste with some nuttiness and honey notes, even a touch of maple. The flavors are complex andf not overpowewring at all, Invites you to savor it.
    Finish
    Medium finish, which is my only (slight) criticism, although so close to perfect thaat they'd better leave it alone. Incrredibly smotth!

    My favorite of a all the highlands and for special guests. The fine oak finish now incorporates aging in three barrels: sherry-trreated European and American Oaks treated with sherry, an American Oak treated with bourbon. The "treated with" feels wierd, but the result is terrific!

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Jun 20th 2009

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold
    Nose
    Ripe fruit, mild smoke, well-balanced and appealing.
    Body
    Medium
    Palate
    NIce sweetness, balanced with smoke and a little salt. Very smooth. Almost reminds me of peanut butter.
    Finish
    Long, smooth finish.

    After my first glass, I wasn't sure how I felt about this whisky, but by the end of the bottle it became one of my favorites. Great value, great taste, I strongly recommend.

    Midleton Very Rare

    Midleton Very Rare Jun 19th 2009

    96
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Perfect
    Nose
    A little smokey with hints of oranges
    Body
    Smoooooth!
    Palate
    Sweet and smooth with mild spiciness.
    Finish
    Moderately long and warmTastes like more

    An Angelic Chior broke into song as the first taste touched my lips and mouth. Midleton's everything I ever wanted and more. It cured my herpres then I rubbed it on my dead irish grandfathers corpse, he proceeded rise and dance a jig. Truely truely the water of life.

    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label Jun 18th 2009

    76
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    straw gold
    Nose
    faint vanilla honey, tender in it aroma yet strong and sharp in it own unique way
    Body
    moderate thick , warm and tender , more feminine than you first expected
    Palate
    bitter-sweet, honey and chocolate
    Finish
    moderate long , not so hot and faded away beautifully

    a very sensitive taste that might be a bit harder to catch, great for it price ofcause would be my choice anytime of the day.

    Crown Royal

    Crown Royal Jun 11th 2009

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    rich amber
    Nose
    wiff of vanilla with a hint of citrus
    Palate
    very smooth and creamy
    Finish
    long lasting with a slight bite of rye

    Crown Royal is CANADIAN whiskey and the best of the lot. It isn't supposed to taste like bourbon or scotch. It is simple, elegant, and comfortable.

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old May 24th 2009

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale straw
    Nose
    Very smoky, leather, ink, salt
    Body
    Full, oily
    Palate
    Overwhelming: a small splash of water releases full flavour: heavy peat, brany, even salt, dry smoke, some herbs
    Finish
    Lingering, salt and dry, complex

    A real killer, this one. In my opinion water is a necessity. Remarkably dry and salt and therefore even more powerful than the Laphroaig 10jr or the Talisker 10jr.

    Talisker 18 Year Old

    Talisker 18 Year Old May 23rd 2009

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Deep gold
    Nose
    Vanilla, toffee, sweet flowers
    Body
    Full, ever so slightly oily
    Palate
    Initially warm fruit, then vanilla and toffee, pepper, subtly peaty; like burning wood
    Finish
    Long and pleasant, the finish releases some spice; autumn fruit and cinnamon

    Very lovely, balanced whisky, which for me contains all the elements that make a good Single Malt: smokiness, fruit, vanilla and an overall warm sensation. It reminds me of a campfire by the seaside on a warm night in summer.

    Glen Moray Classic

    Glen Moray Classic May 23rd 2009

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale amber
    Nose
    A very strong nose. Floral, butter.
    Body
    Smooth and easy
    Palate
    Slightly sweet, exceptionally easy to drink.
    Finish
    A little short on the finish

    In my opinion an excellent whisky considering the reasonable price. This is my second choice of single malt after Glenmorangie.

    Caol Ila 12 Year Old

    Caol Ila 12 Year Old May 22nd 2009

    84
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Avslagen folkl
    Nose
    Aska!
    Body
    Varm aksha, brnner i halsen,
    Palate
    Skogsbrand!
    Finish
    Efternga, det ngar liksom upp i gommen.

    Now we're off to to play pool! Love M

    The Macallan Fine Oak 18 Years Old

    The Macallan Fine Oak 18 Years Old May 20th 2009

    87
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark Amber
    Nose
    Citrus, Smoke, Hint of Wood
    Body
    Meduim Full Body
    Palate
    Slight Smoke, Hint of Sherry, Spice
    Finish
    Medium Length, Pepper, Slightly Sour

    Very good dram. In my opinion not as good as the regular 12 year old, very good dram for the value.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old May 14th 2009

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber gold
    Nose
    sweet woody smell,
    Body
    dfull in flavour, explodes in you mouth, goes down smooth
    Palate
    sugar
    Finish
    warm and fuzzy

    best damn whiskey i have tasted

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay May 14th 2009

    67
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale amber
    Nose
    Peat, cinnamon, something vaguely floral
    Body
    Light
    Palate
    Restrained peat and salt. Relatively mild but a bit rough, very light peat, slightly sweetish, no primary taste note.
    Finish
    light but lingering finish with a wee bit of iodine

    Errors of omission rather than commission; nothing special here but nothing nasty either. An unremarkable, passable, islay-ish whisky. If it weren't inexpensive it would be useless, but it does hit a nice price/value mark.

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old

    Ardbeg 10 Years Old May 9th 2009

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale straw
    Nose
    Nose is sweet and earthy. Smells like a peat bog on a cool but very humid summer night, with some trees on fire.
    Body
    Medium, a little oily. Not as thick as other ten year olds.
    Palate
    This whisky has a strong alcohol flavor that is truly numbing on the tongue and lips. Despite this, strong smoky peat flavor comes through. It also tastes like fire. This whisky burns with the fire of a thousand suns. The flavor is brutish and surprising - kind of a slap in the face. Tastes like medicine, too, as a result of these characteristics.
    Finish
    Intense and long. Breathe out through your nose and there is a distinct burn and tingle that raises the hair on the back of your neck. Kinda feels like your head is full of fire, but it's not burning you. After this, a sweetness that is exactly like the smell of old musty wood furniture can be enjoyed for several minutes.

