At For Peat' Sake you are the whiskey expert. All of our whiskey reviews have been submitted by whiskey drinkers like you who want to help others by sharing their experiences. We encourage you to help us grow by signing up and reviewing the whiskey you drink.
Superstition Reviews
- Distillery
- Isle Of Jura
- Style
- Single Malt
- Release
- Unspecified
- Age
- Unspecified
- Alcohol
- 43% abv.
- Region
- Scotland, Island
- Bottled For
- Distillery
- Buy Now $46.97 WineChateau.com
- see all offers
The people of Jura are superstitious. From the prophecy of the one-eyed Campbell to an aversion to cutting peat before May, age-old island beliefs resonate to this day.
Superstition
Review by ColoradoDram
- Color
- Tobacco amber.
- Nose
- Tobacco, wet hay/grass, toffee.
- Body
- Medium bodied. Water makes more silky/oily and chewy.
- Palate
- Tobacco, minty-camphor. wet leather, ever-so-slight sherried-toffee-grass.
- Finish
- A beautifully dry sip of tobacco oil without the cough. Water adds some peppercorn spice and heat and length without any increase in acidity. More youthful attack when tasted neat. What a great mix of contrasts - how much is young and how much is mature?
I'm on my second bottle of this confoundingly unique and great 'old' and 'new' expression from an island distillery. I suggest 4 drops of water to the dram from the outset and then nose and taste (and chew?) your way through this one with a good cigar or a nearby lighted chimney.
Superstition
Review by J
At first I thought this was a great whisky, however I found that it leaves a not particularly pleasant after taste. (the kind you get in the morning after a heavy night out) Jura 10year old on the other hand was very good with no aftertaste.
Superstition
Review by Draces1
- Color
- Old Gold
- Nose
- Bit of smoke, bit of maritime, bit of orange zest.
- Body
- Full, complex and smooth - exceptionally complex - a little chewey/oily.
- Palate
- Chocolate covered orange, buttered popcorn, smooth and sweet.
- Finish
- Bite at the end, finish is long, this Scotch does leave an aftertaste - goes great with a Cigar.
A fantastic Whisky - I would drink it every day if I could. It is hard to obtain in my area. It's complex so it may be tough for some to enjoy. Do not judge it by your first dram.
Superstition
Review by BigJuanny
- Color
- Dark sherry tinged amber
- Nose
- Medium smoke and slightly sweet-almost a peaty Crown Royal
- Body
- Tried a few drams with a friend. Some with a few drops and others neat. Finished most of the bottle and every dram tasted different. Even 2 drams neat one ater the other tasted different. Some were smooth and peaty with a clean finish ohters were harsh and a bitter finish. Very odd experience.
- Palate
- smoke mixed with sweet slight spice tatses. Very drinkable. Went and bought another for the library.
- Finish
- With water-finished smooth and sweet. Straight finished harsh and bitter. Didn't linger long either way. No smoke 'burps' later.
Complex and Frustrating
Superstition
Review by Aussie Malt
- Color
- Dark orange
- Nose
- Slight sweet smoke, the zest of an orange lingers in the air as grandma makes maramalade.
- Body
- Oily and chewy
- Palate
- Too much orange and chocolate (that of a jaffa), slightly too sweet... like the end of a bag of jaffas you've eaten all in one sitting
- Finish
- Long, unfortunately.
If you like jaffas (an orange flavoured chocolate candy) then you'll like this... toherwise far too sweet and full of orange zest.
Superstition
Review by Julianne
- Color
- Amber, dark honey.
- Nose
- Salty, a bit peaty.
- Body
- Quite full.
- Palate
- Mostly salt, a bit less of peat and earth.
- Finish
- Still pleasantly salty.
Very pleasant salty whisky.