    If you want to get into Islay, don't start with this. I've had Laphroaig's 10, 15, and Quarter Cask (Laphroaig 10 is my favorite whisky so far). The character of Ardbeg 10 is not elegant, complex, and rich like Laphroaig 10, but is rather belligerent, reckless, and hyperactive. Comparing these two whiskies is kind of like comparing Athens and Sparta. This whisky, while very enjoyable, is not quite my cup of tea. However, if you want a whisky that spits in your face and insults your character while screaming obscenities in your ear, Ardbeg 10 is for you.

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old

    The Balvenie Doublewood 12 Year Old May 2nd 2009

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Rich Gold
    Nose
    Toffee Apples,Burnt Sugar,Go Deep for Slight peat and Nuttiness
    Body
    Thick,Creamy and Coating.
    Palate
    Tangy and Slight Peat add water for Hints of Vanilla and Sherry,Very Sweet
    Finish
    Sherry Beings to fade with slight peat then smooth sweetness comes back.Long and Satisfying

    An Extremely Fantastic Malt, Enjoy long summer nights in your garden with this one... A must have!

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old May 2nd 2009

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Deep Gold, Chestnut
    Nose
    Caramel, smoke
    Body
    Full bodied, oily
    Palate
    Oiliness gives way to smoky peat, vanilla, toffee
    Finish
    Long and warming, spicy flavors

    Not quite Laphroaig but a very enjoyable blend.

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey May 1st 2009

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Copperish Orange.
    Nose
    99.9% Ethyl Alcohol + Cherry Cola. Perhaps a bit of fruity sweetness.
    Body
    Sharp. Medium Texture and Body.
    Palate
    99.9% Ethyl Alcohol + Cherry Cola mixed 5/1; sweet like brown sugar with a warming/burning sensation.
    Finish
    Warms the belly, numbs the mouth. General warm and soothing feelings.

    First bourbon I have really ever enjoyed! Delicious whiskey if I may so myself. Most defiantly "distinctive and exceptional" far beyond my perception of bourbon whiskey.

    Oban 14 Year Old

    Oban 14 Year Old Apr 17th 2009

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light amber
    Nose
    fruity, pear, firm
    Body
    full, warming
    Palate
    fruity, light nutty
    Finish
    long lasting heavy flavoured finish

    powerful, flavourful, well balanced

    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve

    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve Apr 13th 2009

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden
    Nose
    Honey, faint peat, fresh grains, phenol/tannins, iodine, citrus. Lovely really.
    Body
    Quite a heavy, oily mouthfeel
    Palate
    Oaky tannins, iodine, malty grains, honey, some peat as well
    Finish
    Warm and smooth finish. Why blends were created afterall.

    No surprises here save the faint peat in the nose and palate as i was expecting a more unaffected dram. A solid blend for beginners and/or those wanting to get back to center. Worth the experience and coin. I've been an avid Single Malt drinker for years and this is just fine.

    McClellands Highland

    McClellands Highland Apr 6th 2009

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light gold
    Nose
    Sandal and cedar wood fuse with the sweetness of buttercream and fresh vanilla.
    Body
    soft, suttle, velvety smooth
    Palate
    combination of the sweetness of malt and the aridity of salt Traces of gooseberry and a hint of lime
    Finish
    A pleasantly smooth, lengthily, mouth filling aftertaste.

    A very good single malt scotch whiskey for the price. Well balanced.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Apr 4th 2009

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light honey
    Nose
    Hospital bandaging
    Palate
    Smoke, iodine and band-aids. Then more iodine.
    Finish
    Iodine, iodine and iodine

    IODINE. A smooth but powerful whiskey that will be adored by anyone with a strong penchant for hospitals. Personally, I don't get the attraction, and could live long and quite happily without ever crossing paths with this distillate again.

    Bushmills Malt 21 Year Old

    Bushmills Malt 21 Year Old Apr 3rd 2009

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Warm copper
    Nose
    Caramel and cream. Barely-there traces of smoke and grain.
    Body
    Creamier, maltier than its younger siblings- hints of fruit. Buttery smooth without being oily.
    Palate
    Sweet toffee with a hint of honeyed orange. (Whatever smoke the nose promised seems to have vanished- yet it's hardly missed.)
    Finish
    A satisfying finish, nutty and smooth.

    A sweet, jubilant introduction to Irish Whisky. Perhaps the "friendliest" whisky I've ever tasted- though by no means does it lack in character or complexity.

    Caol Ila 12 Year Old

    Caol Ila 12 Year Old Apr 2nd 2009

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    translucent white wine
    Nose
    grass, laundry basket. citrus peel, barn, malt
    Body
    oily and delicate.
    Palate
    malt, carrot cake, sugar,grain, peat.
    Finish
    nice rise & expanding plateau Roller coasters into a splash of peat.

    A lot of taste. Light, overall a good dram.

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Apr 1st 2009

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    orange gemstone
    Nose
    Alcohol, sweet, clean, sarsaparilla, caramel, carnival air.
    Body
    consistently dense body.
    Palate
    sugar which builds yet savory, salty, malt, alcohol, cocoa, caramel, vegetatation, some smoke.
    Finish
    lingers as it evolves; sweetens yet warms the pallet.

    Very well constructed. A quality dram, rich, and flavorful. An experience.

    Jack Daniel's Old no7

    Jack Daniel's Old No7 Mar 31st 2009

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Caramel
    Nose
    Rich fruity, spice, and oak
    Body
    Very smooth and mellow
    Palate
    Wonderfully smooth fruit, spice, and oak
    Finish
    Warm long finsih that holds the flavor throughout

    Magnificent stand alone drink and an exceptional mixer.

    Crown Royal

    Crown Royal Mar 31st 2009

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light Caramel
    Nose
    Slightly fruited and nutty, sweet and sharp
    Body
    Light and watery
    Palate
    Fruity with a hint of rye
    Finish
    Warm finish that loses the flavor to alcohol sensation

    A very good mixer, but not a good stand alone drink.

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Green Label 15 Years Old Mar 22nd 2009

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light cooper
    Nose
    a hint of a tiny bit sweet, and bitter. hard to describe
    The Glenlivet Nadurra 16 Year Old (06 2006)

    The Glenlivet Nadurra 16 Year Old (06 2006) Mar 12th 2009

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous

    The spices anise and ginger give this whiskey an exceptional not.

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old

    Lagavulin 16 Year Old Mar 11th 2009

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark, golden
    Nose
    Heavy smoke, almost a beacon note
    Body
    full bodied
    Palate
    peat, smoke, nuts.
    Finish
    Finish is strong and unique.

    I tried this for the first time a few weeks ago, now i have bought a bottle. It definately is not an everyday scotch. Interesting change, love the heavy smoke.

    Hazelburn 8 Year Old

    Hazelburn 8 Year Old Mar 10th 2009

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale gold
    Nose
    Very fresh and fruity with some spice.
    Palate
    sweet fruity and clean. Pears lemon sherbet fruit tingles and more.
    Finish
    medium length finish and very cleansing.

    An excellent apertif whisky. Unbelievable good at 8 years old. Cant wait to see it at 12 yo.

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey

    Bulleit Burbon Frontier Whiskey Feb 28th 2009

    95
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Honey
    Nose
    Burnt Smokey Fruit
    Body
    Full bodied
    Palate
    Burnt Sugar, Tangy BURN
    Finish
    HOT BURN

    Red Neck Kentucky Sippin Whisky

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old Feb 26th 2009

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Rebel Yell Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

    Rebel Yell Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Feb 25th 2009

    89
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold
    Nose
    heaven
    Body
    36-24-36
    Palate
    Reminds me of home
    Finish
    Smoothest there is. None Better

    I do not know about the fruitiness or hint of raisin or any of that stuff. I have been a bourbon drinker for over 35 years. I have been drinking Rebel Yell for as long. It is as good as any bourbon there is and it is the brand I look for. I really feel the bad reviews are by people who are influenced by price. If you are paying more for Beam, Daniels ( I know not a true bourbon, but close enough, Kentucky Whiskey), or Makers Mark you may be paying too much. It used to be only available in the south, it was that exclusive in the 70's-80's. This is so smooth I turned a non-drinker into a bourbon drinker. Jack couldn't do that nor Beam...no way. . It is all a matter of taste said the farmer's wife when she kissed the cow. This is not as tasty as Wild Turkey or Knob Creek...but it is close and an excellent bourbon,whatever the price.

    Benriach Curiositas Peated 10 Years Old

    Benriach Curiositas Peated 10 Years Old Feb 19th 2009

    96
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale ambe
    Nose
    PeaT
    Body
    Full bodied
    Palate
    Heavy peat
    Finish
    A very long finish, and strong to the end. Warm and tingly. Hot.

    a Kick that you will never forget

    Bowmore 12 Year Old

    Bowmore 12 Year Old Feb 16th 2009

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    medium amber
    Nose
    smoke, coal, aok
    Body
    smooth and oily
    Palate
    mushroom, tar, peat, oak
    Finish
    smooth and disappearing

    very impressive and works perfectly with a nice Romeo y Julieta No2

    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve Feb 9th 2009

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    dark amber
    Nose
    peaty, earthy, farmlike; smells like the Irish countryside, smokey, verdant
    Body
    full, astringent, dense. I absolutely love the way this stuff smells; I regularly put my face into the glass and inhale.
    Palate
    peat, iodine, smoke, grassland
    Finish
    The finish is warm and long. It has an enjoyable aftertaste which subsides very gradually.

    Admittedly, I'm not a scotch connossieur. I've come to this recently and have drunk some example of speyside, some blendeds, some Kentucky bourbons (some cheap, some expensive) but this is the most interesting and satisfying bottle I have in my bar. I've gone through 2 bottles and stocked up on a few more, The taste and smell are not to everyone's tastes, but if you like complexity and something which tastes organic/of the earth and soil, this is a good place to start.

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Jan 21st 2009

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Smoke, Leather, Barn Hay
    Body
    Full
    Palate
    Smoke, salt, rubber.
    Finish
    long, building smoke.

    Epic length, like drinking a delicious oak campfire.

    Bushmills Malt 16 Year Old

    Bushmills Malt 16 Year Old Jan 17th 2009

    74
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    copper
    Nose
    somewhat astringent, coffee
    Body
    biting, strong
    Palate
    astringent, a hint of coffee
    Finish
    heartburn, a hint of coffee, but mostly that unpleasant burning sensation of stomach acid. That post vomit taste you get on the back of your tongue.

    Being of Irish decent, I'm very disappionted we can't keep up with the Scotts. For an Irish whiskey, I'd have to go with Redbreast.

    Jameson

    Jameson Jan 11th 2009

    82
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    honey
    Nose
    woody, earthy, occasional spice
    Body
    full flavored, complex, light feel
    Palate
    woody, aged, nutty
    Finish
    lingers on your mouth, delightfully not spicy, not much burning . smooth

    definatley worth buying. easy to enjoy, even for non whiskey drinkers

    Laphroaig 15 Year Old

    Laphroaig 15 Year Old Jan 5th 2009

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light gold
    Nose
    peat, smoke
    Body
    full bodied, thick
    Palate
    Peat, Salty, Smokey, Iodine
    Finish
    Warm and spicy very different from any scotch I've had.

    Very different from the usual scotch. Definitely worth giving it a shot. It seems to me that it as a "love it or hate it" kinda of taste. Give it a shot!

    Glenmorangie 10 Years Old

    Glenmorangie 10 Years Old Dec 30th 2008

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Light smoke.
    Body
    Able bodied, not overpowering
    Palate
    A bit nutty, with a whiff of peat.
    Finish
    Smooth, long finish.

    A great Highland Scotch for the Islay fan.

    anCnoc 12 Year Old Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky

    AnCnoc 12 Year Old Highland Single Malt Scotch Whisky Dec 27th 2008

    84
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber - yellow
    Nose
    Slightly citrus
    Body
    Smooth. Fairly light.
    Palate
    Peppery with a hint of licorice. Citrus. Not at all peaty.
    Finish
    Very long finish. Still peppery.

    A very interesting whisky, rather different from those I usually drink. I like the very long finish, but I'm not sure I'd buy it again, given the less peaty flavor.

    Glenfiddich Special Reserve 12 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Special Reserve 12 Years Old Dec 20th 2008

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden Amber
    Nose
    Sweetly floral, caramel, lightly fruity, creamy.
    Body
    Smooth like clover honey
    Palate
    Neat; Very full bodied and warm with hints of caramel, sweet cream, and spices. Rocks; Lightly complex with hints of caramel, apples, apricots, green grapes, sweet cream and honey.
    Finish
    Neat; The finish is very warm with hints of pepper and cedar which mellos quickly to a gentle smooth taste of honey. Rocks; very smooth and mellow with hints of buttery caramel and sweet spices.

    This is a very nice Whisky which I can enjoy any time of the day. I prefer it over rocks it seems to wake up the flavors a little more and give it very complex yet gentle flavor. It is very smooth and is an excellent choice for both new and experienced drinkers.

    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve Dec 18th 2008

    81
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden
    Nose
    Heavy smoke, earthy, grassy
    Body
    Smooth
    Palate
    sea salt, the moor
    Finish
    Warm to the end, dry after taste

    I disagree with some of the other reviewers. This is pretty good islay and you can't beat the price at Trader Joe's. I may have an overwhelming bite at first, but when opened up with a tablespoon of room-temp water and left to breathe for a moment, it's quite delightful.

    Glenfiddich Ancient Reserve 18 Years Old

    Glenfiddich Ancient Reserve 18 Years Old Dec 18th 2008

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    dark
    Nose
    a little smoked,earth,sweat
    Body
    full bodied
    Palate
    full strong sweat espresso
    Finish
    don't want to finish

    Drink it. I think is very underrated here,but much better than other more expensive blends.

    Bowmore 12 Year Old

    Bowmore 12 Year Old Dec 17th 2008

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    medium amber
    Nose
    Salt, some smoke and sardine
    Body
    smooth
    Palate
    If some whiskies are well-balanced, this is dissonant, in a very good way. You detect distinct flavors of salt, iodine, citrus, and of course, peat.
    Finish
    Strong finish, a little spicey.

    The word I think of is "deconstructionist." One of my favorites.

    Yamazaki 12 years old

    Yamazaki 12 Years Old Nov 28th 2008

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber brassy gold
    Nose
    Estery and fragrant on the nose, the smell of egg nog ie nutmeg and all spice mabey mace too , very mouth watering,
    Body
    medium bodied and sensuous in the mouth
    Palate
    Nice aroma of chocolate and cherries, good whiff of thick cut orange marmalade. Nice dry taste in back of throat with wonderful dried fruits and plum.
    Finish
    very nice long finish not warm or hot but smooth

    Seductive tast and feel, once youve had it you might never go back to any other sipping whisky. The Japanese got it all locked up with this one. Great price

    Bushmills Original

    Bushmills Original Nov 25th 2008

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light yellow
    Nose
    apples, and woody, slight hint of banana, butterscotch
    Body
    oily, and thin.
    Palate
    Hazelnut beginnings, slightly sweet, nutty.
    Finish
    Spice and chili pepper, lingers a long time.

    Pleasant, but finish is really harsh. But overall really nice, and great.

    J & B Rare Blended Scotch Whisky

    J & B Rare Blended Scotch Whisky Nov 25th 2008

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale Gold
    Nose
    Oak, Lemon, Maple, Cherries, Light peat, caramel and Toffee.
    Body
    Light, watery, with a hint of oils.
    Palate
    Citrus, hint of apples, Buttery, very little malt, and slight smoke.
    Finish
    very smoky, and lots of chili spices

    Pleasant, but I'm concerned with how little the taste of malt I'm picking up. I think its because its a blend of mostly grains.

    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label Nov 22nd 2008

    76
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark(ish) honey. wonderful pale golden.
    Nose
    Restrained: Fruit; earth: (hint of) peat. Toffee. Vanilla(ish).
    Body
    Thin(ish) but very nice with it.
    Palate
    Sweet-earthy-spring-automn-British-army-manouvres, Toffee. Faint vanilla.
    Finish
    Slow and mellow. Warming

    Good. Sexy. Probably a good target for single malt snobs, but different animal so different rules. Very (too?) smooth. If it was more expensive would be better appreciated (but I won't complain!)

    Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select

    Woodford Reserve Distiller's Select Nov 20th 2008

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    caramel copper
    Nose
    nectar honey tones, with a deep rich caramel nose.
    Body
    Thick and rich.
    Palate
    creamy full body, caramel nutmeg flavours with a hint of citrus. well balanced between alcohol and taste
    Finish
    Not overpowering, but nice warmth without the burn. Long lasting finish

    True to the way a Kentucky bourbon is meant to taste. the small batch distilling reflects in the charactor of this bourbon. Great!

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay Nov 20th 2008

    73
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    pale gold
    Nose
    intense peaty almost compost, iodine/antiseptic. sea-salt. Nose on this scotch is powerful.
    Body
    light-bodied for a single-malt. young age shows here.
    Palate
    peaty-compost, iodine/antiseptic, dry. Negligible fruit and smoke.
    Finish
    sea-salt, iodine, peaty finish. very very dry.

    peaty, iodine/antiseptic, sea-salt dominates. very little sweetness, scant smokiness. Nose remiscent of Teachers. Worth a try for the adventurers. Ice mellows and enhances sweet and fruit a touch.

    Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky

    Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky Nov 19th 2008

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Reddish amber.
    Nose
    Vanilla, apple, brown sugar.
    Body
    Medium-bodied, smooth and creamy. Doesn't burn.
    Palate
    Sour apple, vanilla, caramel notes coming through, with subtle undertones of molasses.
    Finish
    A warming, tingly finish that doesn't last too long but lingers enough to make me want another sip.

    I prefer Maker's with just a touch of pure, room-temperature water. It's not an extremely complex whiskey, but it is pleasant, drinkable, and very smooth.

    Glengoyne 17 Years Old

    Glengoyne 17 Years Old Nov 19th 2008

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    maraschino cherries, pear, cedar wood
    Body
    voluptuous
    Palate
    smoky vanilla, hint of banana and raisins.
    Finish
    long lasting leathery finish
    Cragganmore 12 Years Old

    Cragganmore 12 Years Old Nov 12th 2008

    68
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    A honey brown.
    Nose
    Immediate grape or fruit scent followed by a floral garden.
    Body
    A very smooth, almost too-light watery mouthfeel. Not too warming.
    Palate
    Lighter peat and a spice that I can't put my finger on, but overall, it's very light. Something seems to be lacking.
    Finish
    Not as warming as some of the greats, but that's probably because there isn't enough taste to linger.

    I would recommend this one to someone who's just starting out and is still hesitant to try something more full-bodied. It's worth a taste, but I won't be buying it again, even at its lower price.

    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve

    Dewars 12 Years Old Special Reserve Nov 12th 2008

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    light smoke,
    Body
    Watery in body.

    This was TERRIBLE! The worst I have had bar none. Avoid at all costs.

    Yamazaki 18 years old

    Yamazaki 18 Years Old Nov 10th 2008

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden hue, varnished yellowood.
    Nose
    Spring flowers, ginger, caramel, honey, hint of vanilla.
    Body
    Light at first, then rises to the occasion and makes its presence known. Medium textured for a single malt.
    Palate
    A subtle sea breeze ? Balanced peat with some vanilla caramel sweetness. Almonds and a dash of ginger. Buttered toast with honey in the middle of the mouth.
    Finish
    Hint of alcohol coming through at the end. Warm on the tongue, smooth with a slight snap going down. Common with Japanese whisky's - perhaps not as smooth as a highland or Islay 18 y.o. but makes up for it with bountiful flavours and "drink me some more" nuances.

    The Japanese are skilled craftsmen when it comes to single malts. I had to wait years before stumbling on a bottle - quite pricey but well worth the expense. A unique taste - something to spoil your friends with if they enjoy a special dram. You will remember this one for a long time to come - it makes itself known in very pleasant manner. A polite acquaintance.

    Finlaggan Old Reserve

    Finlaggan Old Reserve Nov 4th 2008

    63
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber, slightly pale
    Nose
    Smoky but a sharp petro distillate background, like creosote. Yes, I get the "rubber tires" too.
    Body
    med. full
    Palate
    Tastes better than it smells. Has a bite but not too much. Can't compare to Jamesons or Bushmill for smoothness. No more raw than Knob Creek.
    Finish
    A good long finish.

    I drink Irish & US whiskies mostly. I don't prefer the smoky scotch but I can appreciate it done well. This isn't it. It has a lot of flavor but the aroma is off in a big way.

    Aberlour 10 Year Old

    Aberlour 10 Year Old Oct 14th 2008

    63
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    As it should smell! Syrupy, a hint of vanilla and some oak. Very inviting.
    Body
    Very thin, almost like old water. It feels like it evaporates too quickly or that its some kind of mixed drink. The body seriously dissapoints.
    Palate
    Very good start, with some faint whiff of iodine, then some caramel and lastly the vinalla comes down. Eventually it all fades and really doenst satisfy.
    Finish
    Leaves a numb feeling in the mouth, almost like it has bad alcohol in it, or that it has been added later (not implying anything here). It stays for a long time, but its not a pleasant feeling. It lacks warmth.

    A mediocre single malt, just bought this and when i opened the cardbord cover it was very promising, since it has a dark color and I have had only pleasant memories of the more amber looking whiskies. BUt eventually it dissapoints, it even left a bitter taste in my mouth. Not really what you would excpect from Aberlour. And certainly not from a 10 year old single malt.

    Compass Box The Peat Monster

    Compass Box The Peat Monster Oct 3rd 2008

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    No caramel,non chill-filtered Hoorah!,clear straw
    Nose
    smoke,slight citrus
    Body
    Although I prefer oily malts generally, I find this light bodied and easy-drinking offering quite nice.
    Palate
    smoke,touch of salt,vanilla in background along with hint of citrus tang
    Finish
    Short finish with slightest sour note.

    I find it laughable how Caol Ila rates so highly among testers yet this vatted,which is I believe mostly Caol Ila, gets dubious remarks..Perhaps the vatting with other malt(s) compromises the anticipated instead of marrying successfully? Not a bad intro for beginners to Islay characteristics. REVIEWER FROM CLAREMONT,ONTARIO,CANADA

    Jack Daniel's Gentleman Jack

    Jack Daniel's Gentleman Jack Sep 15th 2008

    76
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    little smoke, little toffe
    Body
    medium to full
    Palate
    spicy, and some kind of vanilla.
    Finish
    the spice is persistent in that strong and warm finish.

    Not a bad whisky, but nothing awsome either. For the price you'll pay, you can find better. Except maybe for the strong-burbon lovers...

    Johnnie Walker Red Label

    Johnnie Walker Red Label Sep 14th 2008

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Fuel
    Nose
    Fuel
    Body
    Watery

    Probably the most overrated drink ever.

    Jack Daniel's Single Barrel

    Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Sep 6th 2008

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    dark
    Nose
    Heavy Smoke
    Body
    Full bodied
    Palate
    Sea salt + honey
    Finish
    strong

    A very good bourbon,miles from the classic J.D.

    Bowmore 12 Year Old

    Bowmore 12 Year Old Aug 26th 2008

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    gold
    Nose
    smoky peat and fruit
    Body
    thick and oily
    Palate
    peaty & salty
    Finish
    long, complex, yet smooth

    You will enjoy this one!

    Talisker 10 Year Old

    Talisker 10 Year Old Aug 25th 2008

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    a peat monster!
    Palate
    sea salt, yet sweet.
    Finish
    a lingering peppery finish

    Best scotch for the price. No matter what I try, it always gets compared to Talisker, a rich, distinctive, and complex whisky. A fantastic, bold drink!

    Midleton Very Rare

    Midleton Very Rare Aug 24th 2008

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale amber
    Nose
    slightly fruity
    Body
    Full bodied
    Palate
    The definition of balance, complexity and smoothness
    Finish
    Lingers long and warm

    My word, if you like your Whiskey, you have got to try this.... again and again.

    Highland Park 12 Years Old

    Highland Park 12 Years Old Aug 4th 2008

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold hue
    Nose
    sweet sherry nose
    Body
    Medium Body
    Palate
    smooth and elegant
    Finish
    nice long finish with accents of honey

    I started with the Glenlivet 15 year old which was good but then found my palate enjoyed the more complex 12 year Macallan. I am enjoying the Highland Park 12 year old just as much as the Macallan.

    Auchentoshan Select

    Auchentoshan Select Jul 9th 2008

    79
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light gold
    Nose
    some orange and lemon, floral, a bit hot
    Body
    light, a bit oily, smooth
    Palate
    vanilla, pear, lightly sweet
    Finish
    warm, sweet, fruity, Some Pears.

    Great Sweet, and my favorite bargain Lowland Whisky. A great buy.

    McClellands Highland

    McClellands Highland Jun 30th 2008

    76
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Ligt to medium golden amber
    Nose
    Very light smoke, heather and faint fruit; we disagreed on what fruit. Peaches? Nectarines?
    Body
    Medium to light in body, a bit warm but not hot in feel. (We used a few drops of filtered water with it)
    Palate
    A wonderful, light whiskey with enough complexity to interest one. Roasted malt and light new wood flavor. Residual hard candy sweetness that went well with the fruity notes and faint smoke / tar.
    Finish
    Moderate lingering finish. Not particularly complex. Some herbal notes, maybe green hay or leaves?

    Another surprisingly good offering for the price. At under $20 US you will absolutely not go wrong with this or the Speyside. Real regional character at blend price.

    McClellands Speyside

    McClellands Speyside Jun 30th 2008

    78
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light golden amber
    Nose
    Honey in the comb, summer flowers, faint maltiness and a hint of citrus
    Body
    Medium in body, not a burly whiskey but quite satisfying, especially given the price point.
    Palate
    Fragrant and even a bit fruity, a summery feel of flowers and heather. Just a bit of caramel malt.
    Finish
    Moderate finish, certainly not up to the best of breed, but quite good for a five year old. Light on the wood but a definite touch of vanilla at the end.

    You will be surprised how good this is at under $20 US a bottle, especially if you taste it blind against almost any ten year old. EXCELLENT value for everyday drinking, even if you save something exceptional on the shelf for guests.

    The Glenlivet Nadurra 16 Year Old (06 2006)

    The Glenlivet Nadurra 16 Year Old (06 2006) Jun 30th 2008

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark Amber

    I like the kick of this wiskey - nice & strong.

    The Six Isles Island Blended Malt Scotch Whisky

    The Six Isles Island Blended Malt Scotch Whisky Jun 26th 2008

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale honey
    Nose
    Musty sweet like damp sack cloth with a hint of iodine.
    Body
    Smooth and fine.
    Palate
    The hefty Orkney asserts itself with a powerful sweet malty smokey taste but still allowing the salt and iodine of the Islay whisky through.
    Finish
    This is a subtle blend which has an initial smooth satin taste on the tongue but is so light it doesn't linger on the palate as long as west coast single malts.

    Deceptively light, and so easy to drink, this one creeps up on you unlike the big hitters.

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Jun 16th 2008

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    wheat field
    Nose
    phenolic but lighter than standard laphroaig
    Body
    smooth and quite heavy in texture, the cask strength giving it considerable length of texture
    Palate
    Reminiscient of beached seaweed. Iodine precariously but perfectly balanced by the high strength alcohol.
    Finish
    a slight warmth in the finish but the phenol and iodine lingers. Very long finish.

    A real classic at a good price point. This is one to keep, if you can resist the temptation. To me Laphroiag is the glorious epitome of character in malts and this is a more refined version of the essential parts of this distillary's output. Of course there are better but not at this price...

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay May 24th 2008

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden
    Nose
    a bit harsh, some peat, a little hay
    Body
    a bit rough
    Palate
    defined peat
    Finish
    hot on the throat

    This is a single malt that is for the budget drinker. I can appreciate a nice Lagavulin every now and then (and even keep some at hand), some Laphroigh a little more often, and a good Talisker as well. However, those can all break the bank in a hurry. This is a good "house malt" if you will... and it also benefit greatly from just a bit of water.

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old

    The Glenlivet 12 Years Old May 20th 2008

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale Amber
    Nose
    Very floral and fruity. I absolutely love the nose on this expression. Pear, apricot, apple. No burn, very sweet, very pleasant to nose. Very light, to almost no peat smell.
    Body
    Medium body, not chewy or thick.
    Palate
    sweet, floral, fruity and grassy. It has very good balance. Not very much distinct "peat" flavor at all. This is a very light and sweet dram, very good for afternoons and dinner.
    Finish
    good long lasting finish. Sweet, sticky and delightful.

    This is my favorite scotch hands down. I'm not a heavy smoky and peaty scotch lover. I like Speyside scotches and this and Glenfiddich happen to be my favorite. This is a great all around, enjoy anytime scotch.

    J & B Rare Blended Scotch Whisky

    J & B Rare Blended Scotch Whisky May 20th 2008

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Straw
    Nose
    light Peat, fruity, grassy.
    Body
    medium body
    Palate
    a little hot and peppery. Light, peaty, lemony, very sweet.
    Finish
    has a good smoky smooth finish that is pretty long. Leaves a good numbness on the tongue and a good sweet stickiness on the finish as well, leaving you wanting to take another pull like any good whiskey should do.

    There are many good scotches on the market. This is one of them. J & B is an old contender and maybe because of that it has lost some popularity, but in my opinion, it's a darn good blend. Especially for the price. It has a pretty good nose, it's pretty smooth and has a good taste about it. It finishes well and it's a good quality liquor. I like to drink my scotch with ice and J & B takes to ice very well, which means that it has some depth and character. It's my everyday scotch.

    Ballantine's Finest

    Ballantine's Finest May 14th 2008

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Straw
    Nose
    Peaty with a light smoke and dull chocolate
    Body
    Full and mellow
    Palate
    Most excellent, well rounded, tongue caressing, a slow burn with a lingering smoky afterburner
    Finish
    warm and fuzzy

    An excellent sipping scotch, in company of women its rated as an industrial strength panty-remover.

    Blanton's The Original Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey

    Blanton's The Original Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey May 5th 2008

    72
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    grass, pepper
    Body
    thick
    Palate
    caramel, grains
    Finish
    pleasant peppery note
    McClellands Lowland

    McClellands Lowland May 1st 2008

    62
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale Amber
    Nose
    Butter, pear, apple
    Body
    Thin
    Palate
    Hot, thin peat , pleasant at first, goes to mediciny after a while.
    Finish
    Hot, long finish, tingly.

    Decent regular drink, when you want to save the better stuff. Very good for the price.

    Bowmore 17 Year Old

    Bowmore 17 Year Old Apr 22nd 2008

    94
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Medium Amber
    Nose
    Peat, cocoa, toffee, very nice.
    Body
    Medium body, smooth like fine chocolate.
    Palate
    More toffee, but darker, medium peat, light apple, light smoke.
    Finish
    smoke gives way to light warmth, toffee and cocoa blend, then become more buttery.

    Wow. Recommended by an Internet acquaintance, and I can't say enough about it. I love the darker tastes of Ardbeg and Talisker, but this whisky HAS to be around at all times.

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay Apr 22nd 2008

    57
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale Amber
    Nose
    Overripe apple, musty peat.
    Body
    Thin, hot, almost peppery. Pungent.
    Palate
    Pepper, slight medicine taste.
    Finish
    Hot, fades quickly to peat, few overtones.

    Not very pleasant. The nose and palate mix poorly, too much contrast. A cheap whisky that tastes like one.

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label

    Johnnie Walker Blue Label Apr 12th 2008

    99
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark amber
    Nose
    Powerful, yet extremely delightful burnt wood smell that sifts through your nose. Fiery, sweet, and very spicily enjoyable smell.
    Body
    Heavy texture, great spicy sweet feeling on and especially around the tongue, numbing the pallet, great to breathe in. Absolute pleasure.
    Palate
    Spicy burnt oak that lingers in your mouth creating an anesthetically pleasing feeling. It reminds me of euphoria, with a mix of nostalgia (finished my bottle in a year's time).
    Finish
    It has the greatest aftertaste of any whiskey I've ever had. Long lasting spicy feeling in mouth, throat-warming feeling, The best is the tongue + pallet-numbing feeling it gives you. Lasts so long...

    Buy this if you have the money.

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old

    Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old Mar 18th 2008

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    burnt raisins, smoke, rich fruit
    Body
    chewy , smooth and silky.
    Palate
    raisins again, fruit, very chewy, medium smoke, perfect balance.
    Finish
    long with some bite of peat and fruit.

    This is the best blend money can buy. Brilliant balance of so many layers.

    The Balvenie Single Barrel 15 Year Old

    The Balvenie Single Barrel 15 Year Old Mar 8th 2008

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light honey
    Nose
    warm honey and vanilla, moss
    Body
    warm, full bodied
    Palate
    honey, toast, earth and vanilla
    Finish
    medium finish, warming to the end

    excellent 15 year old scotch, this paticular one was aged 17 years according to the notes on the bottle. quite the difference when adding water as opposed to serving neat. water opens it up quite a bit, but i would suggest serving it neat to get a comparison. great addition to the range.

    McClellands Highland

    McClellands Highland Mar 2nd 2008

    75
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    sweet, honey
    Body
    silky,light
    Palate
    mild peaty, honey, sweet
    Finish
    short, not lingering, slightly musty and tangy

    Its a very pleasnt whisky which is very nice for a sip or two in front of the fire on a snowy Sunday afternoon.

    Midleton Very Rare

    Midleton Very Rare Feb 13th 2008

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber
    Nose
    Earthy with a smooth finish.

    Overall, an outstanding beverage, smooth in approach, subtle in its flavors, a symphony of flavors dancing across the palate, each one begging attention. It will leave you smiling. Well worth sampling.

    Midleton Very Rare

    Midleton Very Rare Feb 13th 2008

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Light amber
    Nose
    Earthy with a smooth finish.

    Overall, an outstanding beverage, smooth in approach, subtle in its flavors, will leave you smiling. Woell worth sampling.

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Feb 13th 2008

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber gold
    Nose
    Peat, sea salt, bit of iodine, finish off with sweet.
    Body
    wet full strong
    Palate
    So many complex flavors, you need to sample a few times to enjoy them all.
    Finish
    long lasting taste that starts off powerful and slowly drifts into sweet. after about 10mins you can still taste the sea.

    Man i love this Whisky. Laphroaig with so much flavor!

    Glenmorangie 15 Years Old Sauternes Wood Finish

    Glenmorangie 15 Years Old Sauternes Wood Finish Feb 12th 2008

    93
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Initially amber, then when mixed with ice and when the water mixes with the non-chill filtered concoction, it just becomes a light honey colour
    Nose
    It smells like maple syrup, very sweet aroma
    Body
    It is heavy, with a syrupy texture, well balanced whisky which doesn't bite.
    Palate
    A very slight hint of peat, with a large gush of honey explosion inter-twined with subtle hints of smoke.....and then a release of sweet cedar aromas in your mouth
    Finish
    Fantastic lasting finish, that leaves a smoky peaty finish at the back of the tongue. The sweetness lingers on the edges of the back edges of your tongue.

    It has the aromas of the balvenie, the colour of the macallan, the subtlety of the bunnahabhain, the finish of the auchentoshan, the taste of the aberlour.....taking only the best bits, a well balanced whisky, a winner. One for companionship, and to share with your best mates.

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old

    Laphroaig 10 Year Old Feb 7th 2008

    88
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    golden amber
    Nose
    Heavy peat.
    Body
    Medium-bodied.
    Palate
    Peat. Peat. Peat.
    Finish
    A nice long, enjoyable phenolic phinish!

    Search the archives of "The Atlantic Monthly" for a very nice article by Corby Kummer some years ago. He went through the distilleries of Islay, and described the Laphoaig 10-year very nicely.

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay Feb 7th 2008

    68
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light amber
    Nose
    peat
    Body
    light and smoky
    Palate
    not overwhelming peat, but good
    Finish
    a nice,mild finish

    I think this is a fine, every day single malt whiskey. I simply can't afford to drink Laphroaig or Lagavulin all the time, at $70+ a bottle. However, I can enjoy McClellands at $24 a bottle locally. You make some concessions, but you still have a nice, Bowmore-style Islay single-malt to drink.

    Red Breast 12 Year Old

    Red Breast 12 Year Old Jan 19th 2008

    91
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Gold
    Nose
    Full and fruity
    Body
    Warm and intense
    Finish
    Hot

    Excellent

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask

    Laphroaig Quarter Cask Dec 11th 2007

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Amber
    Nose
    Smoke, peat, salt, iodine
    Body
    Strong, full
    Palate
    Strong peat, smoke, slight sweetness
    Finish
    Smokey burn sums it up

    This is whisky that will fight you and WIN. Not for the casual whisk(e)y sampler, Laphroaig is definitely for the mature palate. Once you've lost a few rounds to it though, you begin to appreciate the complex flavous more.

    Tullamore Dew The Legendary Irish Whiskey

    Tullamore Dew The Legendary Irish Whiskey Dec 11th 2007

    85
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    slightly sweet with a hint of grain
    Body
    medium
    Palate
    creme, vanilla, malt
    Finish
    warm, lingering

    Also my favorite Irish Whiskey. Distinctive taste, very smooth, and a bargain at the store.

    Tullamore Dew The Legendary Irish Whiskey

    Tullamore Dew The Legendary Irish Whiskey Dec 7th 2007

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale amber
    Nose
    light sweet malt
    Body
    medium heavy, but smooth
    Palate
    nice mix of grain/malt with a touch of sweetness, no peat, smoke, or sea, very nice
    Finish
    medium finish, a touch of sweetness at the end

    This is good stuff, clean and light with a nice malt/grain mix, my favorite under 20.00 Irish whiskey

    The Macallan Cask Strength

    The Macallan Cask Strength Nov 27th 2007

    79
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Dark red amber
    Nose
    Sweet cherries, hints of pear.
    Body
    Thin and fiery.
    Palate
    Strong oak sherry, alcohol, hints of rubber.
    Finish
    Longish oak laden finish, very hot.

    Red label version. A very fiesty and strong whisky with an excellent nose and thoroughly enjoyable finish but a lackluster palate.

    McClellands Islay

    McClellands Islay Nov 25th 2007

    55
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light gold
    Nose
    Heavy smoke, bit of vanilla
    Body
    thick, heavy,
    Palate
    iodine
    Finish
    Very aggressive at first, then hot, but fading quickly

    Very immature whiskey. Though cheap, it's not worth the money.

    Knob Creek

    Knob Creek Nov 17th 2007

    68
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    caramel
    Nose
    caramel, earthy
    Body
    thin
    Palate
    sweet, peppery
    Finish
    sweet and caramel gives way to a pepper / spice burn - short lived

    I like it better than Jack. It almost reminds me of a grown up southern comfort - not sure that's what was intended.

    Isle Of Jura 10 Year Old

    Isle Of Jura 10 Year Old Oct 28th 2007

    72
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    leather, dark chocolate, ripe cherrys
    Body
    light and airy
    Palate
    luscious herby sea air with a hint of honey
    Finish
    short, sweet finish

    A nice undemanding dram with subtle flavour and gentle warmth.

    Glenkinchie 10 Years Old

    Glenkinchie 10 Years Old Oct 22nd 2007

    80
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Pale Amber
    Nose
    Light smoke, wheat.
    Body
    Full, not thick though.
    Palate
    Malt syrup, roasted nuts. Subtle flavors revealed when rolling the whisky in your mouth.
    Finish
    Warm but not searing.

    This is a wonderful whisky. I know that some drink this as an apertif and that is a good choice. It can finish dinner too, if nothing too aggressive was consumed first. A better idea is to drink it with dinner.

    Bushmills Malt 16 Year Old

    Bushmills Malt 16 Year Old Sep 23rd 2007

    90
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    amber
    Nose
    vanilla,sherry,summer
    Body
    very smooth
    Palate
    smooth blend of flavor
    Finish
    the finish is of medium length,but very satisfying

    I would have this all the time if possible.Very good whiskey,very drinkable and satisfying.

    Compass Box The Peat Monster

    Compass Box The Peat Monster Sep 12th 2007

    50
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    light amber
    Nose
    slightly earthy
    Body
    medium
    Palate
    mediocre taste
    Finish
    short finish,disappointing

    For being advertised as a Peat Monster,this is certainly disappointing in that catagory.If you want strong peatiness,go with Lagavulin or Laphroaig.This pale in comparison

    McClellands Highland

    McClellands Highland Aug 28th 2007

    70
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Wheat like gold
    Nose
    Light smoke, earth, black pepper
    Body
    Thin and light
    Palate
    Pepper, woody, not much peat
    Finish
    short, warm but not overpowering

    I bought this for $16 and it was a great buy for that price. It lacks depth and the heavy characteristics you might be used to in Scotch, but it is not bad.

    Bushmills Black Bush

    Bushmills Black Bush Aug 25th 2007

    98
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Tawny Gold
    Nose
    A bit of chocolate and butterscotch. Not a lot, just enough to get your interest.
    Body
    This is a smooth, even whisky, Has a little weight, enough to let you know you are dealing with significant quality.
    Palate
    A touch of sweet, a bit of butter, a mellow feel to the tongue.
    Finish
    Holds its own with a mellow warm afternote.

    This is an excellent whisky for reading, contemplating, solving world problems, or just relaxing after having solved world problems. This is the one I serve important people.

    Bushmills Black Bush

    Bushmills Black Bush Jul 16th 2007

    92
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    Golden
    Nose
    A little oaky, and a hint of sweet sherry
    Body
    Medium body,Good whiskey feel
    Palate
    Oak, spice and a little buttery, nice balance
    Finish
    Long, spicy with some oak and and a touch of toffee

    I've tasted a lot of Irish and this is one of my favorites

    Compass Box The Peat Monster

    Compass Box The Peat Monster Jan 22nd 2007

    72
    Reviewer
    Anonymous
    Color
    very light
    Nose
    peaty antiseptic
    Body
    thin and smooth, very sweet
    Palate
    face first dive in a peat bog
    Finish
    warm and long, very little bite

    ill simply say that id buy this bottle again